Back

Prestige Auto Mall

Cuyahoga Falls, OH

3.3
466 Reviews
We are proud to be your family owned quality used car dealership since 2008. Since we first opened our doors our No.1 priority has been to offer a world-class customer service. At Prestige Auto Mall we keep things simple. Our shopping process is straightforward and we maintain an easy, no-hassle experience. Everything we do is set up for maximum efficiency. From the showroom to the financing paperwork, we keep things fast, efficient and stress-free.
Contact Dealership

1559 State Rd

Cuyahoga Falls, OH

44223

Directions

By Type

Showing 466 reviews

April 09, 2025

Jeff and Brayden have been awesome with my and myself! ! Thank you guys so much we greatly appreciate everything you’ve done! You’ve went above and beyond. This is seriously the best dealer! More

by Cait.j.d89
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Jeff, brayden
March 06, 2025

I honestly do not even know where to begin with this place is so crooked and out of line it’s not even funny and they should not be in business. On august 31 2024 my fiancé and I headed to prestige auto More

by Justin L
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
No
Employees Worked With
Brian, Bill, Pete Newman
February 16, 2025

made a deal, paid over phone, w good faith they would do all things agreed upon and when we got car, not ONE thing was done! Called multiple times daily, kept getting the run around, no one would help us, n More

by AJ
Sales Price Transparency
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
No
Employees Worked With
Other managers , Jeff McMahan, Tyler Lipscomb, Peter Schlosser, Russell Sackett, Scott MacKenzie
February 07, 2025

This place has caused me nothing but problems and headaches! I would not recommend! Purchased a vehicle and the vehicle was taken back to their service dept 3x and the problem still wasn’t fixed. The More

by aramiscox
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
No
Employees Worked With
Spence, Lamont, Emily, Jeff McMahan
January 19, 2025

Need to be zero. . I recently Visit Prestige Auto Mall and was thoroughly unimpressed with the service I received. The salesperson Jemar and manager Tyler and other m More

by gladysbjjn@gmail.com
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
No
Employees Worked With
Jemar, Tyler Lipscomb, Russell Sackett
Jul 03, 2025 -

gladysbjjn@gmail.com responded

CustomerNeeds1 Need to be zero. . I recently Visit Prestige Auto Mall and was thoroughly unimpressed with the service I received. The salesperson Jemar and manager Tyler and other manager seemed more interested in pushing me to agree to a number than in showing me the car underneath when we ask or addressing my concerns. When I asked to see the car's under, I was met with resistance and told that we have to agree with number in order for him to show us the car underneath when we asked. . The salesperson didn't even bother to accompany me on the test drive, which left me feeling ignored and unvalued. Prestige hit the worst cold sales and manager experience, Do Not go to dealership , I told the manager that we need to see the car underneath and he response was the only has 5 bay and I told him he could just had a jack and have one of his mechanic to lift the car up but oh course he want to run our credit first . I am so disappointed with this dealership. To make matters worse, the manager was rude and dismissive when I expressed my dissatisfaction. It's clear that this dealership prioritizes making a sale over providing good customer service. I would not recommend Prestige Auto Mall to anyone. There are plenty of other dealerships that will treat you with respect and honesty. Customer comes first … Now I see why they have bad reviews . Do not come here please .Do not waste your time time. After I submitted this information the dealership Try to delete my post

January 18, 2025

Great staff Mark is the man great selection. They do so much to work with everyone that goes in great people. More

by mclark0131
Sales Price Transparency
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Mark finance man, Ron Kapis
January 16, 2025

I bought my Dodge Ram from Prestige Auto Mall in Tallmadge Ohio. From the first conversation from Ron to the closing of the deal with Mark, this was the best experience I’ve had at a dealership. Wi More

by axson.adrienne
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Employees Worked With
Ron , Ron Kapis
December 12, 2024

I bought a car through Prestige Auto Mall on cars. com in February 2024. The salesman I spoke to told me he had just driven the car and there was "nothing to apologize for". I am a single mother trying More

by Ksmith262
Sales Price Transparency
Purchase Time
Recommend Dealer
No
Employees Worked With
Ron Kapis
November 25, 2024

We purchased a Toyota FJ Cruiser to be sent to Wichita, KS. Three days after receipt we had to replace the radiator clamp (100.00). Three days after that we had to replace the straps that held the fuel tan More

by leisteralana
Sales Price Transparency
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
No
Employees Worked With
Bryan
Nov 25, 2024 -

leisteralana responded

hi, sending review

October 31, 2024

I purchased a 2016 Lincoln MKZ from prestige auto mall on 6 - 22 - 24 . I was told that the car had a 6 month, 6k mile power train warranty . I had the car for 29 days and put less than 800 miles on it and t More

by fordhowardjr
Sales Price Transparency
Purchase Time
Recommend Dealer
No
Employees Worked With
Jeff McMahan
2
...