Dealer Reviews
Service Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
Competition Subaru of Smithtown
St James, NY
591 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Service Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
Showing 591 reviews
January 10, 2025
Love this dealer and Cathy was a pleasure to work with. Bought my first Subaru from her and definitely plan to return in the near future! Bought my first Subaru from her and definitely plan to return in the near future! More
by rich83
Employees Worked With
John Giannetto, Michael Fiandor, Matthew Adler, James Buzzetta, Chris Barcelo, Justin Stein, Nino Tiburzi, Reginald Watkins, Cathy Kelleher
January 10, 2025
We recently had the pleasure of buying a 2025 Subaru Ascent from Cathy Kelleher. This is the second new Subaru we have purchased from Cathy. From the filling out of the order sheet up to the delivery of Ascent from Cathy Kelleher. This is the second new Subaru we have purchased from Cathy. From the filling out of the order sheet up to the delivery of the vehicle Cathy was 5 stars across the board. She has an impressive depth of knowledge of the Subaru brand. She is also very friendly and down to earth with a great sense of humor. Cathy made our purchase stress free and extremely enjoyable. We highly recommend Cathy Kelleher to anyone interested in purchasing a Subaru. You won't be disappointed. More
by bondfan38
Employees Worked With
Lovelle Fenico, Cathy Kelleher
January 08, 2025
I recently had the pleasure of purchasing a car from Farrell at Competition Subaru and I couldn't be happier with the experience. From the moment I walked in, Farrell was friendly, approachable, and mad Farrell at Competition Subaru and I couldn't be happier with the experience. From the moment I walked in, Farrell was friendly, approachable, and made me feel comfortable. Just an overall great guy. He listened to everything I was looking for, answered all my questions patiently, and guided me through the process with ease. Farrell was very knowledgeable, and he was genuinely enthusiastic about finding the perfect car for me. There wasn’t any pressure or salesy vibe like I’ve gotten at many other dealerships, just a genuine desire to help. If you're looking for a car and want a stress-free, enjoyable experience, I highly recommend asking for Farrell at Competition Subaru. He's a true professional and a genuine pleasure to work with. I can’t recommend him enough! Also worked with Rahul in financing who was great. He made the process fast, easy, and painless More
by r.campbell08
Employees Worked With
Rahul Verma, Farrell Shapiro
January 08, 2025
Customer service at the dealership I go to for service never disappoints. They are professional, kind and accommodate this old girl with humor. Plus I love your snacks never disappoints. They are professional, kind and accommodate this old girl with humor. Plus I love your snacks More
by clare.martinez360
Employees Worked With
Tommy Santoro, Michael Giardinello
January 07, 2025
It was an extreme pleasure working with Lisa Cain and the other members of the staff at Competition on the lease of my new 2025 Crosstrek. Very professional and no high pressure. other members of the staff at Competition on the lease of my new 2025 Crosstrek. Very professional and no high pressure. More
by rogerw
Employees Worked With
Lisa Cain, Lovelle Fenico, Regina Medina
November 11, 2024
I felt very grateful to have Zaak as my salesman. He was patient, knowledgeable, caring and kind during my visit. I trusted him and sealed the deal the same day. I will refer him to my friends and He was patient, knowledgeable, caring and kind during my visit. I trusted him and sealed the deal the same day. I will refer him to my friends and family in the future. Thank you Zaak for a wonderful experience purchasing my new car! More
by pennyjoseph36
Employees Worked With
Zaak Fox
November 07, 2024
Was nervous and anxious to purchase a new car. Zaak and the team at Competition Subaru made me feel at ease and made the whole experience stress free and enjoyable. They worked with me to find exa Zaak and the team at Competition Subaru made me feel at ease and made the whole experience stress free and enjoyable. They worked with me to find exactly what i wanted and I left later the same day with a new car. 5 stars!!!!! More
by raymondpaul86
Employees Worked With
Zaak Fox
November 07, 2024
Recent car buying experience at Competition Subaru was great. Everyone there was experienced & professional with no pressure to just push out & move around some stale inventory. Zaak knew which models great. Everyone there was experienced & professional with no pressure to just push out & move around some stale inventory. Zaak knew which models & trims I was interested in & made it happen. Was able to intercept an in-transit vehicle and get a trailer hitch installed by Subaru in Boston with no labor cost. The streamlined & seamless in-house processing of insurance paperwork & transitioning the DMV registration & plates from my old vehicle (that was totalled & left in Virginia) was the finishing touch on an overall great car buying experience. More
by Alan M
Employees Worked With
Zaak Fox
