Eric Papenthien

Andrew was terrific from start to finish, really a pleasure to work with! He looked out for our interests and made sure we got the vehicle we really wanted. Cannot recommend highly enough! Eric was a pleasure to work with! He looked out for our interests and made sure we got the vehicle we really wanted. Cannot recommend highly enough! Eric was also great to work with throughout the financing process. More

Print

Working with Marry was by far the best car-buying experience I've ever had. After dealing with several dealerships that added markups, hidden accessories, or weren't transparent about pricing, Mar experience I've ever had. After dealing with several dealerships that added markups, hidden accessories, or weren't transparent about pricing, Marry was a breath of fresh air. She was honest, responsive, and straightforward from the very beginning. She answered all of my questions, never pressured me into anything, and worked hard to find exactly the vehicle I wanted. She kept me updated throughout the process, made everything easy to understand, and genuinely cared about making sure I was happy with the purchase rather than just making a sale. That level of customer service is rare. If you're looking for someone who values honesty, professionalism, and exceptional customer service, ask for Marry. I would absolutely recommend her to my family and friends, and I wouldn't hesitate to buy another vehicle from her in the future. Thank you, Marry, for making what is usually a stressful process such a positive experience! More

Print

Always a pleasure to purchase my new Toyota with Marc as my salesperson. Words to describe him: Dependable, Friendly, Trustworthy, Knowledgeable my salesperson. Words to describe him: Dependable, Friendly, Trustworthy, Knowledgeable More

Print

I just helped my mom purchase a 2026 RAV4 Hybrid from out of state and Dave Leveritt made the entire experience a pleasure. I handled the whole process remotely from New York and contacted twelve dealerships of state and Dave Leveritt made the entire experience a pleasure. I handled the whole process remotely from New York and contacted twelve dealerships across NY and WI before landing on Umansky. Dave was, without exaggeration, the single best salesperson I dealt with. Most dealerships I reached out to refused to communicate over email, which made comparison shopping a nightmare. Dave was the opposite. He was happy to email throughout the entire process, kept me updated at every stage — from assembly, to freight, to the ETA in Milwaukee — and never made me chase down information. When my mom and I picked up the car, the price we'd agreed on was the price we paid. No surprises, no last-minute add-ons, no games with financing. If you want a buying experience that's straightforward, professional, and genuinely respectful of your time, ask for Dave. Can't recommend him highly enough. More

Print

We had never worked with anyone from Umansky Toyota. We saw on cars.com that a 2020 Subaru Limited was for sale. We went don to Milwaukee and met marc. We were very happy with him and the whole transa We saw on cars.com that a 2020 Subaru Limited was for sale. We went don to Milwaukee and met marc. We were very happy with him and the whole transaction of buying this SUV. It took only about a total of an hour and a half. We are very have with our new Subaru and was very happy with working with Marc. We definitely would buy another car from Marc and Umansky Toyota. Marc is an excellent salesperson! Joe and Mary Mares More

Print

I want to give a big thank you to Andrew at Umansky for helping me with my new RAV4! He made the whole process smooth, answered all my questions, and made sure I found exactly what I was looking for. I helping me with my new RAV4! He made the whole process smooth, answered all my questions, and made sure I found exactly what I was looking for. I really appreciate his professionalism and friendly attitude — highly recommend working with him! I would also like to thank Michael and Kacey for all their help in selecting an amazing RAV4! The entire team made my buying experience even better by going above and beyond! More

Print

Marc & the Umansky team are wonderful! Professional in every way & attentive to our particular needs. It was a delightful purchase experience!! Professional in every way & attentive to our particular needs. It was a delightful purchase experience!! More

Print

Anthony Herbig provided a top-notch and low stress car-buying experience when my wife and I went to Umansky Toyota to buy a new car. He even paid for a paint touch up pen for the new car out of his ow car-buying experience when my wife and I went to Umansky Toyota to buy a new car. He even paid for a paint touch up pen for the new car out of his own pocket. Sales Manager Christian Coroian also provided excellent customer service making it easy for us to choose Umansky Toyota as the local Toyota dealer we decided to buy from. More

Print