Back

Paul Miller Honda of West Caldwell

West Caldwell, NJ

4.5
1,098 Reviews

1170 Bloomfield Avenue

West Caldwell, NJ

07006

Directions

By Type

1,098 Reviews of Paul Miller Honda of West Caldwell

September 06, 2026

My salesperson was incredibly knowledgeable, helpful, and had a great attitude. Highly recommend him , A+ More

by 1Customer
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Mr Gabriel , Jean Jacques
Sep 08, 2026 -

Paul Miller Honda of West Caldwell responded

We're happy to hear about your positive experience with our team! Thanks for choosing Paul Miller Honda and for sharing your feedback. Safe travels ahead!

September 05, 2026

I am extremely disappointed with the way I was treated by this dealership during what should have been a simple oil change. When I purchased my car, I was entitled to two complimentary oil changes. When I More

by nicolecornacchia
Service Price Transparency
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Recommend Dealer
No
Employees Worked With
Nick
Sep 08, 2026 -

Paul Miller Honda of West Caldwell responded

Sorry you feel that way. My response in Carfax was factual.

Sep 08, 2026 -

nicolecornacchia responded

Nick, I understand that you believe what you said was factual. However, there are several specific facts that were either incorrect, misleading, or contradicted by what I was actually told and what was later confirmed. Let’s be clear about what happened: • I was told by your salesman that I was entitled to two complimentary oil changes. • I was told that the person I was communicating with through your dealership’s online chat was a robot. I contacted the online chat again and was specifically informed that I was speaking with a real person, not a robot. That same representative also confirmed that I was entitled to the two complimentary oil changes. • I should not have had to go through multiple employees and then independently verify your dealership’s own policy through your online system just to determine whether I was entitled to a benefit that came with my purchase. • You also described the oil change as a “courtesy” because it was free, while simultaneously acknowledging that you did not know the circumstances surrounding what happened. If you did not know the circumstances, then you could not have possibly had all of the facts necessary to make an accurate statement about my experience. So when you say your response was “factual,” I would genuinely like to know which part you are referring to. Is it factual that I was initially told I was not entitled to the oil changes? Yes. Is it factual that a salesman later confirmed that I was entitled to them? Yes. Is it factual that I was told the person on your online chat was a robot? Yes. Is it factual that I later confirmed that the online representative was actually a real person? Yes. Is it factual that the online representative confirmed I was entitled to the two oil changes? Yes. Is it factual that you admitted you did not know the circumstances of what happened before responding to my complaint? Yes. Those are the facts I am talking about. The issue isn’t that I “felt” like I was treated poorly. I was given conflicting information by multiple employees, had to repeatedly advocate for myself, and ultimately had to verify the dealership’s own policy independently. Then, when I raised the issue, instead of taking the time to fully investigate it, the General Manager responded publicly and doubled down. That is the issue. I am not asking for an apology because I “felt a certain way.” I am asking for accountability and accuracy. If you believe my account is factually incorrect, then please explain specifically which statement is false and provide the documentation supporting your version of events. Because from my perspective, the facts are very clear, and I have no problem continuing to explain exactly what happened and why I believe this dealership handled the entire situation unprofessionally. This is no longer about a free oil change. It is about how customers are treated, the contradictory information they are given, and what happens when they question it.

September 05, 2026

Nice place and staff. We were greeted immediately and they made the car buying process stress less and comfortable. Much appreciated! More

by Carl
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Jose M. Velasquez
Sep 08, 2026 -

Paul Miller Honda of West Caldwell responded

Hi Carl, thank you for choosing Paul Miller Honda and for sharing your positive experience. We’re so glad to hear that our team made you feel welcome and supported every step of the way. Enjoy your new car!

September 04, 2026

Easy and comfortable purchasing from Paul Miller. We worked with Narain who was excellent. Showed us all our choices and worked hard to find the right match for us. It was simple and felt like we wer More

by rehanadutta
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Narain Idnani
Sep 08, 2026 -

Paul Miller Honda of West Caldwell responded

We are grateful for your feedback on Narain and the team! Your comments will be shared with everyone. Thank you for choosing Paul Miller Honda!

July 15, 2026

I recently visited Paul Miller Honda, and from start to finish, the experience was smooth, transparent, and stress-free, the showroom was clean and welcoming and the staff greeted me warmly without any pus More

by Lt72556
Sales Price Transparency
Purchase Time
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Jean Jacques
Jul 15, 2026 -

Paul Miller Honda of West Caldwell responded

Larry, we're delighted to hear about your seamless experience with Jean and the team at Paul Miller Honda! Thanks for the glowing review. We hope to see you again!

May 20, 2026

I liked the service that they gave me im very sastified…. Very respecfull with everything More

by zaiekbasilia
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Josué sucre
May 20, 2026 -

Paul Miller Honda of West Caldwell responded

Thank you for the great review. We look forward to seeing you again at Paul Miller Honda!

May 20, 2026

Very professional, reasonalbe and helpful! I bought my Honda Ridgeline 2026 Black Edition amd Jean was helping me. What a nice experience! More

by tubui7462
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Jean Jacques
May 20, 2026 -

Paul Miller Honda of West Caldwell responded

Congratulations on your new 2026 Honda Ridgeline Black Edition! We are thrilled to hear Jean and the team were of such great help. Thank you for choosing Paul Miller Honda!

May 06, 2026

Could not have had a better experience leading a car. Jean was incredibly transparent, knowledgeable, and attentive. More

by cari
Sales Price Transparency
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Jean Jacques
May 06, 2026 -

Paul Miller Honda of West Caldwell responded

Thank you, Cari! We're so glad Jean made your leasing experience so smooth and enjoyable. We'll see you again at Paul Miller Honda!

May 02, 2026

The sales and service departments at Paul Miller Honda in West Caldwell have always met my expectations. More

by Honda1
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Ameen Mohamad
May 04, 2026 -

Paul Miller Honda of West Caldwell responded

We're happy our sales and service teams continue to meet your expectations! Thank you for choosing Paul Miller Honda and for sharing your support. Safe travels!

April 29, 2026

The entire experience at Paul Miller Honda was great, as usual. I have leased every Honda from there. My sales rep, Narain Indnani was extremely helpful and knowledgable. I give him top marks in every ca More

by nicklaricha
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Narain Idnani
Apr 30, 2026 -

Paul Miller Honda of West Caldwell responded

Nick, thank you for sharing your experience with Narain and the team! We truly appreciate your continued support and we look forward to seeing you at Paul Miller Honda again in the future. Safe travels!

1
...