I have completely lost confidence in Ira Toyota of
Manchester after my most recent service experience.
I brought my 2021 Toyota RAV4 in for service and was initially told that the oil pan drain plu
Manchester after my most recent service experience.
I brought my 2021 Toyota RAV4 in for service and was initially told that the oil pan drain plug threads were cross threaded and stripped and that the oil pan needed to be replaced. This immediately concerned me because my oil changes have been performed through Toyota, including an oil change at this dealership only approximately two months ago.
When I questioned how the threads could be cross threaded when Toyota technicians have been servicing the vehicle, the explanation suddenly changed. After I pushed back and management became involved, I was then told the threads were simply worn down and that this was normal wear and tear.
That change in explanation is extremely troubling to me. If the threads were simply worn from normal use, why was I initially told they were cross threaded and stripped? And if they were already severely worn, why was nothing mentioned during my oil change here approximately two months ago? I came looking for a reasonable explanation and assistance, not a diagnosis that seemed to change after I questioned whether the dealership could bear responsibility.
Unfortunately, my interaction with management made the situation considerably worse. When I went in hoping to have a professional conversation about my concerns, the manager began by asking whether I was going to watch the Patriots game. When I tried to discuss the actual issue and challenged the explanation I was receiving, I felt dismissed rather than heard. I was essentially told that I was wrong, that he knew what he was talking about, not to tell him what to say or do, and most disappointing of all, that the dealership would make money with or without my business.
Regardless of who ultimately bears responsibility for the oil pan threads, that is an unacceptable way to speak to a customer who is simply asking legitimate questions about a potentially expensive repair.
I was not asking anyone to blindly accept responsibility. I was asking them to explain why the original diagnosis was cross threading and stripped threads, why that explanation subsequently became normal wear and tear, and why this supposedly significant wear was not identified when the dealership serviced the same drain plug approximately two months earlier.
I chose Toyota dealership service because I believed it offered a higher level of expertise, accountability, and confidence in the work being performed. After this experience, I no longer have that confidence.
I sincerely hope the owner or general manager of Ira Toyota of Manchester contacts me directly and reviews both the technician's original findings and my vehicle's service history. I would genuinely like an explanation of what happened and an opportunity for someone at this dealership to restore the trust that was lost today.
More
by Angelad2016
Service Price Transparency
Sep 24, 2026 -
Ira Toyota of Manchester responded
We are sorry to hear that you feel this matter has not been resolved to your satisfaction. We have carefully reviewed the documentation, photographs, videos, and communications related to your vehicle to ensure that we have not overlooked any of the concerns you raised. Based on our review, the drain plug threads are in excellent condition and do not show evidence consistent with cross-threading. The oil pan itself, however, shows wear and needs repair. Based on our review, the condition of the oil pan is consistent with normal wear over time and is not the result of neglect or improper workmanship by our technician. Additionally, our records include communication documenting your authorization for the brake fluid flush. That service was also provided to you at a discounted price. We understand how frustrating it can be when a higher-mileage vehicle begins to require repairs due to the wear of various components. However, after thoroughly reviewing the information available to us, we have not found evidence that the concerns with the oil pan resulted from improper workmanship or negligence by our technician. Rather, the condition is consistent with wear and tear that can occur over the life of the vehicle. We appreciate you giving us the opportunity to review your concerns thoroughly and to clarify our findings. John McCarthy General Manager
Sep 29, 2026 -
Angelad2016 responded
I would not trust Ira Toyota of Manchester with my vehicle again.
I brought my vehicle here for routine service and left facing an expensive oil-pan repair. Their own technician documented that the “drain plug came out rough” and that threads from the oil pan came off with/on the drain plug.
My vehicle has been routinely serviced by Toyota, which means the drain plug has necessarily been removed and reinstalled during previous oil changes. Yet prior to this visit, I had never been advised that the oil-pan threads were worn or damaged. Rather than seriously addressing whether previous installation, over-tightening, cross-threading, or repeated servicing could have contributed to the damaged threads, Ira Toyota has taken the position that this is simply normal “wear and tear” and denies responsibility.
In its response to my BBB complaint, the dealership emphasized that the drain plug itself is in excellent condition while the oil pan shows wear. But that does not address my concern. The issue is the damaged threads in the oil pan where the drain plug is repeatedly removed and reinstalled during oil changes, not whether the metal drain plug itself looks good. Their own technician documented that the plug “came out rough” and that oil-pan threads came off with/on the plug.
I also verbally declined a brake-fluid flush before the work was performed. They performed it anyway. I subsequently signed the final paperwork and paid the bill after the work had already been completed, but paying for completed work is not the same as giving permission beforehand. The dealership now points to “authorization” while failing to acknowledge that I verbally declined the service before it was performed.
This is also not the first time I have had concerns involving brake-related recommendations or charges here. Taken together, these experiences have left me with very little confidence in this service department or in the way management handles customer disputes.
I tried to resolve this directly with management, escalated the matter to Toyota, and filed a BBB complaint. Instead of offering a reasonable resolution, management has continued to deny responsibility for the oil-pan issue and defend the disputed brake-fluid service.
