
Atlantic Toyota
West Islip, NY
Hours
Sales/Showroom
Monday 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Tuesday 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Wednesday 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Thursday 9:00 AM - 8:00 PM
Friday 9:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Saturday 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Sunday 11:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Service
Monday 7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday 7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday 7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday 7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday 7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday 7:30 AM - 4:00 PM
Sunday Closed
Parts
Monday 7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday 7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday 7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday 7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday 7:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Saturday 7:30 AM - 4:00 PM
Sunday Closed
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
Showing 2,116 reviews
My 2008 Matrix has been serviced at Atlantic since I purchased it (at another Toyota dealership) in Fall 2007. Their service was recommended to me by a neighbor, and overall, Atlantic service has maint purchased it (at another Toyota dealership) in Fall 2007. Their service was recommended to me by a neighbor, and overall, Atlantic service has maintained a high standard, in quality of work, friendliness and helpfulness of personnel, and sometimes even in price. I have used Michelle as a Service Advisor on 3 visits so far and she has been most helpful during the service experience - pleasant, professional, and honest in her assessment of the work my car has needed. I have, and will continue to recommend Atlantic Toyota Service to my friends. More
Service was great as always. Drove away knowing my Highlander was the best it could be, safe and reliable. It's nice knowing I have a place I can go and feel confident that my SUV is being taken care Highlander was the best it could be, safe and reliable. It's nice knowing I have a place I can go and feel confident that my SUV is being taken care of right. More
Service is fast, with short wait time. All the people are friendly. Waiting area is comfortable. Competitive prices on services performed, they also accept all competitor coupons. I've been to other dealersh friendly. Waiting area is comfortable. Competitive prices on services performed, they also accept all competitor coupons. I've been to other dealerships for services, and I choose to come back to Atlantic Toyota even though it's further for me to travel to. More
After going to two other Toyota Dealerships on the Island we ended up at Atlantic Toyota. From the first minute I walked in until the minute I left this dealership, I felt like this was one of the best buyi we ended up at Atlantic Toyota. From the first minute I walked in until the minute I left this dealership, I felt like this was one of the best buying experiences me and my family have ever had. I have been purchasing cars for the past 30 years and every time I walk into a dealership, anxiety fills my body. You are always waiting for that shoe to fall, but my experience here at Atlantic was the complete opposite. The professionalism displayed and practiced from the Finance Director, Frank Pugliese and the Salesrep Tafawa Lee was nothing short of amazing. The negotiations were clear and to the point. There was no game playing and the car was ready when promised. All the paperwork went smooth and Frank explained everything I signed and made sure that any questions I had were answered completely. I would recommend this dealership to everyone and I already have. I have not been to their service department yet, but Im sure it will be the same as the showroom as far as professionalism. More
I am giving today's experience a very poor rating because of the following: I was coming in for my 10,000 mile service visit... when I first arrived I was greeted by someone after about 10 minutes of because of the following: I was coming in for my 10,000 mile service visit... when I first arrived I was greeted by someone after about 10 minutes of waiting in my car (don't know his name or title) who took down the mileage, surveyed the car and instructed me to have a seat in the waiting room, which I did. After ONE HOUR of no one calling my name I went on a search for someone to speak to. I was instructed to speak with someone in the "corner" office. I met Mike Jaworski who then led me to his office when I told him I was waiting an hour and I had not been seen by a service adviser prior to this. (Mike Jaworski ended up being my service adviser for today) I told him I was upset about waiting so long and that I had a prior commitment to pick my brother up from the hospital directly after today's appointment. Mike was very apologetic; he then checked a sheet of paper where he told me that someone had crossed off my name and put a "check" mark, indicating that I was called and didn't respond. This was not true because I was listening very intently and my name was NEVER called. I didn't even fix a cup of coffee or visit the rest room because I didn't want to miss hearing my name. So I then returned to the waiting room for another hour; at which point I returned to Mike Jaworski and inquired as to why it was taking so long. He told me they were working on the car and that it was taking so long because they had to rotate the tires as well. He did apologize for the wait. So I went back to my seat and waited another half an hour; I couldn't find Mike so I asked if there was a manager available. After 2 1/2 hours, I spoke with Tasha Drew. At this point I was becoming very, very upset. Tasha first words were that she was not going to sit there and be "screamed at". (I wasn't screaming but I was upset so my voice was obviously elevated). I then said that I wasn't screaming at her but I was upset about the situation. She went to find out about my car and told me it was almost done but in speaking with her, she made reference to the fact that this service visit was under "Toyota Care" and that I wouldn't be charged. Am I to assume that if I was paying for todays visit I would have been treated better?? And I do "pay" for it with every monthly payment!! (Tasha did say she was going to "add-on" ONE free oil change after my Toyota Care is expired but I'm not sure I want to return to this dealer for my service visits.) My car was finally ready about 20 minutes later. By then I was there for 3 HOURS!! When I made the appointment I was told it should only take an hour. If this is what its like under Toyota "CARE," who would want it? Waiting three hours with an appointment is absurd. This was a simple oil change and tire rotation!! With the rude behavior and dismissive attitude of Tasha Drew toward my experience, you can bet that I would give second thoughts to A - recommending this dealership to anyone for anything, and B - getting my next car from them. More
the dealer service agent benny was very friendly and helpful, time for sevice was less and he tried to minimize the cost affectively.the service job was good. my overall experience was very good. helpful, time for sevice was less and he tried to minimize the cost affectively.the service job was good. my overall experience was very good. More
Benny was really friendly and professional. I had a really poor experience with a different worker in the service department one time, so I was relieved to work with Benny this time around. I would pr really poor experience with a different worker in the service department one time, so I was relieved to work with Benny this time around. I would probably request him in the future because of it. More
Terrific service. Friendly, Helpful. Efficient. Terrific service. Friendly, Helpful. Efficient. Krystle had me in and out of service within 45 minutes. Couldn't ask for better service. Even th Terrific service. Friendly, Helpful. Efficient. Krystle had me in and out of service within 45 minutes. Couldn't ask for better service. Even the bagels were great. More