Dealer Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
Sheehan Cadillac
Pompano Beach, FL
596 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Service Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
Showing 596 reviews
March 10, 2026
DANGER! Deceptive Practices! Buyer be extremely carful. I purchased two vehicles from Sheehan Cadillac after spending nearly four hours at the dealership wo Deceptive Practices! Buyer be extremely carful. I purchased two vehicles from Sheehan Cadillac after spending nearly four hours at the dealership working through the sales process. Only after investing that amount of time and moving toward finalizing the purchase was I informed that I was REQUIRED to purchase an additional $5,000 dealer package in order to complete the transaction. This package was not presented upfront and was communicated as a condition of sale rather than an optional product. At that stage of the process, after several hours at the dealership, I felt completely cornered into accepting something I never asked for simply to finish the purchase. For clarity, my sales representative Justin was professional and respectful throughout the process. The situation changed once the General Manager Mark became involved. The interaction was dismissive and unprofessional, and it turned what should have been an exciting purchase into a very uncomfortable experience. He was even rude and disgusting in front of my 8 year-old son who asked me why i let a person speak to me that way. Consumers should be extremely cautious and confirm all dealer add-ons before beginning the purchasing process. Introducing mandatory packages late in the transaction after customers have invested hours at the dealership creates a pressured environment that undermines transparency and is 100% deceptive in nature. If you have had the same experience i highly recommend not only sharing what was done with you so others are able to find another dealer but also file compilates with all the appropriate parties. More
by bhorowitz0
Employees Worked With
Justin Klindt, Mark Gerke, Scott Zislen
March 02, 2026
I recently purchased a used CT5 Cadillac and was very satisfied with the professional help I received from your excellent sales person, Rene Ruiz. He made the entire experience a pleasant and easy one. T satisfied with the professional help I received from your excellent sales person, Rene Ruiz. He made the entire experience a pleasant and easy one. Thank you. Donald Motta More
by Ruth Dry
Employees Worked With
Rene Ruiz
December 29, 2025
Simple The Best ! Showroom, sales lot and all staff were of the highest standards. Sales person Tonya Smith was great. Showed knowledge of all questions and details Showroom, sales lot and all staff were of the highest standards. Sales person Tonya Smith was great. Showed knowledge of all questions and details of the automobiles that we looked at. I entered the sales lot just to look around at pre-owned CT 5s and wound up purchasing a 2026 CT5-V. The deal that Tonya got for me was so good that I could not walk away from it. My trade in allowance was most fair. I drove home 1 hour after entering the lot with my Beautiful 2026 CT5-V. The entire staff including the owner, Tom Sheehan was the most friendly and helpful of any dealership that I have ever been involved with purchasing a new automobile. Sheehan is Believing. . . More
by chew4play
Employees Worked With
Tonya Smith. Tom Sheehan. , Mark Gerke, Alex Campos
December 10, 2025
From the moment I arrived to browse until the deal was closed (about 4hrs total), I felt welcomed and the experience was enjoyably seamless. Mr. Sheehan, Scott & Mark were helpful & knowledgeable and the closed (about 4hrs total), I felt welcomed and the experience was enjoyably seamless. Mr. Sheehan, Scott & Mark were helpful & knowledgeable and the new vehicle checked all my boxes (year, make, model, price). Don’t hesitate to visit for quality automobiles & service. More
by JPMIRANDA
Employees Worked With
Scott and Mark
October 14, 2025
Horrible service department. Very unprofessional and rude. They overbill for everything. Travel 8 miles SOUTH TO BAYVIEW CADILLAC you won’t regret it. Very unprofessional and rude. They overbill for everything. Travel 8 miles SOUTH TO BAYVIEW CADILLAC you won’t regret it. More
by g1paintman
Employees Worked With
James Reardon, Steve Auger
August 26, 2025
I recently purchased a 2025 Escalade Sport Platinum and had an outstanding experience working with Scott Lynton. He was extremely knowledgeable and experienced which made the entire process smooth and stre had an outstanding experience working with Scott Lynton. He was extremely knowledgeable and experienced which made the entire process smooth and stress-free. He was excellent at follow up and true to his word. From start to finish he delivered everything he promised and made sure every detail was taken care of. I couldn’t have asked for a better buying experience. And I love the car! More
by tg8198
Employees Worked With
Scott Lynton
August 06, 2025
My XT5 had an AC malfunction. The extended warranty company was reluctant to pay for a replacement. Danny Asherman convinced them to pay. His courteous and professional attitude i The extended warranty company was reluctant to pay for a replacement. Danny Asherman convinced them to pay. His courteous and professional attitude is to be commended. More
by Harry Atkins
Employees Worked With
Danny Asherman
July 27, 2025
Bought our XT5 from Sheehan Cadillac and it’s the only place to have it serviced. Thanks to Jim Reardon, he has always taken care of us and made our service visits a pleasure. Jim is a true professional. place to have it serviced. Thanks to Jim Reardon, he has always taken care of us and made our service visits a pleasure. Jim is a true professional. More
by Mike Z
Employees Worked With
James Reardon
