Dealer Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
FIAT of Manhattan
New York, NY
64 Reviews
Sort by
64 Reviews of FIAT of Manhattan
September 25, 2012
I was checking out dealer stock online when I happened on the Abarth outfitted exactly as I wanted it. I clicked the link to schedule a test drive. This was done at 1:00am in the morning. At 9:00am I got a c the Abarth outfitted exactly as I wanted it. I clicked the link to schedule a test drive. This was done at 1:00am in the morning. At 9:00am I got a call from Angela and I said I wanted a test drive for noon that day. When I got there I immediately asked Angela if the Abarth I saw online was still available. It was in transit and still available! So we test drove an Abarth they had sitting around and it was fantastic. We returned to the dealership and I plunked down my deposit. I had to wait just 18 long days until it got to the dealership. It was there when originally promised and I took delivery the same day. People order these cars and have to wait months. Angela was great. However, I cannot recommend this dealership because of Caleb Denis. He is a thief of the first order. He inflated the price of the new car to offset the price I negotiated for my trade in. In the instalment contract he added about $1200 and I didn't notice it until I got home with my new car. Live and learn. BUT learn from my mistake and STAY AWAY from Fiat of Manhattan!!! More
by kn57rick
Employees Worked With
Angela Ramsumair, Caleb Denis
September 11, 2012
Caleb Denis is the biggest rip off artist. Buyer beware!!!!!!! Tried to sell us a dirty damaged car on a bait and switch for a different color Made me wait 2 hours to pick the car up because he wa beware!!!!!!! Tried to sell us a dirty damaged car on a bait and switch for a different color Made me wait 2 hours to pick the car up because he was too busy scamming other buyers. Tried to rip me off on the Ally Lease bank fee by charging me $795 when it was really $50 Promised to make up for it buy offering free all weather floor mats...10 calls later....no response! BEFORE YOU SIGN......think twice about even dealing with Fiat of Manhattan and Caleb Denis. If you must then get the lease the prior to signing it to review it. Check the bank fee. Leases are very confusing so do your research to read and understand the contract. I did and it prevented me from being ripped off nearly $750.00 Best of all....Caleb Denis said to me "I'm an honest man"....Yeah right!!!! More
by Fiat_NYC
Employees Worked With
Caleb Denis
August 28, 2012
I went into the FIAT dealership with my two small children. We saw this beautiful, black FIAT 500 Abarth on display. I was not planning to purchase a car since I leave in Manhattan, I already own a V children. We saw this beautiful, black FIAT 500 Abarth on display. I was not planning to purchase a car since I leave in Manhattan, I already own a Vespa and I love using the subway. Anyhow, Mr Cooper was so gentle and friendly. He took all of us in the garage and he showed us few FIAT 500. Never ask me to buy one, he was just very professional. We went back to the showroom, we looked at the black FIAT 500 Abarth again and I just asked him to turn the engine on. It sounded as a Ferrari or an Aston Martin. Few hours later I was already driving downtown Manhattan. The car is fast, comfortable, and fun, a lot of fun. I get compliments every time I took it. FIAT also offered me a one year $ 99.00 a month parking garage! One of the best deal ever in New York unless you win the Lotto!!! I greatly recommend working with Mr Cooper. Salvatore More
by denuccio
Employees Worked With
Taron Cooper
August 20, 2012
I am not one to write on review sites, but my experience I am not one to write on review sites, but my experience at Fiat of Manhattan with Lemiron Starling and Caleb Denis has compelled me to write to help I am not one to write on review sites, but my experience at Fiat of Manhattan with Lemiron Starling and Caleb Denis has compelled me to write to help insure that unsuspecting New Yorkers won’t fall for Lemiron Starling and Caleb Denis’s lies, manipulations and falsehoods that they perpetrate at Fiat of Manhattan. I am going to quickly outline what I view as the dishonest and frankly, inhuman way that the sales staff of Fiat of Manhattan (Lemiron Starling and Caleb Denis ) try to, (in my opinion,) STEAL money from unsuspecting car buyers or leasers. ONE: Lemiron Starling and Caleb Denis do the “BAIT and SWITCH”. I had been over there with my girlfriend a couple of days earlier, and I had also