Back

Brewster Subaru

Brewster, NY

5.0
2,599 Reviews
Welcome to the All-New Brewster Subaru! As of November 17, 2014, the dealership formerly known as Smith-Cairns Subaru is under new ownership. Family owned and operated with over 25 years of Subaru experience, we look forward to serving New York and Connecticut Subaru owners and future owners. There are truckloads of factory fresh Subarus on their way to Brewster, plus many positive changes in the works. Here are just some of the things you can expect from the All-New Brewster Subaru: Friendly Faces: Lots of familiar faces and some new ones too! A Relaxed, Low Pressure Environment: Our Experienced Subaru sales and service staff are here to serve your needs and guide you through the shopping process. Change has already begun: We are working hard to quickly bring you an improved dealer experience. More customer parking, a new look in the showroom, an upgraded customer lounge & refreshments are just few of the enhancements we have already made with much more to come. Receive the most for your trade in: Although we are family owned, we own a number of dealerships and have many outlets available that allow us to pay the most for your trade in. We accept trades of all makes and models with the most competitive offers. Brewster Subaru is easy to get to right off Route 84 and our goal is to make it an enjoyable and quality Subaru buying and servicing experience that you will want to tell your friends and family about. We look forward to meeting and serving all of our new customers.
Contact Dealership

3751 Danbury Rd.

Brewster, NY

10509

Directions

By Type

Showing 2,599 reviews

February 26, 2026

I just purchased my second Subaru with Mitch. Mitch does a great job of making you understand the process and ensuring that you feel comfortable along the way. This was my first time trading in a More

by Lindsay Mets
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Rich Johnson
5.0
This rating includes all reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Mitchel Pollak
5.0
This rating includes all reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Feb 26, 2026 -

Brewster Subaru responded

Lindsay, thanks for sharing your seamless experience with Mitch and Rich at Brewster Subaru! It's great to hear that they made every step clear and easy, from trading in to syncing your app. Congratulations on your second Subaru!

February 18, 2026

I couldn't ask for a better experience, especially as a Michigan resident. Kristen kept me fully aware of every step and was in constant communication. More

by chrisry9
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Rich Johnson
5.0
This rating includes all reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Kristen Hetzer
5.0
This rating includes all reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Other Employees : Patti Youmans
Feb 18, 2026 -

Brewster Subaru responded

Thank you for sharing your five-star review of Kristen's attentive service! We appreciate your business and we hope you won't hesitate to reach out if there's anything else we can do for you! - The Brewster Subaru Team

February 10, 2026

My experience is very good and andre reid and Mike the technician are very professional and very helpful More

by amhpc3
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Andre Reid
5.0
This rating includes all reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Feb 11, 2026 -

Brewster Subaru responded

We're delighted to hear about your positive experience with Andre and Mike! Thank you for choosing Brewster Subaru!

January 24, 2026

Great experience working with Carmelina and everyone at Brewster Subaru! They were patient and competent! More

by cdefaber
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Rich Johnson
5.0
This rating includes all reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Other Employees : Carmelina Bruni
Jan 26, 2026 -

Brewster Subaru responded

Hi Defaber! We’re delighted that Carmelina and the team made your experience a great one! Thank you for choosing Brewster Subaru and sharing your feedback!

January 19, 2026

Talk about salesmanship. We started with one car and by the time we were done the whole family had new cars. Andre was extremely accommodating and went out of his way for eve More

by phyllis.perlmutter
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Andre Reid
5.0
This rating includes all reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Jack McCaffrey
5.0
This rating includes all reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Other Employees : Nick sales mgr.
Jan 20, 2026 -

Brewster Subaru responded

Hi Phyllis! Thank you for sharing this wonderful feedback! We are pleased to hear that Andre, Jack, and Nick made your car-buying experience so comfortable and accommodating. We greatly appreciate your recommendation and your business! See you next time at Brewster Subaru!

January 06, 2026

Carlos and Rich were great people to work with and made the entire purchase experience pleasurable. No pressure, always a smile and were able to answer all questions. Very happy with our new 2025 outback More

by kmulemag
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Rich Johnson
5.0
This rating includes all reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Other Employees : Carlos Argueta
Jan 06, 2026 -

Brewster Subaru responded

Congratulations on your new 2025 Outback! We will pass along your thanks to Carlos and Rich for making the buying experience so enjoyable. Thank you for choosing Brewster Subaru!

December 31, 2025

Kristen Hetzer is a very knowledgeable, trustworthy and extremely helpful salesperson. She is easy to work with and very efficient. I highly recommend Kristen and the Brewster Subaru dealership. More

by happycustomer
Sales Price Transparency
Purchase Time
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Kristen Hetzer
5.0
This rating includes all reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Jan 02, 2026 -

Brewster Subaru responded

Thank you for recommending Kristen and our team at Brewster Subaru! We’re so glad we could help you find the right car and we’ll be sure to pass along your appreciation!

December 30, 2025

Mitch was very helpful with the trade in of my old car and the purchase of another pre-owned Crosstrek. He took me through several options and found me a great deal. Personable and patient - I will refer More

by Nancytucci
Trade-in Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Mitchel Pollak
5.0
This rating includes all reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Dec 30, 2025 -

Brewster Subaru responded

Hi Nancy! We are so grateful for your feedback! It's fantastic to hear that Mitch was so helpful in your trade-in and purchase experience. Thank you for choosing Brewster Subaru and for spreading the word about our team!

December 29, 2025

All involved helped put me at ease with the process of trading in my beloved 2016 Crosstrek for a new one. No pushy pressure to decide. Overall a very nice experience! More

by toeroeks
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Rich Johnson
5.0
This rating includes all reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Christine Bates
5.0
This rating includes all reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Other Employees : Connor Stroh and also Michael- explained systems features very patient
Dec 30, 2025 -

Brewster Subaru responded

Hi Toeroeks! It's awesome to hear you felt so comfortable and supported during the trade-in process at Brewster Subaru. Enjoy your Subaru Crosstrek!

December 04, 2025

i had an amazing experience working with Kristen Hetzer se is very honest and open with everything she is very straight forward i came to her after calling a few other dealers and all of them too More

by shimon s
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Kristen Hetzer
5.0
This rating includes all reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Dec 04, 2025 -

Brewster Subaru responded

Shimon, thank you for choosing Brewster Subaru and sharing your feedback about Kristen! We are thrilled to hear you are in good hands with her.

1
...