Dealer Reviews
Service Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
Atlantic Hyundai
West Islip, NY
2,810 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Service Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
Showing 2,810 reviews
September 26, 2023
Ed and Atlantic Hyundai were great to work with, they helped me get the Hyundai I was looking for and couldn't find anywhere in NH. From negotiating to pick up I could not ask for a more accommodating d helped me get the Hyundai I was looking for and couldn't find anywhere in NH. From negotiating to pick up I could not ask for a more accommodating dealership. I feel they truly wanted me to have the car I wanted. Ed has called me several times since the sale to make sure I am happy with my purchase, and everything is going well. More
by CINDYMCKENNA24
Employees Worked With
Ed Brightman, Darnell Baptiste
Helpful September 21, 2023
On 9/17/23, we met salesman Ed Brightman in person after a few phone calls the day before. During one of those calls, Ed answered all of our questions very thoughtfully from home after business hours. At th a few phone calls the day before. During one of those calls, Ed answered all of our questions very thoughtfully from home after business hours. At the dealership, he analyzed our deal, gave us a thorough review, and provided great advice on next steps. We really appreciated his time, effort, & customer service. The meeting was worthwhile and educational. No high pressure sales. I recommend Ed to anyone seeking a Hyundai deal on the east coast. He was knowledgeable, funny, and very personable. More
by Vivian B.
Employees Worked With
Ed Brightman
September 16, 2023
GO SEE ED ! I’m not gonna lie- I hate the whole car buying process. You’re there so long it starts to feel like a hostage situation. Ed is all gas no breaks. So I’m not gonna lie- I hate the whole car buying process. You’re there so long it starts to feel like a hostage situation. Ed is all gas no breaks. So between him and Lenny in finance, the whole process took less than 3 hours and my aunt drove off in a car she absolutely loves. Thank you again Ed Brightman ! More
by af82069
Employees Worked With
Ed Brightman, Lenny Orlov
September 15, 2023
Ed was great to work with and very helpful when my wife and I purchased our new Elantra. I definitely would recommend him and go back in the future. and I purchased our new Elantra. I definitely would recommend him and go back in the future. More
by c.oliveras15
Employees Worked With
Ed Brightman
September 06, 2023
Listen, it's notoriously the worst dealership on Long Island. If they have the car you want, it's probably not worth dealing w/ these people regardless. Just wait for the car at any other dealership. The Island. If they have the car you want, it's probably not worth dealing w/ these people regardless. Just wait for the car at any other dealership. They will lie directly to your face and pressure you to pay made up fees. You can likely get those removed, but it will be a complete fight to get it done that will take multiple days and a lot of time. The finance department are complete crooks as well. Just stay away from here unless you are ready for a complete battle w/ a bunch of terrible people. More
by charlespickens
Employees Worked With
Abhi Malhotra
August 29, 2023
Atlantic Hyundai Sonata s my go to place for cars and Gary Calixte is the salesperson to go to. He is patient, kind and honest. Thanks Gary for your help with my new Santa Fe. Gary Calixte is the salesperson to go to. He is patient, kind and honest. Thanks Gary for your help with my new Santa Fe. More
by Gubitosidenise0
Employees Worked With
Gary Calixte, Lenny Orlov
August 29, 2023
I am now 5 months post purchase of my vehicle and I still do not have the rugs for this vehicle. After 3 months of waiting and being ignored I decided to leave a negative review on multiple platforms. This g do not have the rugs for this vehicle. After 3 months of waiting and being ignored I decided to leave a negative review on multiple platforms. This got their attention! I finally received a call back from someone claiming to be a customer experience manager. She said she would help me get my rugs and asked that I take down the negative review in a show of good faith. She said if I take down the review she would send me a tracking number for the rugs right away. I told her that I would take down the review but only AFTER I received the rugs. She insisted that I take the review down right away. After a lengthy back and fourth and her insisting I take the review down first she finally realized that I was not going to budge on taking down the review until I get my rugs first. It was then that she said the rugs are on back order and I haven't heard from her since (or anyone else there). If they are on back order, what tracking number was she going to send? I am now confident that if I deleted the review, I'd still be rugless. Afterwards I went to the Hyundai website to see if they were on back order and needless to say they were not. They were available for purchase!!!For them to call me and tell me that I need to delete the review before I get my rugs is taking Shady Dealerships to a whole new level. This is next level dishonesty and corruption. If you are looking from buying at this dealership be aware that they will stoop down to any level and are capable of lying about everything. You'd think I was asking for a new car when you see the effort they are putting in to not give me rugs worth less that $200. If they are willing to do all this for a set of inexpensive rugs what do you think they would do to not honor a pricey warranty item? This is the kind of dealership everyone warns you about!! More
by EA
Employees Worked With
EA, Sandra Redway