brought my Honda Fit over so they could see it for they said they could buy out my lease. I called Lemiron Starling to get a final price. He told me on the phone that they would give me $345 a month to lease the car (with the Honda buyback) with $2500 down. When we arrived with $1000 cash payment in hand to reserve the car, Lemiron Starling said “Oh I am sorry, that price was for financing - I made a MISTAKE. The price for Leasing is really $409 with $2500 down. It wasn’t a mistake. Lemiron Starling sells cars for a living. You don’t make that kind of mistake when it comes to numbers. It was the classic BAIT and SWITCH. SHAME ON YOU, Honda of Manhattan. And Shame on me for falling for it. TWO: Lemiron Starling and Caleb Denis tried to charge us a $895 leasing fee from ALLY Financing. After some checking at another dealer, I found out that the fee from ALLY is only $295. That is STEALING in my book. THREE: Lemiron Starling and Caleb Denis never inform customers that the $99 a month New York City parking deal that comes with a New Fiat (really $117 with tax) is only for NEW Quik Park customers. After some checking I found out that if you are a current Quik Park customer, the rate does not apply for you. FOUR: They will RUN DOWN THE STREET to get you back and manipulate you more.These guys will do whatever it takes to work you over the coals. After trying to negotiate the final amount down to a reasonable level, I told Lemiron that we could not go any lower and to call us on Monday if he could find a way to make it work. My girlfriend and I left. Not 5 minutes later, Lemiron is chasing us down the street saying : “Yes, I worked it out with Caleb! We will give you your price!” We walked back, and the same nonsense continued. FIVE: Lemiron Starling ASKED for a CASH PAYMENT to negotiate! I didn’t give it to him, but Lemiron Starling kept asking. Incredible. FIVE: After I asked Lemiron Starling if (x amount of money) would be the FINAL amount that I would owe, that I would bring in to pick up the new Fiat, Lemiron Starling said “Yes.” (My girlfriend who was there with me witnessed it too.) So we signed the contracts, giving Lemiron Starling a $1000 cash deposit to secure the car which he took to Mr. Dennis. My girlfriend and I then started planning our vacation with the new Fiat knowing that we would pick it up the following Friday as we waited for Lemiron to return. Then Lemiron Starling came back (now get this!) with a NEW contract, asking me to sign it AGAIN, saying that the numbers were in the wrong places. Under one line on the new contract was some tiny unreadable words scribbled in saying something which we couldn’t read. “What is that? I asked. “Oh that is just taxes and fees. It is nothing. “ Lemiron replied “How much exactly will that be?” I said defiantly. Lemiron Starling said “ Oh, it is nothing.” I requested he go and find out the exact amount. Again, Lemiron Starling said “ Oh it is nothing.” I said, “Please go and find out the exact amount.” Lemiron Starling came back and told me that it would be $1700 dollars more!!! I was flabbergasted. I asked for my money back. “Oh, let’s talk about this..” Lemiron warbled. I immediately went to Caleb Denis’s desk, (who seems to me to be the mastermind of this scam.) “I need my $1000 back.” I said calmly. “What seems to be the problem?” Caleb Denis replied. ? “What seems to be the problem? You know what the problem is.” I responded trying not to make a scene. “Let’s talk about this.” Caleb Denis pontificated like he was Tony Soprano. I said. “Give me my money back now, or I am going to call the police. I will be waiting over there.” In about 5 minutes, Lemiron Starling came back with our $1000 deposit. No apologies. My girlfriend and I couldn’t even look at him. We counted the cash to insure it was all there and we left, having lost THREE hours of precious life with this ridiculousness, feeling disgusted, and frankly, emotionally beat up. I called Fiat USA main offices and spoke with a woman asking for someone to call me to help deal with the situation. It has been a week and no one has contacted me. Here’s the big question: DOES FIAT of USA condone this type of lying and manipulation that was perpetrated at Fiat of Manhattan in order to make money? How about a good product at a good price? Don’t go anywhere near Fiat of Manhattan. Never in my life have I experienced such dishonesty at a car dealership. More
by KenWolf1
Employees Worked With
Lemiron Starling, Caleb Dennis
August 16, 2012
