Dealer Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
Atlantic Kia
West Islip, NY
747 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Service Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
747 Reviews of Atlantic Kia
May 29, 2025
We had a great experience with Sean. I had spent 2 previous days at dealers closer to my home and the service Sean provided was by far superior in every way compared to the others. Despi I had spent 2 previous days at dealers closer to my home and the service Sean provided was by far superior in every way compared to the others. Despite leaving deposits at both Smithown and Gerneration I drove home in a new car after meeting with Sean. His professionalism was noted from the moment we walked in. Anthony in finance was just as great. I will certainly recommend Sean and will definitely purchase from him again. More
by KBDIMEGLIO
Verified CustomerEmployees Worked With
Sean Johar and Anthony in finance
May 28, 2025
So so happy with my new Kia forte 2022 lxs, as soon as I came in I met Eddie (absolutely great salesman) he helped with every single thing, every question and was so accommodating with my circumstances on w came in I met Eddie (absolutely great salesman) he helped with every single thing, every question and was so accommodating with my circumstances on what car I wanted and what I had to give for it. Thank you so so much Eddie I am ecstatic with the car and your help!!!!!!! You’re awesome, give this man a raise for real haha!!!! More
by Isabella
Employees Worked With
Eddie
May 26, 2025
If I could give zero stars, I would. After confirming multiple times—by phone, text, and email—I drove two hours from Connecticut for an appointment with Andrew, who assured me the car After confirming multiple times—by phone, text, and email—I drove two hours from Connecticut for an appointment with Andrew, who assured me the car was available. Turns out, that was a flat-out lie. I was passed between three different people, each with a different story about the car. Complete waste of my time. To make it worse, he took my license, stuck it in his pocket, and completely forgot to give it back until I asked. No explanation, no apology—just weird and unprofessional. Save yourself the drive and the headache. Go literally anywhere else. More
by Liz
Employees Worked With
Andrew Vickers
May 24, 2025
We had a very positive experience working with Nick Tumminello. He did his best to accommodate us with all our needs to find the car we wanted. He was always knowledgeable, patient , kind and courteous Tumminello. He did his best to accommodate us with all our needs to find the car we wanted. He was always knowledgeable, patient , kind and courteous. It was a pleasure working with him. We also had a pleasant experience with the finance manager. I would definitely recommend Nick (5 stars) and this dealership to anyone in the market for a car. More
by NADINE.WOOD907
Employees Worked With
Brian Okeefe
May 23, 2025
My experience at Atlantic Key was amazing! My salesman Matt was honest and extremely helpful throughout the process. I would definitely refer my friends and family! My salesman Matt was honest and extremely helpful throughout the process. I would definitely refer my friends and family! More
by johnjennjack
Employees Worked With
Matthew Hughes
May 18, 2025
Second vehicle we have leased from Atlantic Kia. The sales person Sean was great to work with yesterday hard working and honest. I went in to have my wife’s Kia Telluride serviced and ended up t The sales person Sean was great to work with yesterday hard working and honest. I went in to have my wife’s Kia Telluride serviced and ended up trading in my Honda and leaving with a 2025 k5 More
by ALICEADENNIS
Employees Worked With
Sean (6 stars)
