Gary Prestidge
Sales & Leasing Consultant
Hyundai West Allis
10611 W Arthur Ave
West Allis, WI 53227
11 Reviews
Write a Review11 Reviews of Gary Prestidge
May 26, 2026
Gary Prestidge, our salesman, was terrific. We completed extensive pricing research, including several internet quote requests. And a CarMax quote for a trade-in value. Trust me, we did our hom We completed extensive pricing research, including several internet quote requests. And a CarMax quote for a trade-in value. Trust me, we did our homework! West Allis Hyundai's pricing beat them all, including the CarMax trade-in price. Since the trade-in price was deducted from the new car price, it lowered our tax on the new car. Everyone there was friendly, helpful, and knowledgeable. They offered additional maintenance warranty packages, but they were never pushy. While I typically dislike the new car buying process, this was a very positive experience. I wouldn't hesitate to buy from them again. More
Other Employees Tagged: ROBERT GONZALES, Phoenix Mikulec
May 23, 2026
Amazing staff in every department. They really get to know you and I feel like they really get me! They really get to know you and I feel like they really get me! More
Other Employees Tagged: ROBERT GONZALES, Don Smith, Phoenix Mikulec, Lorna Swiatkowski, Victoria Tatro, Jeff Rivi, Craig Mierow, Ryan Nikolaus, Paul Lenon
April 23, 2026
This dealership is the best! Everyone is so friendly and they are pressuring. They respect the clients shopping and want to see them get what fits their lifestyle best. Highly r Everyone is so friendly and they are pressuring. They respect the clients shopping and want to see them get what fits their lifestyle best. Highly recommend Gary! More
Other Employees Tagged: Don Smith, Phoenix Mikulec
April 01, 2026
Very easy dealership to work with fair price and good service I have bought many vehicles from service I have bought many vehicles from More
Other Employees Tagged: ROBERT GONZALES, Phoenix Mikulec
March 13, 2026
Buying my Sonata from the dealership was smooth. Gary and Felix were amazing to work with. Gary and Felix were amazing to work with. More
Other Employees Tagged: Don Smith, Phoenix Mikulec, Paul Lenon
March 10, 2026
I had a tight time frame and all did well to keep it. Gary is a great sales rep. Gary is a great sales rep. More
Other Employees Tagged: ROBERT GONZALES, Don Smith, Phoenix Mikulec, Ryan Nikolaus
March 04, 2026
Gary was amazing with the whole process. This is our fourth Hyundai from West Allis and it's because of their staff from service to the front desk that has us return. This is our fourth Hyundai from West Allis and it's because of their staff from service to the front desk that has us return. More
Other Employees Tagged: Don Smith, Phoenix Mikulec, Jeff Rivi, Craig Mierow
February 26, 2026
Very friendly and easy to deal with. As with any place buying a car, had to negotiate a few details but, they made a a very fair deal and ended up beating several other dealers in the ar As with any place buying a car, had to negotiate a few details but, they made a a very fair deal and ended up beating several other dealers in the area. Gary in Sales and Don the Sales Manager were very friendly and easy to work with. More
Other Employees Tagged: Don Smith, Phoenix Mikulec
January 28, 2026
Very clean showroom. , Friendly, knowledgeable salesman. Received vehicle in a timely manner. Salesman spent a great deal of time explaining controls , Friendly, knowledgeable salesman. Received vehicle in a timely manner. Salesman spent a great deal of time explaining controls More
Other Employees Tagged: Don Smith, Phoenix Mikulec