The dealership is clean, nicely set up & in a convenient location. Display models are available to sit in and drive. Griffin Green is very pleasant, friendly and extremely knowledgeable. it wa convenient location. Display models are available to sit in and drive. Griffin Green is very pleasant, friendly and extremely knowledgeable. it was a pleasure to decide which car to buy from him within the dealership. the negotiating process with the manager (through Griffin)was very very slow i almost gave up once the price was decided the manager added a $1000 charge that was not discussed i was walking out so they took it off im glad i stayed & leased the car Rachelle in finance was very thorough regarding all the possible added coverage she was very nice to work with as well. i really like the car More
by normanys
Employees Worked With
Griffin Green & Rachel in finance
August 15, 2012
While the employees were very nice, they almost seemed reluctant to give me a breakdown on the price of the car and terms of the lease. They ultimately gave me the information. The salesmen did too much o reluctant to give me a breakdown on the price of the car and terms of the lease. They ultimately gave me the information. The salesmen did too much of the back and forth, good/bad cop routine; however, i got what i wanted. The sale took too long (nearly 5 hours). I caught the dealer on a few bait and switches, but whn i did they backed off. Overall, i love the car and hd a favorable transaction More
by Bearesq
Employees Worked With
Various
August 10, 2012
Caleb Denis and Angela were very professional and friendly......angela went over the car with my wife and was very exacting with all the details.....i took videos of my wife in the car along with an friendly......angela went over the car with my wife and was very exacting with all the details.....i took videos of my wife in the car along with angela showing how happy my wife is with the little italian....being that my wife is a full blown italian and myself half an italian..... More
by lowride37
Employees Worked With
angela ramsumair
July 23, 2012
We were immediately approached. Lemiron was very friendly and informative but not high pressured. He was very patient and courteous as he answered all our questions. The entire process of leasing friendly and informative but not high pressured. He was very patient and courteous as he answered all our questions. The entire process of leasing the FIAT was painless and fun with Lemiron. It was nice to meet Caleb Dennis, the Director who was also friendly. We think the opportunity of parking our FIAT in Manhattan for $99.00 a month is a genius idea and was the deciding factor in our decision to lease a FIAT. More
by Patricia Hogan
Employees Worked With
Lemiron Starling Caleb Dennis
July 12, 2012
Lemiron has excellent customer service. He was so friendly and knowledgeable. He made my car buying experience and pleasant one. Thank you so much Fiat of Manhattan. friendly and knowledgeable. He made my car buying experience and pleasant one. Thank you so much Fiat of Manhattan. More
by chocchic
Employees Worked With
Lemiron Starling
July 10, 2012
I decided to look into leasing a Pop after hearing this dealer's commercial on the radio about the $99/month lease and the $99/month parking in Manhattan. Since I already have another car and was already p dealer's commercial on the radio about the $99/month lease and the $99/month parking in Manhattan. Since I already have another car and was already paying for a parking space in Manhattan, I wasn't desperate for the car. Figured the savings in gas and parking was worth checking out. I spoke to Caleb a couple of days before I was able to make it into the studio, he was helpful enough on the phone to actually get me into the studio. When I got there on Saturday afternoon, I was set up with Angela. Within 20 minutes I was test driving the car. After a hour or so, we worked out the numbers and I was on my way to getting a new Fiat. Unfortunately because I needed an automatic, they didn't have the color that I was interested in. By Friday, they were able to locate one of my color choices from another dealer. I went back into the studio on Friday evening to finalize all the paperwork and pick up the car...but the car wasn't there. It was a bit frustrating to have been there for almost 2 hours to fill out paperwork and still leave without a car. Granted it wasn't their fault the other dealership wasn't able to deliver the car as promised. Both Angela and Caleb were extremely helpful and friendly. More
by lauralau
Employees Worked With
Angela Ramsumair & Caleb Denis
