Dealer Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
Jay Miller
107 Reviews
I am a Lancaster County boy. Married to beautiful Colleen for 30 wonderful years, with 2 fantastic children. My son is at Villanova Law and my daughter is in NYC, working in PR. I'm a very proud dad! My BMW history goes in line with my history. In 1967 my dad bought a BMW 1600 Alpina, because he couldn't afford a Porsche 911. From that point on, we became a BMW family, which translated in to only BMWs for over 58 years! Both I and my brother are in the BMW business. Me in sales since 1990, and my brother a Master BMW Technician since 1980. I own several models, including a 2023 i4 Electric car, a 2011 X5 35i, a 2015 3 GT, a 2008 M3 Convertible, a 2008 335i Coupe, an R1200 S motorrad, and an ultra-rare 1974 2002 Turbo! Please reach out, and I will be glad to assist!
Read moreDealership Experience
20 yrs, 10 mos
Industry Experience
35 yrs, 10 mos
Specialties & Trainings
37-year BMW owner/driver
Classic BMW specialist
BMW Profiles in Achievement- Gold
BMW M Certified
107 Reviews
Write a Review
107 Reviews of Jay Miller
June 29, 2023
I have been buying my BMW's here for 25 years. Keep up the great work! Keep up the great work! More
by SJD60
Verified CustomerOther Employees Tagged: Kevin Mahoney, Wilmer Rodriguez, Justice Mogano, Ralph Nofsinger, Scott Gately, Chad Carey , Cameron Ashman, Noel Montesano
June 20, 2023
Jay made the pickup of our new BMW a special moment. The icing on the cake was the Teddy bear waiting on the car for Eleanor. Very much appreciated! The icing on the cake was the Teddy bear waiting on the car for Eleanor. Very much appreciated! More
by Richard Bird
Other Employees Tagged: Kevin Mahoney, Chad Carey , John Keenan
June 16, 2023
Great experience. Jay makes the purchase of a new car a truly enjoyable experience. This is the fourth BMW we have purchased from him. Jay makes the purchase of a new car a truly enjoyable experience. This is the fourth BMW we have purchased from him. More
by ldgreensniffles
Other Employees Tagged: Noel Montesano
June 08, 2023
Scott was great. Love my new car. A true pride experience love the gay approach to running a car dealership. Happy Pride:) Love my new car. A true pride experience love the gay approach to running a car dealership. Happy Pride:) More
by Tom
Other Employees Tagged: Wilmer Rodriguez, Justice Mogano, Ralph Nofsinger, Scott Gately, Ian Martin , Dan McCloy, Noel Montesano, Ian Welsh
April 06, 2023
This was a great experience from start to finish. I walked into the dealership late in the day with my wife looking for a certified BMW. Jay Miller was a great help and went far and beyond to help I walked into the dealership late in the day with my wife looking for a certified BMW. Jay Miller was a great help and went far and beyond to help us get the car we wanted on the same day through all.of the complications with our license and insurance. Noel made the paperwork quick and painless. They both stayed an hour after the dealership was closed to get things completed. Even after everything was done, Jay spent extra time cleaning the vehicle and showing us how everything worked. This was A+ customer service experience and we will be referring Jay, Noel, and Ottos to our friends and family. More
by JoeD
Other Employees Tagged: Noel Montesano
June 17, 2022
The best new car buying experience I've ever had! Jay Miller was exceptional in the process and really explained all features and set up very well. John, who handled the paperwork did so seamlessly a Jay Miller was exceptional in the process and really explained all features and set up very well. John, who handled the paperwork did so seamlessly and in a professional manner. The car was in a beautiful space for delivery and for going through all the information needed to make me feel comfortable in driving out. From start to finish it really was a wonderful experience, Kudos to Otto's, the best dealership! More
by awisa12
Other Employees Tagged: John Keenan
April 26, 2021
I have worked with Jay for many years. I can't say enough good things about my experiences with him. He is patient and kind which is always helpful when I am in the process of leasing a new car. Jay enough good things about my experiences with him. He is patient and kind which is always helpful when I am in the process of leasing a new car. Jay listens to my wants and needs and never fails to deliver! So happy with my new car. Thank you Jay. More
by faymarie
March 12, 2021
Jay has been our BMW sales person for over 10 years, and that will definitely not change. In all this time he always had great advice, researched all my crazy ideas and questions and never ever was pushing that will definitely not change. In all this time he always had great advice, researched all my crazy ideas and questions and never ever was pushing us, which I appreciate very much. He is a car enthusiast himself and has quite the history with BMWs and another famous German brand. If you are looking for a great and honest sales man who will also work out the best deal for you, go to Jay. We just picked up a new beamer last week. More
by wolfgang
March 07, 2021
We've used Otto's for our last two BMWs and have had a great purchasing and service experience with both. Our salesman Jay Miller has been great from the start not pushing, listens to our questions, and i great purchasing and service experience with both. Our salesman Jay Miller has been great from the start not pushing, listens to our questions, and informative regarding our options. We highly recommend both. More
by Jim Connelly
January 31, 2021
Jay was awesome to work with. Has his own personal journey with multiple BMW's and has a depth of experience. Easy ordering, timely feedback and great communication. journey with multiple BMW's and has a depth of experience. Easy ordering, timely feedback and great communication. More
by W Hesel
Other Employees Tagged: Kevin Mahoney
Dealership Inventory (292 Vehicles)
