4 Reviews of Colin Sherrer
June 16, 2025
One of the best car buying experiences I have ever had. My wife found the perfect used vehicle online and called to check availability, pricing and trade values. Worked with Colin, the General Manager, and My wife found the perfect used vehicle online and called to check availability, pricing and trade values. Worked with Colin, the General Manager, and he put together an amazing deal and had everything ready for me when I arrived. No surprise fees and the car was in excellent shape, beautifully detailed and filled with gas. Both the salesperson and the finance manager made it a super easy and pleasant experience. Super easy and straightforward from start to finish. Drove almost 2 hours each way for this vehicle and it was totally worth it. Highly recommend these guys at Sarasota Toyota!!! More
January 15, 2022
Nice folks, great car, great price. It was a quick and easy experience. I got exactly what I wanted, and they were wonderful to do business with. I will return for all of my family’s cars in the future easy experience. I got exactly what I wanted, and they were wonderful to do business with. I will return for all of my family’s cars in the future More
October 10, 2021
Unscrupulous, stay away. Will and does take advantage of inexperience and unknowing customers. Sales tactics bordering aggressive, with mistruths. GMs are responsible for sales guys and should be fired. inexperience and unknowing customers. Sales tactics bordering aggressive, with mistruths. GMs are responsible for sales guys and should be fired. Will tell everyone I know to stay away and read BBB reviews. Had to buy the car due to Nonrefundable deposit put down by inexperienced kid. Celio in finance was clearly trained properly by the Finance Manager and deserves to be associated with a reputable dealership, not this one. More
Other Employees Tagged: Billy Sparks

