Dealer Reviews
Service Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
Atlantic Kia
West Islip, NY
741 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Service Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
741 Reviews of Atlantic Kia
July 27, 2025
The sales department lodge is spacious and comfortable, providing a pleasant and professional environment for my purchase and trade-in. The staff is polite, energetic, and attentive to detail, leaving no s providing a pleasant and professional environment for my purchase and trade-in. The staff is polite, energetic, and attentive to detail, leaving no stone unturned to ensure a smooth process. More
by GNGL
Verified CustomerEmployees Worked With
Alexander Ortiz
July 27, 2025
Andrew Vickers was awesome! !! We lost our 2023 Sportage in an accident and we’re looking to replace it. Luckily Atlantic Kia had one and Brian (the manager) and Andrew made gett !! We lost our 2023 Sportage in an accident and we’re looking to replace it. Luckily Atlantic Kia had one and Brian (the manager) and Andrew made getting into the new one very easy. I would recommend Kia and especially Atlantic Kia if you’re looking for a great car and a great place to buy a new car! More
by theoldstoneman
Employees Worked With
Brian Okeefe, Andrew Vickers, Artur Atanov
July 25, 2025
like dealing with the salesman also the sales manager and the credit manager all went well. left not feeling being taking advantage of would recommend them again. the credit manager all went well. left not feeling being taking advantage of would recommend them again. More
by Pbrabant103
Employees Worked With
Sandra Dellolio, Brian Okeefe, Andrew Vickers, Alexander Ortiz, Artur Atanov, Jordan Confino, Kamran Sheikh, Moise Volcy
July 24, 2025
Alexander Ortiz was great! Really appreciated they way he helped us through the entire process of leasing a new Telluride. The finance person was also excellent and straight fo Really appreciated they way he helped us through the entire process of leasing a new Telluride. The finance person was also excellent and straight forward. I will recommend Atlantic Kia to anyone looking for and honest experience and great customer service! More
by milamadisonnigro
Employees Worked With
Alexander Ortiz
July 13, 2025
Doesn’t even deserve 1 star! Total Jerk, most incompetent Manager EVER! Should be fired for how he treats customers trying to return a leased vehicle WITH an appointment. Stay aw Total Jerk, most incompetent Manager EVER! Should be fired for how he treats customers trying to return a leased vehicle WITH an appointment. Stay away from this dealership. Management to service, they don’t care about you, the customer, just about making a sale. Have never been treated so poorly by a dealership, The most ridiculous part was and the salesman asks if we’d like to lease another vehicle. OMG, there are no words, JUST DISGUSTING. Good luck to others who deal with the shabby location, hope your experience is better. 🙏🏻 More
by juniebear
Employees Worked With
Brian Okeefe, Andrew Vickers
July 02, 2025
From start to finish was a very good experience at Atlantic Kia. Eddie the car dealer was the nicest and most helpful dealer that I have ever dealt with. I will definitely be back for another car I. A Atlantic Kia. Eddie the car dealer was the nicest and most helpful dealer that I have ever dealt with. I will definitely be back for another car I. A few years! More
by CCORDARO2
Employees Worked With
Eddie the car dealer exceptional , Alexander Ortiz, Jordan Confino