What makes this even more disappointing is that I was planning to purchase a new vehicle and had intended to continue doing business with this dealership. Ira Toyota of Manchester has now lost that sale as well as my future service business because of how this situation was handled. After this experience, I would not feel comfortable purchasing another vehicle from them.
My advice to other customers: document everything, clearly state which services you do and do not authorize, keep your previous service records, and carefully read the technician’s notes before paying.
I will not be returning to Ira Toyota of Manchester for service or to purchase my next vehicle.
Extraordinary effort, knowledgeable sales and service
team that goes above and beyond. Terrific communication from start to finish. Total pros, very transparent and high integrity the entire time! They s
team that goes above and beyond. Terrific communication from start to finish. Total pros, very transparent and high integrity the entire time! They set a high standard for all dealerships!
More
by Connecticutgal
Jul 26, 2026 -
Ira Toyota of Manchester responded
Hi, we're happy to hear you had such a positive experience with our team! We sincerely thank you for the positive review, and look forward to seeing you again soon!
Mo was a sweetheart to work with.
I would highly recommend him and Ira Toyota.
I would highly recommend him and Ira Toyota.
More
by Crystal
Mar 27, 2026 -
Ira Toyota of Manchester responded
Hi Crystal, thanks for your praise and kind comments about our team. Feel free to reach out to us if you need anything. Have a wonderful day.
Great experience and service!
I never had any complaints or issues, in the many years I’ve been going to Manchester Ira Toyota to buy, trade, lease, and service all my Toyota vehi
I never had any complaints or issues, in the many years I’ve been going to Manchester Ira Toyota to buy, trade, lease, and service all my Toyota vehicles. My number one place for the best of the best in the automotive industry.
More
by slewald
Service Price Transparency
Jan 16, 2026 -
Ira Toyota of Manchester responded
Hi, we are very happy we could provide you with a positive experience! Please don't hesitate to reach out if there's anything additional we can do for you.
MO HOOKED ME UP WITH A NEW TUNDRA.
I WOULD RECOMMEND MO AND RICKY AT IRA TOYOTA IF YOU NEED A NEW CAR OR TRUCK.
I WOULD RECOMMEND MO AND RICKY AT IRA TOYOTA IF YOU NEED A NEW CAR OR TRUCK.
More
by SEMI
Dec 30, 2025 -
Ira Toyota of Manchester responded
Hi, thank you for your kind review; we are happy to pass along your comments to the team here at Ira Toyota of Manchester! If you ever need anything else from us, please feel free to give us a call or stop by. Have an awesome day!
I had a fantastic experience at IRA TOYOTA My salesperson
MO was incredibly professional, knowledgeable, and truly made me feel valued, not pressured. He patiently explained all the features of my new Toyota
MO was incredibly professional, knowledgeable, and truly made me feel valued, not pressured. He patiently explained all the features of my new Toyota corolla cross, ensuring I understood everything before I drove off. The finance team was also great, and the whole process was smooth and stress-free, from browsing to taking the keys. I highly recommend asking for Mo if you're looking for an honest, helpful, and genuinely friendly guide to finding your perfect car!".
More
by gaurilama0077
Dec 30, 2025 -
Ira Toyota of Manchester responded
Hi, thank you for your kind review; we are happy to pass along your comments to the team here at Ira Toyota of Manchester! If you ever need anything else from us, please feel free to give us a call or stop by. Have an awesome day!
Mo was very very helpful.
As being a new driver I couldn’t drive in snow he drove me home even in 3 ft snow.He also helped me with all the paperwork and insurance.
As being a new driver I couldn’t drive in snow he drove me home even in 3 ft snow.He also helped me with all the paperwork and insurance.
More
by Mukesh.gurung123
Dec 25, 2025 -
Ira Toyota of Manchester responded
Hi, we're happy to hear you had such a positive experience with our team! Please let us know if there is anything else we can do for you; we are more than happy to help!
Very friendly and welcoming.
It was snowing sooo much that he came to drop us off in our new car.
It was snowing sooo much that he came to drop us off in our new car.
More
by Sandhyagurung656
Dec 25, 2025 -
Ira Toyota of Manchester responded
Hi, we are very happy to have provided you with such a positive experience! Please don't hesitate to reach out if there's anything additional we can do for you.
I got in at the time of my appointment, and only about a
hour ,and I was back on the road ,not bad at all.
hour ,and I was back on the road ,not bad at all.
More
by ckeyman123
Service Price Transparency
Nov 26, 2025 -
Ira Toyota of Manchester responded
Hi, we are very happy to have provided you with such a positive experience! Please don't hesitate to reach out if there's anything additional we can do for you.
The service was done in a timely manner, and the fee was
very reasonable. The service advisor was very nice.
very reasonable. The service advisor was very nice.
More
by astaritaginny0
Service Price Transparency
Nov 06, 2025 -
Ira Toyota of Manchester responded
Hi, we are very happy to have provided you with such a positive experience! If you ever need anything else from us, please feel free to give us a call or stop by. Have an awesome day!