Dealer Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
Mike Barney Nissan
Amherst, NY
187 Reviews
At Mike Barney Nissan, we take pride in being a part of the Western New York community and beyond — proudly serving customers from all over the area. Whether you’re in the market for a new Nissan, a dependable pre-loved vehicle, or simply need service you can trust, our team is here to make every experience simple, straightforward, and stress-free.
Our buzzing showroom is designed with you in mind. Sit back and enjoy complimentary beverages and take in the energy! We offer everything from comprehensive maintenance and repair on any make or model to our Quick Lane oil change service — no appointment necessary — we make it easy to keep your vehicle in top condition. Our factory-trained technicians use the latest tools and technology to ensure every job is done right, the first time.
As the #1 Nissan Volume Dealer from Western New York to Albany and back, we’ve earned our reputation through hard work, transparency, and a true commitment to our guests. But what really sets us apart is our people. With over 45 years strong being the only locally family-owned Nissan dealership in the area, owners Joe Caldarelli and Scott Horvatits have built a culture centered on community, teamwork, and customer care. They strive each day to create a fun, welcoming environment where car buying and servicing your vehicle feels easy and enjoyable.
At Mike Barney Nissan, our goal is simple — to provide every customer with an exceptional experience from the moment you walk through our doors. Whether you’re purchasing your first car, bringing your vehicle in for service, or just stopping by for a cup of coffee, we’re here to make sure you feel like part of the family.
Call us today for all your vehicle needs at 716-833-9888
Read More
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Service Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Hours
Sales/Showroom
Monday 9:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Tuesday 9:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Wednesday 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Thursday 9:00 AM - 7:00 PM
Friday 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Saturday 9:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Sunday Closed
Service
Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed
Thursday Closed
Friday Closed
Saturday Closed
Sunday Closed
Parts
Monday Closed
Tuesday Closed
Wednesday Closed
Thursday Closed
Friday Closed
Saturday Closed
Sunday Closed
Filter Reviews By Type
Showing 187 reviews
March 31, 2026
Brought my son there to buy his very first car and after one year of the engine blew up. It took Leon in his crew 4 months to get the car back to me. Never offered a loaner vehicle. Communication was very one year of the engine blew up. It took Leon in his crew 4 months to get the car back to me. Never offered a loaner vehicle. Communication was very very poor. The day we pick the car up the service light came on. We had to take it back in. that’s the day Joshua repeatedly called me a liar and argued with me outside the garage over a loaner vehicle. I would never recommend this car dealership. Their service department is terrible. I didn’t mention up above, but the first engine they put in did not work they had to put a second engine in the and all is we treated this car in with a different car dealership and have moved on, but I do want to mention the service light came back on More
by arbaraeaton
Verified Customer
March 31, 2026
Great place. Very helpful customer service. Easy appointment schedule both online and via phone Very satisfied Very helpful customer service. Easy appointment schedule both online and via phone Very satisfied More
by VYAKUBOVSKAYA98
March 29, 2026
Amazing people who show they care. Everyone helping out and making sure everyone feels welcomed. Refreshing to see smiles. Everyone helping out and making sure everyone feels welcomed. Refreshing to see smiles. More
by Kayleejunegallant
March 29, 2026
This place is a total scam please …beware do not send your wife in there alone !!!A simple oil change turned into a 3 week disaster because the under qualified technician destroyed the skid plate bolts your wife in there alone !!!A simple oil change turned into a 3 week disaster because the under qualified technician destroyed the skid plate bolts and still couldn’t get the oil filter off . They just changed the oil but not the oil filter then said the frame is so rusted on a 2021 that the bolts just snapped off !!!!she put me on FaceTime and insisted to show her the proof then everything changed as they could no longer lie and you can clearly see the damage a under qualified technician did with all this being said I fixed the skid plate and snapped bolts on my back in the drive way in 45 mnz. ..which the under qualified tech said they were unable to do it…lol what a joke they destroy and you have to fix …what a-shame this was my local dealership not anymore! More
by Joe k 81
Employees Worked With
Other Employees :
Under qualified technician
March 28, 2026
Took care of my breaks, oil change, and tire rotation in a couple of hours with no appointment. The courtesy shuttle service brought me home and back and was very convenient. a couple of hours with no appointment. The courtesy shuttle service brought me home and back and was very convenient. More
by j.strohmeier12
Employees Worked With
March 26, 2026
The best experience that I have ever had. Dave Croom and Jeremy McLaughlin were great. I was taken care of and happy with my new lease. Thank you for being so nice to me. Love you guys, Miche Dave Croom and Jeremy McLaughlin were great. I was taken care of and happy with my new lease. Thank you for being so nice to me. Love you guys, Michele More
by silverrings71
March 26, 2026
They were very understanding of my dilemma and got the work done on my car as fast as they could. It actually was delivered a day earlier than expected. Appreciated it. work done on my car as fast as they could. It actually was delivered a day earlier than expected. Appreciated it. More
by Jlahpyml
Employees Worked With
Randy
