Dealer Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
Noah Reed
334 Reviews
334 Reviews
Write a Review
334 Reviews of Noah Reed
September 20, 2025
Choosing smithtown Volkswagen was the absolute worst experience I have ever had in my car leasing life! I was close to going to channel 12 news so no one else had to experience what I did. My experience experience I have ever had in my car leasing life! I was close to going to channel 12 news so no one else had to experience what I did. My experience was like this; I had to get a lawyer and even then still had no help bc of corporate lying and telling my lawyer incorrect information leaving out pertinent information as to why I was activating the lemon law. It wasn’t until I wrote a letter and complained about this dealership to the better business bureau that I finally had some help. This letter to the BBB was written AFTER I wrote an initial letter to corporate about what was going on. Even with the letter they denied my case and refused to buy back the nonworking vehicle. THEN their lawyer quickly called me for reconciliation. VW corporate, Kelly in particular was a see you next Tuesday and should NOT be in customer service the way she speaks to human beings who are in need of… customer service. That’s her job. She should probably take a course on how to provide customer service prior to working in this department. She deserves to be fired. My car was stalling while driving it and was brought into be fixed 5 times at that point which is 2 times over the legal limit according to the NYS lemon law and yet I was still denied by corporate even though they couldn’t fix it. I was forced to service the car almost weekly and be left without a car and spent more time in rentals than my actual car as my car as broken day 11 of the lease with under 200 miles on it. I was forced to pay the full payment amount every month that was driving around in stock rental. Keep in mind I was paying high payments for a fully loaded Tiguan. Scott in service was the most disrespectful, lying man I have ever encountered. Rude man lacking empathy and kept telling me to “play the game.” Whatever that meant. I didn’t want to play a game I wanted a working car that I spend my hard earned money on. I wanted to use the extra ammenieies I was paying for instead of sitting in a stock Jetta for weeks at a time for the same price as my Tiguan. Get my point? He didn’t. He has now been “let go.” Hmmm wonder why. The financial guy is a thief who tried to rip me off by $2000 and then pretend that he didn’t realize he added an extra “0.” Oops! Im sure he probably thought I wouldn't notice. He also probably thought I was a dumb girl he can take advantage of since I was there alone trying to buy a car. Once they lied to me and tried to manipulate me into signing for the extra money, I stood up and walked out. That should have been my first red flag. Lesson learned. The dealership then harassed me into “getting my business back” after their “mistake” that they were “very sorry for.” They even had the “manager” come in to talk to me to apologize. I later found out he didn’t even work at that location. He works at the dealership across the street! Comical. I could go on for days writing about the full experience but I just don’t want to waste any more of my time than I already have. After a 13 month battle, I was out of the lease. They gave me a check in the amount of 13 months in car payments but I don’t thinks that was enough to be honest. The amount of time I had to be without a car, inconvenienced, treated like garbage. The hours spent fighting on the phone, finding lawyers, driving back and forth to drop the car off and pick it up and empty my stuff out and put my stuff back in etc etc… I should be compensated for it. I still feel like I should get a lawyer to go after them for what they did and how they treated me. Maybe I will. Maybe I won’t let it go. Stay far away from this location. But also, just know VW corporate will not help you. The customer service alone minus the xxxxty dealership experience will be enough that I will never own a VW for the rest of my life. All my friends and family agree because they saw what I went though and even dealt with it with me as well! Steer clear! You’ve been warned. More
by missmattera
Verified Customer
August 17, 2025
Very pleasant and professional service. Quickly checked the vehicle in and provide appropriate recommendations. Job was performed in a reasonable amount of time. Quickly checked the vehicle in and provide appropriate recommendations. Job was performed in a reasonable amount of time. More
by dan.espina
July 25, 2025
I dropped my car off to have the air bag recall work performed, I found out later that their computer system was down, and had been down for a number of days with no definitive expectation of when it wo performed, I found out later that their computer system was down, and had been down for a number of days with no definitive expectation of when it would be restored. The computer system is required to perform the work. They held my car for an entire day and the work was never performed. Had they been honest and informed me of the situation prior to dropping the car off, I would have rescheduled my appointment for another day. This was a big inconvenience, and I would not recommend going to this dealership; very dishonest. More
by Mrags
Other Employees Tagged: Paul Mitchell, Jonathan KAMINSKI , Nick Weiner, Jamie in service center
July 22, 2025
The window to the shop floor is postered over so that you can’t see anything going on…what are you hiding?? After the oil change the crankcase was 1/2 quart low…makes me uneasy about the work that was done can’t see anything going on…what are you hiding?? After the oil change the crankcase was 1/2 quart low…makes me uneasy about the work that was done More
by zaffers
July 17, 2025
Noah was excellent with the service as always. Kept me updated on the status of my car and made sure it was a seemless transition. Every time I bring my car to smithtown the staff takes care of me Kept me updated on the status of my car and made sure it was a seemless transition. Every time I bring my car to smithtown the staff takes care of me and my car. More
by shawnaroc
July 12, 2025
The waiting room needs improvement. Why is it in the middle of the showroom? Was actually better when upstairs. Noah always kind, very helpful & considerate. I'd rather interact with Why is it in the middle of the showroom? Was actually better when upstairs. Noah always kind, very helpful & considerate. I'd rather interact with him specifically than anyone else. I've actually had another service writer come out to ask me if I need to "call my husband" to discuss the suggested service during a previous visit. Semi-insulting, however IF I am calling anyone it would be my father, who taught me a ton after a career in the business, but I really love the text messages with the service options complete with pictures. Nice touch. More
by Lalize
Other Employees Tagged: Paul Mitchell
July 02, 2025
Brought my car in for a 20,000 mile service. There is a recall for brakes on my car they checked it and found my brakes needed to be changed. They told me my head gasket is leaking an needed t There is a recall for brakes on my car they checked it and found my brakes needed to be changed. They told me my head gasket is leaking an needed to be changed. It was on a Saturday and told me he would call me Monday to set up an appointment so he can give me a loaner. He called me Monday setup the appt, I dropped the car off. Got a call a couple of days later saying the head gasket can't be done we have to replace the head. Also we are replacing your transmission. I said ok what is wrong with my transmission. He told me the issue. I do have the extended warranty for my car but this was all under the regular warranty. They replaced all and of course no charge. More
by afnextel
Dealership Inventory (201 Vehicles)
