Dealer Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
All Salespeople
Sales Department
Johnstons Subaru
Middletown, NY
144 Reviews
This rating includes all dealership reviews, with more weight given to recent reviews.
Sales Price Transparency
Service Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Filter Reviews by Keyword
By Type
144 Reviews of Johnstons Subaru
March 29, 2025
Alfredo is the BEST! !! He is knowledgeable, patient and understanding. He explained all our options with the new car. He went thru all the important items we needed to !! He is knowledgeable, patient and understanding. He explained all our options with the new car. He went thru all the important items we needed to know. It is refreshing to know there are salesman out there with honesty and integrity in this hurry-up society we live in. I give him my highest recommendation and the staff at Johnstons Subaru is very kind, considerate and patience. A thumbs up for Subaru!! More
by mikie65
Employees Worked With
Michelle Dilullo
March 29, 2025
Michael and all of the others at the dealership were competent, friendly and extremely patient. Michael spent a great deal of time with me , especially giving me a tutorial on the computer driven compon competent, friendly and extremely patient. Michael spent a great deal of time with me , especially giving me a tutorial on the computer driven components in my new car. He made sure I knew how to use all of the devices. My purchase went beautifully. Thank you ! More
by tobyroslyn74
Employees Worked With
Michael, Michelle Dilullo
March 23, 2025
I feel very confident about my purchase of a used Subaru from Johnstons Subaru. They were efficient, friendly, thorough, and a pleasure to work with. I will return there, for my next car. from Johnstons Subaru. They were efficient, friendly, thorough, and a pleasure to work with. I will return there, for my next car. More
by amylambesalino8
Employees Worked With
Steven Bandernek , Michelle Dilullo
October 02, 2024
Did my research on all kinds of vehicles. Johnston's Salesman "Frank S." was very kind and helpful in answering all my questions and helping me make a final decision on my choice of which ve Johnston's Salesman "Frank S." was very kind and helpful in answering all my questions and helping me make a final decision on my choice of which vehicle would fit my needs the best. Very happy with my 2025 Outback, and he has followed up with us to make sure we know that they are there for us if any issues arise. Very pleased with their service and consideration. More
by Liz Haviland
Employees Worked With
Frank Sinigaglia
October 01, 2024
Our customer service rep, Maureen Jones, made sure we could have our Subaru checked out even though we were in the area for a short time, and Darren went on a test drive to ensure our problem had been id could have our Subaru checked out even though we were in the area for a short time, and Darren went on a test drive to ensure our problem had been identified and fixed. More
by Dennis
Employees Worked With
Maureen Jones, Darren
