Dealer Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
Service Department
Service Department
Parts & Service
Atlantic Toyota
205 Sunrise Hwy North Service Rd
West Islip, NY 11795
348 Reviews
- At Atlantic Toyota in Long Island our service management team has over thirty years of Toyota experience. - Our twenty five technicians are all Toyota Factory trained with five Master Technicians and three of those technicians hold the highest ranking of Master Diagnostic Technician. Over 500 hours of training and stringent testing is required to achieve these levels. - When you become part of our service family you will be reminded of your next service as well as being advised of our frequent and generous specials. - Atlantic Toyota is a Seven time winner of Service Excellence Award for top rankings in customer satisfaction.
Read more348 Reviews
Write a Review
348 Reviews of Service Department
Verified Customer
October 08, 2026
Always an excellent experience at Atlantic Toyota Service department. I see Judy, a service writer. Judy is extremely informative, professional and friendly. I had a pleasure to meet with Will, a salesman wh department. I see Judy, a service writer. Judy is extremely informative, professional and friendly. I had a pleasure to meet with Will, a salesman who discussed my options with me while I waited on my truck to be serviced. Great staff! Will be back to get my new tires. More
by ALEXANDRAMCGLEESE
Other Employees Tagged: William Blackwood , Judy Feliz
October 07, 2026
Very well organized service. More sophisticated at each visit. Professional, helpful and friendly personnel. Neat and quick. Thank you for your service Atlantic Toyota of West Is More sophisticated at each visit. Professional, helpful and friendly personnel. Neat and quick. Thank you for your service Atlantic Toyota of West Islip, see you next time! More
by tec235
Other Employees Tagged: Mike Keehner, Nick Frank, Tasha Drew
October 05, 2026
The service department was incredibly efficient , kind and helpful . I was taken in on time and they explained exactly what they were doing . I was in and out so quick . Excellent service . and helpful . I was taken in on time and they explained exactly what they were doing . I was in and out so quick . Excellent service . More
by terrysadie
September 30, 2026
Atlantic Toyota is a phenomenal dealership that I will be exclusively going to and working with for any vehicle needs I have. Their service department is excellent, responsive, professional, and talented at exclusively going to and working with for any vehicle needs I have. Their service department is excellent, responsive, professional, and talented at what they do. Anytime I have ever called to make a service appointment, I am always relieved and glad to get to speak with a human representative and not an endless AI-robot maze of an answering system. Making appointments is easy and when I arrived, my advisor Tyler M. was wonderfully kind, professional, and courteous. I waited in the waiting area while my Camry was being worked on and was done & back on the road in no time. HIGHLY RECOMMEND. More
by jcoady181
Other Employees Tagged: Tyler Munro
September 12, 2026
Excellent customer service. Always a pleasure working with Tasha and the team. Appreciate all the hard work and excellence. Always a pleasure working with Tasha and the team. Appreciate all the hard work and excellence. More
by NATDAMY
Other Employees Tagged: William Blackwood, Sandra Dellolio, Rich Healy, Mike Keehner, Nick Frank, Tasha Drew
September 10, 2026
Greeted immediately. Provided the service asked for. Unfortunately I did not make an appointment this time but even with an appointment, wait times for even just a simple Provided the service asked for. Unfortunately I did not make an appointment this time but even with an appointment, wait times for even just a simple oil change are longer than necessary. I like how they always provide feedback but considering this is the only place I go, they don’t have to try to sell me something every time! But Tasha was a pleasure to work with! More
by DIANAFLEMING8283
Other Employees Tagged: Mike Keehner, Nick Frank, Tasha Drew
September 05, 2026
Awesome dealership. Best overall pricing, service, environment etc.. they will beat everyone in all respects. See Greg Connelly for sales and manager Rich. They are awes Best overall pricing, service, environment etc.. they will beat everyone in all respects. See Greg Connelly for sales and manager Rich. They are awesome as are others like Mike in service. Atlantic Auto Group are the owners of this place and 19 different dealerships with all different brands. Try them first before you get ripped off from other companies. More
by honestyimportant
Other Employees Tagged: Greg Connelly, Rich Healy, Mike Keehner
Dealership Inventory (124 Vehicles)
