Dealer Reviews

Cars for Sale

Write a Review

Dealer Log In

Write a Review

Matt Cornicelli

Overview Reviews (9) Inventory (112)

Contact Me

View All Employees

< View All Employees

Matt Cornicelli

Product Specialist

Cole Valley Cadillac

4111 Elm Road NE
Warren, OH 44483

Contact Me

4.7

9 Reviews

Overview Reviews (9) Inventory (112)

4.7

9 Reviews

Write a Review

This rating includes all reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.

Contact Matt Cornicelli

Name

Email or Mobile Phone

Message

By clicking Send Message, you agree to receive automated texts to connect you to this dealership employee, to market and provide information, and to better serve you. Purchase is not required and you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Standard message and data rates may apply.

9 Reviews of Matt Cornicelli

November 07, 2026

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

I have known the Cole family for years. This is my fourth automobile purchase from the dealer. They have all been great vehicles. Team is always easy to deal with and NO pressure. Cole alwa This is my fourth automobile purchase from the dealer. They have all been great vehicles. Team is always easy to deal with and NO pressure. Cole always has very good cars on the lot. More

by dfalatic

Verified Customer

Sales Price Transparency

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Nov 07, 2026 -

Cole Valley Cadillac responded

After four vehicle purchases from our dealership, your continued support means a great deal to our team. We're glad working with us has felt relaxed and straightforward, and we hope you enjoy your Nissan Murano! Grace Cole Internet Manager graceh@colecars.net

November 04, 2026

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

Friendly, good value, quick to respond, flexible, easy to work with, did what they said on time work with, did what they said on time More

by milesjdm

Verified Customer

Sales Price Transparency

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Jarred Maderitz

Nov 04, 2026 -

Cole Valley Cadillac responded

We're pleased your used Cadillac Escalade purchase felt straightforward and our team accommodated your needs, communicated promptly, and followed through on time. Thank you for the five-star rating! Grace Cole Internet Manager graceh@colecars.net

November 04, 2026

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

No one really reached out to address my issue I had to go to them and all I got was shrugged shoulders 30 yrs coming there probably ending soon to them and all I got was shrugged shoulders 30 yrs coming there probably ending soon More

by raynaudhand

Verified Customer

Service Price Transparency

Workmanship

Service Time

Service Communication

Recommend Dealer

Other Employees Tagged: Ken Whitcher, Connie Stiles

Nov 04, 2026 -

Cole Valley Cadillac responded

Thank you for bringing this to our attention, and we sincerely apologize for your recent experience. After 30 years of loyal business, you deserve far better than passive service and unanswered concerns. We take this very seriously and want to personally investigate what happened and make things right. Please share your full name, phone number, and repair order number by emailing us directly at graceh@colecars.net or calling (330) 372-1665. We deeply value your long-standing trust and hope for the opportunity to retain your business. Sincerely, Grace Cole

October 15, 2026

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

I thought with each oil change Cole valley did a car wash also…our car wasn’t washed. also…our car wasn’t washed. More

by cinkut

Verified Customer

Service Price Transparency

Workmanship

Service Time

Service Communication

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Oct 15, 2026 -

Cole Valley Cadillac responded

Thank you! We appreciate your business and look forward to helping you with any questions or future needs. Thank you for choosing Cole Valley Cadillac. Grace Cole Internet Manager graceh@colecars.net

August 12, 2026

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

I want my car to be handled by the people who know it best, and I feel that's who's at Cole Valley. And Matt Cornicelli's being very patient as I try to make the trade-up decision! best, and I feel that's who's at Cole Valley. And Matt Cornicelli's being very patient as I try to make the trade-up decision! More

by emilywlove

Verified Customer

Service Price Transparency

Workmanship

Service Time

Service Communication

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Katie Stowe

Aug 12, 2026 -

Cole Valley Cadillac responded

Knowing that you trust our service department with your Cadillac SRX means a lot to us. We’re pleased Matt could guide you patiently as you weigh your trade-up options. Grace Cole Internet Manager graceh@colecars.net

