24 Reviews
Write a Review24 Reviews of Erin Henry
March 13, 2026
From sales to financing everything was Top Notch. Thank you for such a wonderful, easy experience. Thank you for such a wonderful, easy experience. More
Other Employees Tagged: Juan Muro, Chad Reiss
March 06, 2026
This was the best dealership experience I have ever had. No games, no pressure, just a great lady finding us what we were looking for. Finance was very easy and timely. I will definitely go back and refer o No games, no pressure, just a great lady finding us what we were looking for. Finance was very easy and timely. I will definitely go back and refer others. More
Other Employees Tagged: Juan Muro, Chad Reiss
February 17, 2026
Erin Henry (sales) was fantastic to work with. She was friendly, straightforward, and just what I needed. Working with the finance department was smooth and quick. Anthony (parts? service?), the y She was friendly, straightforward, and just what I needed. Working with the finance department was smooth and quick. Anthony (parts? service?), the young man who picked me up at my home for a 45 minute drive to pick up my car was great company and a great representation of who I think Toyota wants to be. More
Other Employees Tagged: Chad Reiss , Anthony
January 24, 2026
Good experience over all,friendly helpful knowledgeable, worked hard to make the process go as fast as they could. worked hard to make the process go as fast as they could. More
Other Employees Tagged: Brad Ambrozevitch, Chad Reiss
December 22, 2025
Erin was fantastic to work with during my car purchase. Her communication was clear, timely, and consistent from start to finish, which made the entire process smooth and stress free. She took the time to Her communication was clear, timely, and consistent from start to finish, which made the entire process smooth and stress free. She took the time to answer my questions, kept me updated at every step, and made sure everything was handled professionally. I truly appreciated her attention to detail and support, and I would absolutely recommend working with Erin to anyone looking to buy a vehicle. More
Other Employees Tagged: Juan Muro, Thomas Burback, Chad Reiss, Abigail Madrigal
December 22, 2025
Erin was terrific. She was very patient with us showing us several cars and providing very detailed comparisons between them. She was awesome to work with. She was very patient with us showing us several cars and providing very detailed comparisons between them. She was awesome to work with. More
Other Employees Tagged: Chad Reiss
December 03, 2025
The adding of of the $800. 00 dealership fee to Carfax price is xx. They did min to prepare car to be sold. No trust in this dealership. Erin did NOTHING to enhance the buyin 00 dealership fee to Carfax price is xx. They did min to prepare car to be sold. No trust in this dealership. Erin did NOTHING to enhance the buying experience. Nothing was setup on my Camry. Nothing was explained in detail. Total different experience than Peterson Toyota in Fort Collins! If Peterson Toyota had a used Camary in stock, I would have gone there! More
Other Employees Tagged: Juan Muro
November 26, 2025
I switched from a suv to a car and Erin made it a great experience. I didn’t think I’d be able to trade it in suv but she was able to get it done. Thanks to Chad in finance also. experience. I didn’t think I’d be able to trade it in suv but she was able to get it done. Thanks to Chad in finance also. More
Other Employees Tagged: Chad Reiss
November 24, 2025
I strongly advise anyone considering McDonald Toyota in Greeley to look elsewhere. The customer service has been consistently unacceptable. When issues arise, there is no support. Calls go unanswered, mess Greeley to look elsewhere. The customer service has been consistently unacceptable. When issues arise, there is no support. Calls go unanswered, messages are not returned, and any form of follow up is nonexistent. The lack of communication alone makes the entire process far more stressful than it should ever be. Their titling process has been the worst I have experienced with any dealership. When you call to ask about the status of your titling documents, the only response you receive from their onsite finance department is that nothing is wrong with the documents and that they can send you another temporary plate because their off site titling department is behind. While most dealerships in Colorado complete titling in under 60 days, McDonald Toyota appears to be on a 90 to 120 day timeline. That is completely unacceptable, especially for customers from out of state who expect to register their vehicles in a timely manner. The situation is even more frustrating because they insist the documents are fine, yet offer no meaningful explanation, accountability, or solution beyond more waiting. My interactions with their sales staff only added to the frustration. Erin was consistently immature, rarely followed through on the things she said she would do, and left us with more questions than answers. Even worse, Brad and Scott repeatedly excused her behavior instead of addressing it or stepping in to provide real assistance. The lack of professionalism across their team is noticeable and deeply disappointing. The finance department provided even less support, contributing to what has been one of the most frustrating dealership experiences my partner and I have ever had. I genuinely regret encouraging him to purchase his 4Runner here. We could have gone anywhere else and avoided all of these unnecessary issues. Based on our experience, I cannot recommend McDonald Toyota in Greeley under any circumstances. More
September 05, 2025
Great experience purchasing our new Toyota. The financing portion was easy and I felt good about all the details. Erin was great to work with, and so was Luis, and Chad has been great too! The financing portion was easy and I felt good about all the details. Erin was great to work with, and so was Luis, and Chad has been great too! More
Other Employees Tagged: Juan Muro, Chad Reiss, Luis D. Noriega
Dealership Inventory (131 Vehicles)

