Dealer Reviews
Service Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
Competition Subaru of Smithtown
St James, NY
594 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Service Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
Showing 594 reviews
September 18, 2019
Horrible Horrible Horrible After a nightmare when they delivered my new car - was there from 7pm-1am due to errors they made, they only gave me 1 key to my new car because they After a nightmare when they delivered my new car - was there from 7pm-1am due to errors they made, they only gave me 1 key to my new car because they couldn’t find the second one. They promised to send the second key. It has been 5 months - still no key. The salesman Joe and the store manage refuse to answer my emails and calls all this time. Just awful - taking advantage of a senior. Now I have to go to small claims court - such a pain!!!! More
by Cheryl
Employees Worked With
Joseph Giampietro, Christopher Pompeo
August 24, 2019
First Time Lease This was my first time leasing and I could not ask for a better experience. My sales representative, Rodney McCabe, made the process easy and effortle This was my first time leasing and I could not ask for a better experience. My sales representative, Rodney McCabe, made the process easy and effortless. From the moment I walked into the dealership his energy was high and he made me eager to lease with Subaru. He also was very reasonable and understanding with my wants, needs, and budget in a car. I highly recommend if you are buying or leasing Subaru to go to Smithtown and ask for Rodney! More
by Ttrap
Employees Worked With
Rodney McCabe
August 20, 2019
EXCELLENT SALESMAN i bought a used Subaru Outback from Jay liardi, he worked hard to get me a good price and he also take in my off lease vehicle and dropped dropped it i bought a used Subaru Outback from Jay liardi, he worked hard to get me a good price and he also take in my off lease vehicle and dropped dropped it off at Kia for me. I would recommend he to anyone looking for a vehicle More
by blue22
Employees Worked With
jay liardi
August 15, 2019
Excellent experience with sale!!! Not very often can you feel no pressure while making a car purchase but I have to say. It was an absolute pleasure. Joe was very helpful and did not Not very often can you feel no pressure while making a car purchase but I have to say. It was an absolute pleasure. Joe was very helpful and did not make me feel pressured at all!! Will be back. Thank you Joe!! More
by Donnalyn
Employees Worked With
Corinne Johnsen, Joseph Giampietro
August 12, 2019
Loaner car return Patti in service helped with the loaner car I would be using for the day while my Forester was being serviced. I had the pleasure of driving a very cl Patti in service helped with the loaner car I would be using for the day while my Forester was being serviced. I had the pleasure of driving a very clean 2019 Forester. Patti called later in the day saying my Forester could be picked up. I was assisted by a young woman at the cashiers desk when I returned the loaner car. I’m very happy to see Competition Subaru at the expanded location- so much better than the previous cramped location More
by LisaM
Employees Worked With
Patti in service and the brunette young woman at cashiers desk, Mary Spira
August 10, 2019
10k Service Your service advisor Chris Barcello is amazing. He is overly helpful and keeps you informed of the progress. I definitely plan on using your dealershi Your service advisor Chris Barcello is amazing. He is overly helpful and keeps you informed of the progress. I definitely plan on using your dealership again. Thanks Chris. More
by Steve
Employees Worked With
Chris Barcello
August 10, 2019
"Excellent Service" Regina Medina made the purchase of my 2019 Crosstrek a seamless transaction, I'm very pleased with the entire experience of purchasing a new car at C Regina Medina made the purchase of my 2019 Crosstrek a seamless transaction, I'm very pleased with the entire experience of purchasing a new car at Competition Subaru of Smithtown. More
by Crosstrek 2019
Employees Worked With
Regina Medina
August 09, 2019
Excellent service . The sales person worked with us and helped us with explaining all about the car that we purchased. My family is very satisfied. . The sales person worked with us and helped us with explaining all about the car that we purchased. My family is very satisfied. More
by Mikey
Employees Worked With
Tim McCrum
August 07, 2019
Smithtown Subaru I purchased a 2019 Ascent from Smithtown Subaru. My salesperson, Lisa Cain, was great. She was a pleasure to work with and took care of our needs fr I purchased a 2019 Ascent from Smithtown Subaru. My salesperson, Lisa Cain, was great. She was a pleasure to work with and took care of our needs from start to finish! More
by Mtb
Employees Worked With
Lisa Cain
August 07, 2019
New STI Cathy Kelleher was fantastic as always. This is the second car I’ve purchased through her and Smithtown Subaru and I couldn’t be happier. Cathy Kelleher was fantastic as always. This is the second car I’ve purchased through her and Smithtown Subaru and I couldn’t be happier. More
by Mikeygarg4
Employees Worked With
Cathy Kelleher, David Toomey
