Dealer Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
CarMax Madison
Madison, WI
8 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
Showing 8 reviews
October 27, 2025
Kind and helpful people. Honor was a pleasure to work with and very fun. Management here is knowledgeable and reassuring, helping me know that buying from them will assure me Honor was a pleasure to work with and very fun. Management here is knowledgeable and reassuring, helping me know that buying from them will assure me I get a good deal. More
by domingo1997wilson
Employees Worked With
Honor
October 05, 2025
We walked in and were immediately greeted with smiles. Sam was helping us and his energy was amazing! Super nice and fun. He was amazing with our 4 month old baby! He answered all of our questions and was Sam was helping us and his energy was amazing! Super nice and fun. He was amazing with our 4 month old baby! He answered all of our questions and was on top of everything! More
by Bethbignell94
Employees Worked With
Sam Milner
September 28, 2025
I could not ask for more. The sales did everything needed to deliver my vehicle in a timely manner. All the people I encountered in this dealership went above and beyond to de The sales did everything needed to deliver my vehicle in a timely manner. All the people I encountered in this dealership went above and beyond to deliver my vehicle. The vehicle I purchased was in immaculate condition. I needed a fob, and that delivered in a timely manner. My wife and I have told several friends getting ready to search for a vehicle about our experience in detail, regardless of which member of the sales team we talked with, it was totally seamless and flawless transition. They are to be commended for excellence in execution. My wife and I are totally satisfied with the process and if another is required in the future, Carmax shall be our first stop. More
by awcsjhahn
Employees Worked With
Chris Rauch, Pete Rieck, David Marti
September 16, 2025
The experience I had starting in Denver when my car broke down honestly made me want to never do business again with Carmax. But thanks to the Madison store and specifically with Alexis has completely revive down honestly made me want to never do business again with Carmax. But thanks to the Madison store and specifically with Alexis has completely revived my support of Carmax. I cannot begin to say how thankful I am for all the phenomenal support she and the whole store gave me More
by Steven86severino
Employees Worked With
Alexis, Dave, Jeremy
September 07, 2025
We got a great taste in for our previous car, and they were very helpful with getting me in something more suited for my needs! I also loved the sales lady we worked with. were very helpful with getting me in something more suited for my needs! I also loved the sales lady we worked with. More
by randalltink
Employees Worked With
Alexis
