Dealer Reviews
Service Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
Caitlyn Caudill
Refer Me
Caitlyn Caudill
Assistant Sales Manager
Maguire Hyundai of Grand Island
1910 Alvin Rd
Grand Island, NY 14072
14 Reviews
I am a Buffalo native, born and raised in the southern tier. An islander now. I am a loving mom and wife 🏳️🌈. I was in the back end of helping people (BDC) and finally made the jump to official help on the front line of this industry! Now that I am here I have grown in sales to become part of the management team. My mission is to make this process the best ever and the goal is to make your purchase a breeze from start to finish. Let’s have fun and make buying a car easier than ever before!
Read moreDealership Experience
1 yr, 4 mos
Industry Experience
6 yrs, 7 mos
Languages Spoken
English
14 Reviews
Write a Review
14 Reviews of Caitlyn Caudill
April 24, 2024
Easily the best Hyundai dealership in western New York. Never fails to disappoint me and the work is always great! Never fails to disappoint me and the work is always great! More
by Andrew Bernard
Verified CustomerOther Employees Tagged: Brandon Maggiore, David Croom, Andre Lane, Jerome Masters, Donnie DiPalma, Jay Staskiewicz, Ronnie Mansour, Jerrod Hawkes, Connor Burwell , Steve,
Helpful 
April 21, 2024
I’m from Orchard Park and was looking for something around 2 years old. I drove out to Maguire Hyundai because I liked the prices and selection. I walked in “to look” at a car and about 3 hours later I around 2 years old. I drove out to Maguire Hyundai because I liked the prices and selection. I walked in “to look” at a car and about 3 hours later I drove off in my new to me 2022 Elantra. Caitlyn was extremely helpful and professional. I am 58 years old and this really has been the best car buying experience I’ve ever had. I will definitely recommend Caitlyn and Maguire to all my friends and family Thank you Caitlin. More
by ttrevean
Other Employees Tagged: I cannot find Jason with finance on her. But he was awesome!!!! Saved me 1 1/2 percent on the loan my bank offered. Three thumbs up to Jason
April 08, 2024
Liz was very helpful and gracious fixing a problem that another employee didn't take care of. Thanks again. another employee didn't take care of. Thanks again. More
by romuschris4
Other Employees Tagged: Liz Robbins
October 28, 2023
Wonderful experience shopping for a new vehicle. First Ms Chrissy Gilbert and her help with my beginning questions a few months before purchase....then when i went to the dealership Mr Andre Lane wa First Ms Chrissy Gilbert and her help with my beginning questions a few months before purchase....then when i went to the dealership Mr Andre Lane was a great help and answered all my questions with a smile and never let me feel that I was just a customer. I felt very much at home with the Maguire Hyundai dealership and drove home in a nice new reliable vehicle based on Andre's help and the young lady Caitlyn who showed me how to use the Bluelink. God bless you guys and I highly recommend your dealership Thank you Andre the most Sir! More
by Anthony DelGobbo
Other Employees Tagged: Andre Lane, Jerome Masters
October 23, 2023
They did not correct the problem on my electric car. They did not reset the mileage. Detail work was about half done. Have to take it back, waste another half day of my life because they can't get it d They did not reset the mileage. Detail work was about half done. Have to take it back, waste another half day of my life because they can't get it done right the first time. More
by JIM@NIAGARASCUBA.COM
Other Employees Tagged: Jerome Masters , Bob Spink
September 13, 2023
I purchased my car from almost three hours away by phone, and the team here made the buying process so easy even though I was from out of town! I traveled to pick up the car later in the week and was met wit and the team here made the buying process so easy even though I was from out of town! I traveled to pick up the car later in the week and was met with some of the nicest people I’ve ever worked with for purchasing a vehicle. They really made sure everything was taken care of. I’m very happy with the quality of this dealership, and with my new Elantra :) More
by dsawyer96
Other Employees Tagged: David Croom, Jerome Masters
June 06, 2023
I was working with Maguire in Ithaca and found a car I liked better in Grand Island. Caitlyn worked to get me that car! I will be the proud owner of a RED Tucson! I will definitely shop here again! liked better in Grand Island. Caitlyn worked to get me that car! I will be the proud owner of a RED Tucson! I will definitely shop here again! More
by CBabino
March 30, 2023
FRIENDLY, OUTGOING, COURTOUS, VERY KNOWLEDGEABLE, OUTSTANDING SERVICE. Bought a 2023 had the most positive experience and was treated like family, then I ever had buying a vehicle. The Tuson was in p OUTSTANDING SERVICE. Bought a 2023 had the most positive experience and was treated like family, then I ever had buying a vehicle. The Tuson was in production and Caitlyn keep me informed along the whole way. Caitlyn even came in on her day off for the delivery, made me feel like family and went out of her way to make me feel comfortable and relaxed. Would definitely recommend Maguire Hyundai to everyone. Thank you again. More
by williamrschiller1
Other Employees Tagged: Mike Lindstrom
