Dealer Reviews
Cars for Sale
Dealer Log In
Dominick Cataldi
Dominick Cataldi | Page 2
Product Specialist
Starling GMC
1350 S Washington Ave
Titusville, FL 32780
57 Reviews
Dealership Experience
1 yr, 11 mos
57 Reviews
Write a Review
57 Reviews of Dominick Cataldi
February 23, 2026
We did not plan to purchase a vehicle that day, but we fell in love with the new Acadia and the team worked with us on a deal that made it hard to say no. So love our new ride! fell in love with the new Acadia and the team worked with us on a deal that made it hard to say no. So love our new ride! More
by beverly.crowell
Verified Customer
January 06, 2026
Jonathan and Eric were very helpful and ensured we got the vehicle of our choice! They personally followed up after the purchase to ensure we were 100% completely satisfied with everything. We will defini the vehicle of our choice! They personally followed up after the purchase to ensure we were 100% completely satisfied with everything. We will definitely be returning to purchase all of our future vehicles at Starling GMC in Titusville. The service department was also very knowledgeable, quick, and very clean! More
by Berajh
Other Employees Tagged: Eric Lugo, Steve Zullo, Scott Schuler, Jonathan Gould, Nateko Thompson, Philip Smith, Emma Wytko, Daniel Murari, Juan Travieso
January 02, 2026
It was great experience they were very nice great atmosphere very helpful and kind and a family atmosphere. atmosphere very helpful and kind and a family atmosphere. More
by wellsjc8
Other Employees Tagged: Eric Lugo, Steve Zullo, Scott Schuler, Jonathan Gould, Nateko Thompson, Philip Smith, Emma Wytko, Daniel Murari, Juan Travieso
December 25, 2025
I think they are very busy but they get the job done very well and very nice service. well and very nice service. More
by wellsjc8
Other Employees Tagged: Eric Lugo, Steve Zullo, Scott Schuler, Jonathan Gould, Nateko Thompson, Philip Smith, Emma Wytko, Daniel Murari, Juan Travieso
December 23, 2025
Answered all my questions intellectually. Everything was taken care of before I got there. I spent less then a hour at the dealership. Excellent truck buying experience. Special thanks to S Everything was taken care of before I got there. I spent less then a hour at the dealership. Excellent truck buying experience. Special thanks to Shannon. More
by orion406
Other Employees Tagged: Eric Lugo , Shannon 😀😀😀😀😀
December 19, 2025
Service advisor Emily was great. She was fast, friendly and retrieved me a rental in a timely fashion. However was not impressed by the work completed. Purchased a new 2026 Canyon, d She was fast, friendly and retrieved me a rental in a timely fashion. However was not impressed by the work completed. Purchased a new 2026 Canyon, day two the AC drain leaked soaking my passenger floorboard. After the first repair the truck pulled hard to the left and the floor was still wet. The carpet should have been dried prior to me taking the vehicle home. It is now back in the shop. The vehicle has spent more time at the dealer than in my possession. More
by fftmbow
December 19, 2025
I loved dealing with the salespeople at Starling. . They were friendly, knowledgeable and very accommodating. It was a pleasure doing business with all of them! . They were friendly, knowledgeable and very accommodating. It was a pleasure doing business with all of them! More
by dinoto
Other Employees Tagged: Daniel Murari
November 28, 2025
The place is awesome, they found me the perfect car in my price range and they re well worth going back to. price range and they re well worth going back to. More
by borgesginger
Other Employees Tagged: Eric Lugo, Steve Zullo, Scott Schuler, Jonathan Gould, Nateko Thompson, Philip Smith, Emma Wytko, Daniel Murari, Juan Travieso
November 22, 2025
I liked the car and it seems good so far. Dominick seemed to accept my offer, so I was somewhat misled when he came back from his manager with a counteroffer. Then it happened again. Tha Dominick seemed to accept my offer, so I was somewhat misled when he came back from his manager with a counteroffer. Then it happened again. That spoiled the sale a little, But three things also happened afterwards that bothered me. They pushed me to leave the lot with the car forcing me to leave my car overnight and it was a nicer car and a convertible which made me nervous. They also were very cavalier about my insurance company giving me 7 days to insure it and that it would be covered by my insurance on my other vehicle. As it turns out, I flew uninsured for a week because each insurance company does their own thing. The other thing that annoyed me was that they asked me to move to the waiting room so they could clean the car up. I was there for over an hour so finally walked back to the cleaning area. The guy doing the car had taken a lunch break and had no idea that a customer was waiting to get the car, I asked him to double time it and then waited anther 25 minutes, My intention was not to drive off with the car that day, so this major delay screwed up my schedule. All those are easy fixes. I liked the fact that there was only one dealer fee and we negotiated it a bit. I have walked away from other dealerships that surprise you at the end and I will not return to them ever again nor recommend them. I did not feel baited and switched here which is all too common. Dominic seems like a very nice guy and he will do well. More
by bradfordrogergay
Other Employees Tagged: Eric Lugo
Dealership Inventory (225 Vehicles)
