Dealer Reviews
Service Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
Competition Subaru of Smithtown
St James, NY
592 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Service Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
Showing 592 reviews
November 21, 2018
Amazing service!! This was my first experience with Subaru and I couldn’t be happier thanks to Mike and Dan! I was able to walk off the lot with a car of my choice and This was my first experience with Subaru and I couldn’t be happier thanks to Mike and Dan! I was able to walk off the lot with a car of my choice and I recommend this dealership to anyone looking for their perfect Subaru! More
by Ashjenks1109
Employees Worked With
Michael Incristo, Dan Archer
November 21, 2018
Beautiful facility, nice people Making an appointment was easy; the place is clean and comfortable; Mary Pira, my service writer, was efficient, knowledgeable and very friendly. What Making an appointment was easy; the place is clean and comfortable; Mary Pira, my service writer, was efficient, knowledgeable and very friendly. What more can you ask for? More
by 17LegacyLN
Employees Worked With
Mary Spira
November 21, 2018
Friendly atmosphere I just want to say thank you for being so kind and attentive. Each time I came to the dealership, I was greeted immediately with a smile and an offer I just want to say thank you for being so kind and attentive. Each time I came to the dealership, I was greeted immediately with a smile and an offer to help. More
by Marj
Employees Worked With
Rodney McCabe
November 20, 2018
Always a good experience I called Nash the morning of 11/16 to make a last minute appointment as my 2011 Forester was making a grinding and rumbling noise after the snowstorm I called Nash the morning of 11/16 to make a last minute appointment as my 2011 Forester was making a grinding and rumbling noise after the snowstorm on 11/15. He had a loaner car available for me. Chris handled the intake information when I dropped my car off. I also requested some other servicing (oil change and problem with window defroster as I was planning to make an appointment in the next few days). The car was finished by early afternoon. The grinding noise was caused by a large chunk of ice lodged under the drive shaft, and oil change and defroster issue fixed. I have 195,000 miles on the car. All servicing has been done by the Competition team. More
by drivetoomanymiles
Employees Worked With
Nash, Chris.
November 20, 2018
Service Visit Just a quick note to say thank you to Competition Subaru of Smithtown NY. I have been a loyal Subaru customer for the past 18 years and currently own Just a quick note to say thank you to Competition Subaru of Smithtown NY. I have been a loyal Subaru customer for the past 18 years and currently own a 2008 Outback Limited and 2018 Outback Limited with Eyesight. I have been getting both cars serviced at Competition Subaru of Smithtown for almost 5 years and I must say the service department is fantastic. In particular, Mary Spira is just wonderful and knows how to take care of her customers. Everytime I see Mary I have confidence in knowing my car will be serviced correctly and be ready when she said it will be. Thank you Mary Spira and Competition Subaru of Smithtown. - Lou Cavallo, Smithtown NY More
by Lou
Employees Worked With
Erik Tops, Mary Spira, Joseph Giampietro
November 20, 2018
Great job by Joe G & Erik T.! Make it easy.. I turned in my lease early & specifically returned to Competition Subaru because of Erik Tops! Great job by Joe Giampietro as well! I would highly r I turned in my lease early & specifically returned to Competition Subaru because of Erik Tops! Great job by Joe Giampietro as well! I would highly reccomend them to all of my friends. More
by John C.
Employees Worked With
Erik Tops, Joseph Giampietro
November 19, 2018
Poor Experience Poor delivery experience, salesman was irresponsible and lied about delivery process to conceal his responsibility, lack of follow through on communic Poor delivery experience, salesman was irresponsible and lied about delivery process to conceal his responsibility, lack of follow through on communication, employees blamed each other for our problems More
by Phoenix
Employees Worked With
Lisa Sessa, Bart Mandaro, Dan Archer
November 18, 2018
Excellent Worked with Rodney and he was great! It was overall a very painless and professional experience! I would come here again for a car anytime. Worked with Rodney and he was great! It was overall a very painless and professional experience! I would come here again for a car anytime. More
by Cjh93
Employees Worked With
Rodney McCabe
November 17, 2018
Satisfied Very nice process. Jeff and Carol were extremely helpful. I used the Costco Auto Buying service and was referred to Competition Subaru. They clearl Very nice process. Jeff and Carol were extremely helpful. I used the Costco Auto Buying service and was referred to Competition Subaru. They clearly explained the pricing, and provided a "no pressure" environment to make my decision. Thank you. More
by Satisfied
Employees Worked With
Carol Glass, Jeff Barkan
November 15, 2018
First time looking at and ultimately buying a Subaru When looking to lease a new car we decided to visit the Subaru dealership in Smithtown because of the excellent write-up for Subaru's in Consumer Repo When looking to lease a new car we decided to visit the Subaru dealership in Smithtown because of the excellent write-up for Subaru's in Consumer Reports Magazine. We took the Crosstrek for a test drive and were impressed. Dealership was friendly and helpful. Wound up buying the Crosstrek and we are happy with out decision. More
by jbsedos
Employees Worked With
Jeff Barkan, Erik Tops
