Dealer Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
Paul Miller Toyota
Pine Brook, NJ
770 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Service Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
770 Reviews of Paul Miller Toyota
September 03, 2026
The service is top tier. And the facility is brand new, they did an awesome job.As well as the services you received. I had the pleasure of having a young lady named Kelsey a And the facility is brand new, they did an awesome job.As well as the services you received. I had the pleasure of having a young lady named Kelsey as my receptionist for my vehicle. And she was very tentative and explanatory to all of my options concerning my vehicle. Which her strong assets are communication. Ultimately, I love this new service center. More
by Thomas
Employees Worked With
Kelsey
August 29, 2026
Customers deserve respect, honest pricing, and fair financing options. Unfortunately, because of this experience, I decided not to purchase the vehicle. I would not recommend this dealership based on m financing options. Unfortunately, because of this experience, I decided not to purchase the vehicle. I would not recommend this dealership based on my experience. More
by Vieira
Employees Worked With
Jamie Berrios
August 09, 2026
I had received a nice hospitality, service representative was Professional and courtesy, waiting area was nice and clean, I received a video from the service technician about the condition of the car, keep u was Professional and courtesy, waiting area was nice and clean, I received a video from the service technician about the condition of the car, keep up the good work. thank you More
by Sabamed8
Employees Worked With
Robert Kaba, Jamie Berrios
July 27, 2026
worst experience in my life. First of all over charged compare to quotes then change the price. I HAVE 4 Toyota vehicles & never go with this dealer & don't recommend anyone in m First of all over charged compare to quotes then change the price. I HAVE 4 Toyota vehicles & never go with this dealer & don't recommend anyone in my life..Bryan was worst service advisor. More
by Kkhandhar1
Employees Worked With
Bryan service advisor
July 23, 2026
I had a very nice experience. It was my first stop to look at upgrading my Tacoma. Umair listened to what I wanted and then proceeded to show me their options. Was completely sat It was my first stop to look at upgrading my Tacoma. Umair listened to what I wanted and then proceeded to show me their options. Was completely satified. More
by jcarvagno
Employees Worked With
I didn't meet Jamie but Sam and Umair took good care of me.
July 11, 2026
Chris, with the assistance of Victor and Ernest, were extremely helpful in my leasing of a new Camry. I knew what l wanted and they provided it pleasantly and with transparency and capability. The pricin extremely helpful in my leasing of a new Camry. I knew what l wanted and they provided it pleasantly and with transparency and capability. The pricing and terms were fair. I look forward to continuing to work with them as the documents and license plates are prepared. I highly recommend the Paul Miller Toyota dealership in West Caldwell, NJ. More
by curriejr
Employees Worked With
Chris Zak, Ernest Gomez, Victor ?
