Dealer Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
Brewster Subaru
Brewster, NY
2,623 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Service Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
2,623 Reviews of Brewster Subaru
June 12, 2024
This is my 2nd new vehicle (both Outbacks) purchased from Anthony. It is a pleasure to deal with Anthony - he is quite personable & straight-forward. He walked me through all features & answered all questio Anthony. It is a pleasure to deal with Anthony - he is quite personable & straight-forward. He walked me through all features & answered all questions. Car buying made easy! More
by Kathleen
Employees Worked With
Anthony Pilla
June 04, 2024
Rich Johnson had all our paperwork ready, he clearly explained all of our options and was very thorough and answered all our questions. This is our second lease, and we are extremely happy with all th explained all of our options and was very thorough and answered all our questions. This is our second lease, and we are extremely happy with all the service at Brewster Subaru! More
by mariajosephtricrest
Employees Worked With
Roy Schiller, Rich Johnson
June 02, 2024
I never really write reviews online however I was blown away with my experience with Brewster Subaru so I wanted to leave a review for them. I had the upmost pleasure to work with Anthony Pilla and was tre away with my experience with Brewster Subaru so I wanted to leave a review for them. I had the upmost pleasure to work with Anthony Pilla and was treated like family! Picked up my factory ordered 2024 WRX on May 26th, 2024 and had a smooth and quick transaction with Anthony and his team! I highly highly recommend ANYONE who is interested in purchasing any car to please go to Brewster Subaru and ask for Anthony Pilla! He will take great care of you! More
by garyjxp
Employees Worked With
Anthony Pilla
June 01, 2024
I wanted to leave a comment for Mitch Pollack at Brewster Subaru in Brewster, NY. When I visited in March 2024, Mitch was incredibly patient and not pushy, allowing us to make our own decisions. I apologize Subaru in Brewster, NY. When I visited in March 2024, Mitch was incredibly patient and not pushy, allowing us to make our own decisions. I apologize for the delay in providing this feedback, as I was comparing other car dealerships. In comparison, the other salespeople were quite pushy, frequently calling and emailing. Mitch's approach was refreshing and much appreciated." More
by otero11974
Employees Worked With
Rich Johnson, Mitchel Pollak
May 31, 2024
I was very pleased with the professional treatment I received at Brewster Subaru. I will be happy to recommend Brewster Subaru to everyone I know . received at Brewster Subaru. I will be happy to recommend Brewster Subaru to everyone I know . More
by M Uddin
Employees Worked With
Roy Schiller, Rich Johnson
May 30, 2024
Highly professional, well organized, responsive follow-up, keeps promises, and creates a friendly, warm-hearted environment amidst the highest level of professionalism. follow-up, keeps promises, and creates a friendly, warm-hearted environment amidst the highest level of professionalism. More
by lorivoice.samuels24
Employees Worked With
Carmelina Bruno, Rich Johnson
May 29, 2024
Absolutely the best car buying experience I’ve ever had! From the very beginning, the staff at Brewster Subaru took care of everything. Kristen even went beyond to find best financing options for us. Fabulo From the very beginning, the staff at Brewster Subaru took care of everything. Kristen even went beyond to find best financing options for us. Fabulous customer service! More
by aomana
Employees Worked With
Rich Johnson, Kristen Hetzer
May 28, 2024
Excellent experience at Brewster Subaru. Mitch Pollack was extremely knowledgeable and professional which assisted me in picking the right vehicle. I will definitely recommend Mitch and his Mitch Pollack was extremely knowledgeable and professional which assisted me in picking the right vehicle. I will definitely recommend Mitch and his team. More
by Jbmoran109
Employees Worked With
Mitchel Pollak
May 27, 2024
Jack in service department was great other than that I wouldn't come back I asked for the car to get detailed they didn't do it there was a stain on the car and the salesman said i was buying a used car w wouldn't come back I asked for the car to get detailed they didn't do it there was a stain on the car and the salesman said i was buying a used car what do i expect. I was over charged for the warranty and had to go to my credit card to get my money back myself because they refused and and had to go to warranty co and fill out forms to cancel it because they refused to do that to. More
by Ricksnissan
Employees Worked With
Rich Johnson, Mitchel Pollak
