Dealership Experience
10 yrs, 6 mos
Industry Experience
34 yrs, 3 mos
Languages Spoken
English
87 Reviews
Write a Review87 Reviews of Anthony Rotella
January 03, 2025
Purchased a blue certified pre-owned 2019 Mustang on 12/16/24 for a total of 40893.52. Purchased the 3 year premium warranty as well. I was only allowed to test drive the car in the parking lot, because 12/16/24 for a total of 40893.52. Purchased the 3 year premium warranty as well. I was only allowed to test drive the car in the parking lot, because it was “stick”. Everything felt fine and went ahead, as I needed a newer, reliable car for an upcoming Christmas trip. Driving the car on dry conditions I noticed the horrendous amount of wheel hop. I’ve never had this chassis Mustang and know they have issues. The following day, it was lightly raining. The car was all over the road. When I say all over the road, I’m talking cannot take a turn at more than a creep or the car would oversteer or plow. I immediately turn around and drove it to my shop. After putting the car up on the lift I started looking at the tires. By this time most of the tire shine has slung off and the tires were abhorrent. Date codes from 2018. Some of the worst dry rot I’ve ever seen on a tire. So bad that the tread is delaminating from one tire, all others show advanced signs of rot. Raised the concern to the finance manager via text (he’s awesome), and he said he would inform the sales manager to call me. I waited for a phone call for 6 hours the following day. I texted him with a video of one of the tires after I cleaned ALL the tire shine off them. I wanted to just get the issue rectified and be on my way. Anthony, the sales manager finally called me and had a poor attitude. I was told repeatedly “I’m not a mechanic, I don’t know, I don’t know what to tell you” and “I’m not in the tire business” and “I’m busy and I have customers”. After voicing my concern and frustration that I paid 40k for a vehicle that is sitting on a lift undriveable. I was told “it’s a blue certified, so we only replace the tires if they show uneven wear or won’t hold air” The front left tire is has toe wear so bad it’s missing chunks, and the tread is completely gone, as well as the horrible dry rot. “I’ll talk to someone on Monday and we’ll get back to you”. The thing that really angers me is I drove this car for a day with these tires. The car did not handle nor drive like it should have, and was a serious safety liability to myself and everyone else on the road. My holiday trip is now postponed due to not having a vehicle to take, and now I wait to see if they are going to rectify it. I simply want what I paid for. Did they know about the tires? Maybe. Is that why I wasn’t allowed to test drive it on the street in wet conditions? Was it deceptive and misrepresented by someone soaking them in silicone based tire shine to hide imperfections? Definitely. Could someone have gotten seriously hurt or killed? Most definitely. The irony is on their Facebook their tag line is “our customers are like family, and that’s a big deal”. I’d challenge anyone there to put their family in this car with these tires and do 70 down 287. I was going to hold off on this review until a resolution or until they told me to bug off, but the whole thing up until this point has been a negative. I have a car I paid for and cannot safely drive.I have the means to replace the tires, the knowledge and equipment to do so, but what about the single mom strapped for cash? What about an unsuspecting family? As an automotive technician myself you are constantly fighting this preconceived notion that all mechanics are crooks, are out to screw you, and I honestly see why people say that, especially about dealerships. Update 10/23/24…removed the tires to check the brakes because I do not trust that they did everything they said they did. Front brake pads are under 50% wear that would warrant replacement under their “blue certification” and the front left strut seals are gone causing an oil leak from the strut. Final update 12/23/24. I had two options, considerably cheaper new tires or the value of said cheaper tires ($800). I’m paying 1247.00 plus tax to replace them with the same tires. I also replaced the brakes and struts at my own expense (1300 in parts). More
Other Employees Tagged: Eric Federico , Jordy Sepulveda
November 23, 2024
Took the time to explain and help us buy two new cars. It was an easy and great experience. It was an easy and great experience. More
Other Employees Tagged: Jaime Concepcion , Michael Williamson
November 13, 2024
Excellent sales and service team from start to finish including finance team. Highly recommend Wayne Ford if looking for new car including finance team. Highly recommend Wayne Ford if looking for new car More
Other Employees Tagged: Scott Van Peenen, Jaime Concepcion, Sean Bowman
November 12, 2024
I’m customer for past several years and this dealership take care of the customers the way suppose to , excellent service , highly Recomended , take care of the customers the way suppose to , excellent service , highly Recomended , More
Other Employees Tagged: Paul Redmon, Matt Halliwell, Jaime Concepcion, Michelle Redmon, Jimmy Terzioski , Skylar Mawson, Bill Redmon, Riondo Russell, Jordy Sepulveda
October 05, 2024
Easy purchase. They had what I wanted at a payment I could afford. Thanks Sean They had what I wanted at a payment I could afford. Thanks Sean More
Other Employees Tagged: Scott Van Peenen, Justin Wainwright, Sean Bowman , Jonathan Handelsman, Jordy Sepulveda
September 24, 2024
They are Great people they care about what is going so they gave you the right price they gave you the right price More
Other Employees Tagged: Paul Redmon, Scott Van Peenen, Justin Wainwright, Jaime Concepcion, Eric Federico , Patrick McLaughlin
September 21, 2024
Quick and easy process. No pressure. Got exactly what I wanted. Would recommend to others. No pressure. Got exactly what I wanted. Would recommend to others. More
Other Employees Tagged: Sean Bowman , Jordy Sepulveda
August 22, 2024
Guys did a all around great job I love my new truck and will buy my next ford at Wayne will buy my next ford at Wayne More
Other Employees Tagged: Jaime Concepcion , Patrick McLaughlin, Michael Williamson
August 10, 2024
Wayne Ford does the most they can for their customers. They are the best. TY They are the best. TY More
Other Employees Tagged: Paul Redmon, Matt Halliwell, Scott Van Peenen, Justin Wainwright, Jaime Concepcion, Michelle Redmon , Skylar Mawson, Bill Redmon, Jordy Sepulveda
August 06, 2024
The dealer is trying to work with us. We are having a ongoing problem with the Ford transit transmissions. We are having a ongoing problem with the Ford transit transmissions. More
Other Employees Tagged: Paul Redmon, Jaime Concepcion, Michelle Redmon

