Dealer Reviews

Cars for Sale

Write a Review

Dealer Log In

Write a Review

Michael Rutherford

Overview Reviews (101)

Contact Me

View All Employees

< View All Employees

Michael Rutherford

Sales & Leasing Consultant/ Commercial Specialist

Fred Martin Superstore

3195 Barber Rd
Barberton, OH 44203

My name is Mike, I love to help people and do everything I can to make your day better. I am New and Used vehicle sales. Also I am the Commercial Specialist at Fred Martin. I can help you out in anyway to get you going in your next vehicle. Whether it be for yourself or your business. If I’m not at work, I am spending time with both of my daughters and wife. They are the reason I work so hard so I can provide them a life they deserve. I am here everyday for them to have anything they ever want or need. I also love to ride quads and be outside when I can. The outdoors is where I want to be doing anything I can to enjoy the weather. You got to love Ohio.

Contact Me

4.7

101 Reviews

Overview Reviews (101)

Dealership Experience

5 yrs, 5 mos

Industry Experience

5 yrs, 5 mos

Specialties & Trainings

Ram Expert

Chrysler Expert

Dodge Expert

Jeep Expert

Commercial Specialist

Used Vehicle Sales

New Vehicles Sales Expert

View more specialties & trainings

4.7

101 Reviews

Write a Review

This rating includes all reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.

Contact Michael Rutherford

Name

Email or Mobile Phone

Message

By clicking Send Message, you agree to receive automated texts to connect you to this dealership employee, to market and provide information, and to better serve you. Purchase is not required and you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Standard message and data rates may apply.

101 Reviews of Michael Rutherford

August 21, 2026

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

I purchased a car here and when I mentioned it had issues with the engine missing when I was test driving, the guy told me that it was the way it drove but I am still having issues with the engine missing an with the engine missing when I was test driving, the guy told me that it was the way it drove but I am still having issues with the engine missing and it’s only gotten worse the three months I’ve had it due to a transmission issue. Will never go here again and they also sold me the car and had me sign before I knew it was being sold as as. More

by kppbabygirl

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Aug 21, 2026 -

Fred Martin Superstore responded

Good morning. We're sorry to hear that your vehicle is experiencing issues. Please understand that the vehicle was sold As-Is without any warranties or representations of any kind. While we hear your frustration regarding the paperwork, we do want to clarify that the As-Is status of every vehicle is clearly outlined, signed for, and agreed to prior to purchase. Included in this paperwork is a statement where we also suggest that the customer has the vehicle independently inspected prior to purchase. We again apologize that this was your experience, but this unfortunately can happen with an As-Is purchase. We thank you for your comments.

August 06, 2026

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

Excellent service, easiest two cars I have ever purchased. Joe Van Jura and Mike Rutherford are both great guys to work with. 10 out of 10 will get my business again purchased. Joe Van Jura and Mike Rutherford are both great guys to work with. 10 out of 10 will get my business again More

by Egarrettracing

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Joe Van Jura

Aug 10, 2026 -

Fred Martin Superstore responded

Thank you for your kind words and for your business! We're happy to here our team could help! Thank you again and congratulations on your purchases!

March 26, 2026

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

Mike Rutherford was awesome to deal with from start to finish. Great overall buying experience. Would highly recommend them to anyone looking for a new Ram truck. finish. Great overall buying experience. Would highly recommend them to anyone looking for a new Ram truck. More

by tthomas1less

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Mar 27, 2026 -

Fred Martin Superstore responded

We love to hear it! Thank you so much for your kind words and for your 5-star review! Congratulations on your new Ram and we look forward to seeing you again!

February 13, 2026

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

Michael was amazing, making our entire experience wonderful. He listened to every detail we wanted and found us the perfect Truck! He went above and beyond making sure we were happy from the time we wonderful. He listened to every detail we wanted and found us the perfect Truck! He went above and beyond making sure we were happy from the time we walked in to we drove our new truck away! Thank you Michael Rutherford and the entire Fred Martin team! More

by rutherfordj24

Sales Price Transparency

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Feb 16, 2026 -

Fred Martin Superstore responded

We love to hear it! Thank you for your kind words and for your business. Congratulations on your purchase and we look forward to seeing you again!

February 01, 2026

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

I leased a Jeep Grand Cherokee Limited twice from this dealership and have always had a great experience. I love the car and the features. dealership and have always had a great experience. I love the car and the features. More

by hsams34

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Ben Petrone

Feb 02, 2026 -

Fred Martin Superstore responded

We love to hear it! Thank you for your kind words and for your continued support of our dealership. Congratulations on your new Jeep Lease and we look forward to your next visit!

December 23, 2025

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

Matt and Mike are very professional. The whole experience has been straight to the point and what they can do for you. I would shop here again in the future. I recommend giving this stor The whole experience has been straight to the point and what they can do for you. I would shop here again in the future. I recommend giving this store a try. More

by emeryjd91

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Matt Gordon

Dec 24, 2025 -

Fred Martin Superstore responded

We love to hear it! Thank you for your kind words and for your business. Congratulations on your new Ram and we look forward to seeing you again!

May 09, 2025

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

Awesome and great customer service! We worked through the process together with efficiency and got me on the road! We worked through the process together with efficiency and got me on the road! More

by Jay V

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Kelli Slavens

May 09, 2025 -

Fred Martin Superstore responded

We love to hear it! Thank you for your kind words and for choosing to shop with us, Jay! Congratulations on your new Dodge and we hope to see you again!

April 30, 2025

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

They are very helpful and courteous. I like the dealership. I was very pleased.with the service I like the dealership. I was very pleased.with the service More

by antoncross98

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Chris Tompkins

Apr 30, 2025 -

Fred Martin Superstore responded

Thank you for your kind words and for your business! Congratulations on your new Jeep and we look forward to seeing you again!

April 25, 2025

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

Mike Rutherford was an amazing partner in completing my Kia Niro purchase. His diligence and communication in the whole process—ensuring every detail was taken care of—was impeccable. I would highly recomm Kia Niro purchase. His diligence and communication in the whole process—ensuring every detail was taken care of—was impeccable. I would highly recommend Fred Martin and Mike’s expertise to anyone in need. More

by alangay

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Apr 28, 2025 -

Fred Martin Superstore responded

We're happy to hear that Mike and our team could help out! Thank you so much for your kind words and for you business. Congratulations on your purchase and we look forward to seeing you again!

March 12, 2025

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

I LOVE IT! In and out in no time at all!! I KNEW what I wanted. I GOT what I wanted!! A jeep in the heartland!!🇺🇸😊🥰 In and out in no time at all!! I KNEW what I wanted. I GOT what I wanted!! A jeep in the heartland!!🇺🇸😊🥰 More

by taviatheclerk

Sales Price Transparency

Purchase Time

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Mar 13, 2025 -

Fred Martin Superstore responded

We're happy that our team could help! Please let us know if there is anything else we can help out with. Thank you so much for your business and for taking the time to leave us 5-stars! Congratulations on your new Jeep and we look forward to seeing you again!