July 08, 2026

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

Jerred and Grace were very easy and friendly to deal with ! I would recommend everyone to give them chance to make you a deal on a new Cadillac ! ! I would recommend everyone to give them chance to make you a deal on a new Cadillac ! More

by RJRINGER

Verified Customer

Sales Price Transparency

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Jarred Maderitz

Jul 08, 2026 -

Cole Valley Cadillac responded

It was a pleasure assisting you with your new Cadillac XT5. We’re thrilled you found the process so easy and friendly. Thank you for recommending us to others in the market for a Cadillac. Grace Cole Internet Manager graceh@colecars.net

June 02, 2026

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

They didn't wash the car alfter it was done. .Everyone by are...We bought the car from you in 2020 .Everyone by are...We bought the car from you in 2020 More

by BIGFLY82

Verified Customer

Service Price Transparency

Workmanship

Service Time

Service Communication

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Jarred Maderitz, Ken Whitcher , Katie Stowe

Jun 06, 2026 -

Cole Valley Cadillac responded

Thanks for sharing about your experience with Cole Valley Cadillac. We are sorry to hear you weren't fully satisfied with your experience. Thank you for bringing it to our attention. We appreciate your business and hope to see you again! Grace Cole Internet Manager graceh@colecars.net

May 18, 2026

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

Nice business to work with. My salesman was the same person that sold me my first caddi in 2003. They did a big favor for me which was greatly appreciated. Maintenance took My salesman was the same person that sold me my first caddi in 2003. They did a big favor for me which was greatly appreciated. Maintenance took care of my new car concerns as best he could. I will drive it a little longer as suggested and return anytime if necessary. All staff is very friendly. More

by MIAMI10

Verified Customer

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Jarred Maderitz , Not sure of name/ names but they were great.

May 19, 2026 -

Cole Valley Cadillac responded

Thank you for taking the time to write this review and let us know how we are doing. Our customers are our top priority and your feedback is greatly appreciated! All of us at Cole Valley Cadillac are glad to have you as a customer. Grace Cole Internet Manager graceh@colecars.net

May 08, 2026

Dealership Rating

Employee Rating

Had the best experience at this dealership. Our product specialist Matt was fantastic to work with as well as Grace in finance. The process was seamless. All of the staff we encountered offered Our product specialist Matt was fantastic to work with as well as Grace in finance. The process was seamless. All of the staff we encountered offered an inviting low pressure atmosphere that I appreciated the most. Without hesitation we will return here in the future. More

by Rebecca Moore

Sales Price Transparency

Trade-in Experience

Purchase Time

Finance Experience

Recommend Dealer

Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Jarred Maderitz , Grace

May 08, 2026 -

Cole Valley Cadillac responded

Delighted to hear that Matt and our finance staff made your Buick Enclave purchase seamless. We’re glad the low pressure atmosphere felt inviting throughout. We look forward to assisting you again whenever you return. Grace Cole Internet Manager graceh@colecars.net

Dealership Inventory (112 Vehicles)

2025 Ram ProMaster 2500 | used

$28,198

2025 Ram ProMaster 2500

used

Bright White Clearcoat exterior

Automatic

Front-wheel Drive

$28,198

View Vehicle Details

View Details

2023 GMC Acadia | used

$29,898

2023 GMC Acadia

used

Ebony Twilight Metallic exterior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

$29,898

View Vehicle Details

View Details

2024 Jeep Wrangler | used

$27,017

2024 Jeep Wrangler

used

Black Clearcoat exterior

Automatic

Four-wheel Drive

$27,017

View Vehicle Details

View Details

2022 Ford Mustang Mach-E | used

$25,909

2022 Ford Mustang Mach-E

used

Shadow Black exterior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

$25,909

View Vehicle Details

View Details

2024 Cadillac XT5 | used

$33,898

2024 Cadillac XT5

used

Crystal White Tri-Coat exterior

Automatic

All-wheel Drive

$33,898

View Vehicle Details

View Details

2021 Ford Escape | used

$17,398

2021 Ford Escape

used

Gray Metallic exterior

CVT

All-wheel Drive

$17,398

View Vehicle Details

View Details

View All Inventory