I am a resident of Tinton Falls for the past 15 years and have lived in Monmouth County most of my life. When I'm not at work most of my free time is spent with my three daughters. Summer is my favorite time of the year because I enjoy going to the beach. I have a professional yet friendly approach with my clients and will always provide them with a high level of service.
Read moreDealership Experience
6 yrs, 7 mos
Industry Experience
24 yrs, 9 mos
Specialties & Trainings
Sub Prime Financing
171 Reviews
Write a Review171 Reviews of Anthony Paparella
September 04, 2026
Process was quick and painless. Very nice facility. Charles and Anthony were excellent. It is my second car with Circle. Will get a 3rd for sure. Very nice facility. Charles and Anthony were excellent. It is my second car with Circle. Will get a 3rd for sure. More
Other Employees Tagged: Charles Catania
September 01, 2026
My son was interested in test driving a specific BMW. We decided on Circle BMW and made the trip together with my husband. Upon arrival, and almost immediately, we felt welcomed. We also felt no sense of We decided on Circle BMW and made the trip together with my husband. Upon arrival, and almost immediately, we felt welcomed. We also felt no sense of pressure that one might find regularly in car dealerships - especially at the start of a potential sale. We spoke with Charles Catania. He was not only friendly and personable, but he was very thorough with explaining some details of the car that my son was interested in seeing and test driving. When we discussed the money part, It wasn't an endless back and forth - it was quick and painless. Needless to say, we returned the next day because my son liked the details of the deal presented to him, and he signed on the dotted line. During this time, I started to explore some models on my phone. I asked the salesman, Charles Catania, if he could help me and find out if any of the models were on property at the dealership. While Charles helped me, my son and husband were with the finance manager, Anthony Paparella. Anthony was also so personable. It didn't feel like the typical haggling back and forth that we have experienced at this point in a car sale. We talked about our families and such. While my son and husband worked through the details of the finance part, I test drove the model that I liked. Charles was attentive to my questions as I drove around. Once again, I felt no sense of pressure to purchase the vehicle. We pulled back up to the dealership, and we went about making this a second deal. This experience was absolutely the way everyone should experience car dealerships. We felt cared about, we felt that our needs and concerns were addressed, we felt like we both got a good deal, and most importantly, we didn't feel pressured. On a funny note, the area for guests was amazing. My husband and I had a cappuccino, and the snacks were wonderful, too. Circle BMW - and specially Charles Catania and Anthony Paparella- made our purchases of 2 BMWs absolutely phenomenal. Both of the employees should be commended for their great work. Thank you. More
Other Employees Tagged: Charles Catania
July 21, 2026
I’ve purchased six cars over the years, all from Charles Catania. Incredible customer service. Charles always knows exactly what I’m looking for in my next vehicle. Entire dealership is top rate, from finan Catania. Incredible customer service. Charles always knows exactly what I’m looking for in my next vehicle. Entire dealership is top rate, from finance dept to service dept. Can’t recommend them enough! More
Other Employees Tagged: Charles Catania
April 22, 2026
Circle BMW has been very helpful over the past few years, both with sales and service. Alex Escobar-Castro makes the sales process straightforward and transparent and always available afterwards. The servic both with sales and service. Alex Escobar-Castro makes the sales process straightforward and transparent and always available afterwards. The service department is very efficient and always sends detailed videos and updates as work is completed. More
Other Employees Tagged: Alex Escobar-Castro, Rui Costa
March 27, 2026
Amazing dealership—very accommodating and truly focused on meeting your needs while working out a deal that makes sense. Charles Catania is an exceptional salesman who goes above and beyond every step of t on meeting your needs while working out a deal that makes sense. Charles Catania is an exceptional salesman who goes above and beyond every step of the way. He takes the time to help you find a deal that works for both you and the dealership. This was my second time working with Charles, and I wouldn’t hesitate to do so again. Highly recommend! Thanks, Charles—I love my car! More
Other Employees Tagged: Charles Catania
February 05, 2026
From start to finish, my experience purchasing a new BMW M4 Competition Convertible was exceptional — easily one of the most professional and enjoyable automotive experiences I’ve ever had. I want to giv M4 Competition Convertible was exceptional — easily one of the most professional and enjoyable automotive experiences I’ve ever had. I want to give special recognition to my salesperson, Tathiana Carrasco, whose attention to detail and dedication were truly outstanding. From the moment I began the custom-order process, she ensured every aspect — including my request for a unique Individual paint color — was handled with precision. She coordinated closely with the factory to guarantee the order was accepted exactly as specified, keeping me informed every step of the way. Her constant follow-up throughout the manufacturing and delivery stages made the entire experience stress-free and exciting. It’s clear that Tathiana genuinely cares about her clients and takes great pride in delivering an exceptional level of service. When the big day finally arrived, Brian Valentine, the BMW Genius, took the time to walk me through every feature of my new M4. His knowledge of the technology and performance systems was comprehensive, and he patiently explained all the details to ensure I understood how to get the most out of my car. From setting up driver profiles and connectivity features to customizing the driving modes, Brian made the entire delivery experience smooth, informative, and enjoyable. Thanks to both Tathiana and Brian, taking delivery of my BMW M4 Competition Convertible was a moment to remember. Their professionalism, expertise, and genuine enthusiasm embody what makes the BMW brand so special. I wholeheartedly recommend this dealership to anyone looking for a first-class car-buying experience. More
Other Employees Tagged: Brian Valentine, Christopher Bogner, Danny M. Wong, Tathiana Carrasco
February 03, 2026
The dealership had a very low pressure approach to the sales process allowing me to check out inventory and not forcing a sales person on me until I requested help. Once I decided on a car, all associates sales process allowing me to check out inventory and not forcing a sales person on me until I requested help. Once I decided on a car, all associates were professional and friendly making the entire process pleasurable. Jim Hirsch was an exceptional client advisor. He worked with me to find the best solution for my needs (both model and cost) and made the entire process seamless and quick. Zero wasted time! More
Other Employees Tagged: Jim Hirsch
January 16, 2026
Working with Charles and the crew at Circle BMW has been a great professional experience! Great customer service and attention to detail made this purchase seemless. a great professional experience! Great customer service and attention to detail made this purchase seemless. More
Other Employees Tagged: Charles Catania
January 16, 2026
It was a pleasure dealing with Charles, he made the whole purchasing experience painless. Very responsive, very personable. I would highly recommend working with him. purchasing experience painless. Very responsive, very personable. I would highly recommend working with him. More
Other Employees Tagged: Brian Valentine, Charles Catania, Daniel Angelozzi
January 16, 2026
Charles was very professional and friendly. He was great to work with. Helped us find the perfect vehicle. He was great to work with. Helped us find the perfect vehicle. More
Other Employees Tagged: Amanda Ruth, Charles Catania

