Dealer Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
Island Kia
Staten Island, NY
177 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Service Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
177 Reviews of Island Kia
January 28, 2026
Dealer a joke, I had to pay both the same month for my old lease and the new one because it fell on the day after payment, even though I'm a repeat customer. Payment huge for a 2024 Kia Seltos. Car is lik old lease and the new one because it fell on the day after payment, even though I'm a repeat customer. Payment huge for a 2024 Kia Seltos. Car is like cracker jack box car, constant issues since I got it and the service center is awful. You can wait weeks for minor issues and they offer an uber home. What good is that if you work. I'm so dissatisfied with them and this car! More
by suzieq.joe
Employees Worked With
Vincent Macaluso
December 31, 2025
Service center negligence caused my car to go on fire and be totaled and the service center laughed at me, literally, saying "what do you want us to do about it?" be totaled and the service center laughed at me, literally, saying "what do you want us to do about it?" More
by Pweesant
Employees Worked With
Service center employee refused to put manager on the phone
October 15, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Vinny the Car Don is incredible! He helped me get out of my lease a year early and had me driving a brand-new car, all in the same day. The whole process was fast, smooth, and stres He helped me get out of my lease a year early and had me driving a brand-new car, all in the same day. The whole process was fast, smooth, and stress-free. Vinny went above and beyond to make it happen. If you’re looking for your next car, you have to go see him . true 5-star service More
by Erika
Employees Worked With
Vincent Macaluso
August 14, 2025
Horrible service and unprofessional staff! Dropped my car off only for multi point check and they did oil change and tire rotation without asking me first. The car was leased 3 months ago and Dropped my car off only for multi point check and they did oil change and tire rotation without asking me first. The car was leased 3 months ago and not due for oil change or tire rotation, they just do whatever for money! More
by Carguy
Employees Worked With
Collin
April 27, 2025
Second lease from the best dealership & best salesperson. James was awesome and efficient throughout the whole process. Answered all questions, got me a good payment, and set up everything for me. Check out James was awesome and efficient throughout the whole process. Answered all questions, got me a good payment, and set up everything for me. Check out island kia and ask for James! More
by Ashley
Employees Worked With
James Greco
June 24, 2022
Wow what an easy seamless experience. I dealt with Kim and Maria and they were both amazing. Will never shop for another car anywhere else. Thanks Island Auto Group! I dealt with Kim and Maria and they were both amazing. Will never shop for another car anywhere else. Thanks Island Auto Group! More
by Liebo11
Employees Worked With
Vincent Crispino
October 06, 2021
Great experience with Tay with the buying process everything was quick in and out and provided excellent service and pricing on car we wanted even with shortages. Shout out to enyjah as well for everything was quick in and out and provided excellent service and pricing on car we wanted even with shortages. Shout out to enyjah as well for customer success help More
by Nj Kishan
Employees Worked With
Taylan Saylak
April 28, 2021
Was not helpful. Went to see and text drive a used car. It was hit in the front and back which was not disclosed prior. Would not negotiate a price. In fact, tried to add to the price because it wasn’t cer It was hit in the front and back which was not disclosed prior. Would not negotiate a price. In fact, tried to add to the price because it wasn’t certified. SMH. More
by jse698
Employees Worked With
Don’t remember.
