Dealer Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
McGrath Evanston Subaru
Skokie, IL
354 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Service Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
Showing 354 reviews
February 24, 2026
I had a very productive meeting with Brendan. He answered all of the questions I had prepared in advance and offered additional guidance on many of the features of my new Forester. It was worthwh He answered all of the questions I had prepared in advance and offered additional guidance on many of the features of my new Forester. It was worthwhile for me to take the time to come in and do the redelivery in person as he could physically show me how to access each of the options available. Thank you Brendan! More
by Chris on LSD
Employees Worked With
February 18, 2026
Winston is a good salesperson to work with. Appreciated the transparency he provided. Made the buying process a pleasant experience. Appreciated the transparency he provided. Made the buying process a pleasant experience. More
by nic
Employees Worked With
February 18, 2026
Quick and easy arranged a lease with Lou in advance of my old lease ending. Picked my color and they had it ready for me when I needed it for a smooth and seamless swap. Easiest car experience I’ve ever old lease ending. Picked my color and they had it ready for me when I needed it for a smooth and seamless swap. Easiest car experience I’ve ever had. More
by S.F.
February 14, 2026
German was so patient, kind honest and informative. He stayed past closing time just to help walk me through the car and app and I bought it. He supported me through the negotiation process and I never He stayed past closing time just to help walk me through the car and app and I bought it. He supported me through the negotiation process and I never felt like I was forced to agree to a deal I didnt want. I would buy a car from him again! More
by Annashlimon
February 13, 2026
Very pleasant experience. I randomly brought my car in for express service. JP clearly explained everything about the service and recommendations. My car was finished in a ti I randomly brought my car in for express service. JP clearly explained everything about the service and recommendations. My car was finished in a timely fashion. More
by mcdon4
Employees Worked With
JP Rutkowski
February 13, 2026
Brendan was professional, knowledgeable, and personable. After our session with him we felt much more in tune with our new Crosstrek. After our session with him we felt much more in tune with our new Crosstrek. More
by abbot-serifs8z
Employees Worked With
February 12, 2026
We purchased a 2025 Forester Hybrid Limited on January 8. Brendan and I spent over an hour together today, answering the questions that I had written down first, and then he detailed many areas of control th Brendan and I spent over an hour together today, answering the questions that I had written down first, and then he detailed many areas of control that I didn't even know were there. I consider myself pretty good at figuring out tech stuff, so I'm not a complete dullard when it comes to this, but Brandon clearly knows the vehicle inside and out. He's patient and goes above and beyond, which he did with me today. Thank you, Brandon! More
by WhitIV
February 12, 2026
Mcgrath Evanston Subaru works with Mcgrath Hyundai to sell hyundais with known defects so they can get around the consumer and business laws. They Sold me a 2017 Hyundai Sonata Sport with a known defect sell hyundais with known defects so they can get around the consumer and business laws. They Sold me a 2017 Hyundai Sonata Sport with a known defect went in with my warranty they wanted me get 2k worth of parts that aren’t covered under warranty and then they recommended me go to one of hyundai stores because I need a new engine, that’s when I was informed about the class action lawsuit. They claim they were informed about the lawsuit November 2025 but Hyundai knew about the defect since 2017 and can’t sell a car with a known defect so they send it to a subaru dealer who can sell a car with a known defect and play ignorant so they don’t have to share with the consumer. They won’t honor my warranty. The car engine exploded at 106k miles, and the people who got scammed into buying these cars claims the engines are only good until 100,000 More
by Janienja
February 12, 2026
The people who work here are amazing ! Herman was kind and knowledgeable as my salesperson . The new Forester was a little intimidating with the advance technology , but Brendan took t Herman was kind and knowledgeable as my salesperson . The new Forester was a little intimidating with the advance technology , but Brendan took time to explain all of the different features, making sure that I left feeling confident . He was patient and extremely knowledgeable. I have recommended this Subaru dealership to all of my friends and family . They also have the BEST service department ! More
by jeanysontag
February 05, 2026
Been a "Service customer" at this location since 2011 or 2012. They are wonderful In late Jan 2026, I had a big Service done and Juan our Service Rep. was really helpful, knowledgable and Polite!!! A shout 2012. They are wonderful In late Jan 2026, I had a big Service done and Juan our Service Rep. was really helpful, knowledgable and Polite!!! A shout out to the technicians as well More
by J.R.
Employees Worked With
