We brought our 2020 Acura TLX to Goodson Acura of Dallas
because of a loud banging/knocking engine noise. We specifically raised concern about the vehicle’s prior connecting-rod-bearing safety recall and wh
because of a loud banging/knocking engine noise. We specifically raised concern about the vehicle’s prior connecting-rod-bearing safety recall and whether the noise could be related.
Goodson charged us approximately $200 to diagnose the vehicle and told us the problem was the high-pressure fuel pump. They quoted us a very substantial amount to replace that single pump.
We declined that repair.
The engine then failed before either fuel pump was replaced.
Only after the engine failure were the fuel pumps replaced elsewhere.
That sequence matters. The later fuel-pump replacement cannot explain away the original knocking/banging complaint or the engine failure because the engine had already failed before those pumps were replaced.
I have repeatedly asked Goodson to provide the actual diagnostic evidence showing how they ruled out the connecting-rod bearings, crankshaft, or a problem associated with the vehicle’s prior engine recall when it originally came in making this serious engine noise.
So far, I have not been provided documentation showing bearing measurements, photographs, physical inspection findings, oil analysis, teardown findings, or other mechanical evidence demonstrating that the recalled engine components were inspected and ruled out.
Instead, Goodson has emphasized that the recall had previously been performed by another Acura dealership and that Acura’s system showed no open recall.
That does not answer the question.
A recall being marked “completed” in a computer system does not establish that the engine was mechanically sound when we later brought the vehicle to Goodson with a loud knocking/banging complaint. Nor does it explain what testing Goodson performed before concluding that the high-pressure fuel pump was responsible for the noise.
This is what concerns me most: we brought them a vehicle making a serious engine noise, specifically raised the prior engine-bearing recall, paid for a professional diagnosis, were told the issue was the high-pressure fuel pump, and the vehicle was returned to us.
The engine then failed before that fuel pump was ever replaced.
My wife was driving this vehicle. A serious internal-engine failure at highway speed can present an obvious safety risk. We took the vehicle to an Acura dealership precisely because we wanted the abnormal noise professionally evaluated before something worse happened.
I am not asking anyone reading this review to simply accept my conclusion about what caused the engine failure. I am asking Goodson to produce the diagnostic evidence supporting the conclusion they gave us before the engine failed.
If a dealership tells a customer that a serious knocking engine noise is caused by a fuel pump rather than a potentially dangerous internal-engine problem, there should be objective diagnostic evidence supporting that determination.
I will update this review if Goodson provides the requested diagnostic records, photographs, measurements, technician findings, or a substantive explanation of how the internal-engine components were ruled out.
More
by treynrockwall
Service Price Transparency
Sep 30, 2026 -
Goodson Acura of Dallas responded
Trey, we are very sorry to hear about the frightening experience your wife had on the highway. During your first and only service visit with Goodson Acura, your TLX was brought in for a banging and knocking noise, and our technicians completed a comprehensive diagnosis. Based on those findings, we recommended replacement of the high-pressure fuel pump, as well as timing belt and water pump service, all of which were declined. We believe the subsequent mechanical failure and related traumatic event could have been avoided if you had moved forward with those repairs. The recall work referenced in your review was completed at another Acura dealership, and our diagnosis did not indicate that it was related to the concern for which your vehicle was brought to us. While we cannot speak to the vehicle’s condition or repairs performed after the recommended work was declined, we stand behind the diagnosis provided and would be glad to review the report with you directly. If you'd like to revisit the diagnosis with our team in person, you are welcome to contact our Executive Manager, Ankur Javia directly at ajavia@goodsonacura.com or (214) 379-5813. Ankur is available today to discuss this with you.
Sep 30, 2026 -
treynrockwall responded
Goodson’s response raises an important issue that deserves clarification.
Goodson has now publicly stated that it believes the subsequent engine failure and frightening highway incident “could have been avoided” had we authorized the high-pressure fuel pump, timing belt and water pump work they recommended.
What is the technical basis for that statement?
Our vehicle was brought to Goodson specifically because it was making a banging/knocking noise. Acura’s own safety-recall documentation concerning the TLX connecting-rod-bearing defect identifies engine knocking/rattling and possible engine failure as symptoms and consequences of that defect.
Goodson’s response does not explain why a vehicle presented with a banging/knocking complaint was attributed to a high-pressure fuel pump and routine timing-belt/water-pump work rather than the known engine-bearing condition, nor does it explain how those declined repairs would have prevented the subsequent internal engine failure.
This is especially important because the Acura fuel-pump safety recall concerns the in-tank fuel-pump motor/impeller. That is not the same component as the high-pressure fuel pump Goodson recommended replacing.
I am therefore asking Goodson a very straightforward question:
What diagnostic evidence establishes that replacing the high-pressure fuel pump, timing belt and water pump would have prevented the subsequent engine failure?
If Goodson is going to make that causal statement publicly, I believe it is reasonable to ask them to identify the technical evidence supporting it.
I am also continuing to request the complete diagnostic documentation associated with our visit so that the sequence of events can be evaluated based on records rather than competing statements.
Sep 30, 2026 -
treynrockwall responded
Goodson Acura has now publicly stated in its response to this review that it believes the later engine failure “could have been avoided” if we had approved its recommended high-pressure fuel pump, timing belt and water pump repairs.
I am asking Goodson to provide the technical basis for that statement.
Our vehicle was brought to Goodson because of a banging/knocking noise. Acura’s own safety-recall documentation regarding the connecting-rod-bearing defect identifies knocking/rattling and potential engine failure as symptoms and consequences of that condition.
Goodson has not explained how replacing the high-pressure fuel pump, timing belt or water pump would have prevented the subsequent internal engine failure.
Their response also refers to a “comprehensive diagnosis.” I am requesting the complete diagnostic documentation so that this can be evaluated based on the actual records.
If Goodson has diagnostic evidence supporting its public assertion that the recommended repairs would have prevented the later engine failure, I welcome them providing that evidence publicly.
If they do not, then I believe that statement should be corrected.
Longtime customer.
They always deliver a quality experience. From the Reps to the refreshments. It's all good.
They always deliver a quality experience. From the Reps to the refreshments. It's all good.
More
by REG
Service Price Transparency
Other Employees Tagged:
Eric Johnson
Aug 25, 2026 -
Goodson Acura of Dallas responded
REG, thank you for sharing 5 stars! We're glad to hear our team always delivers a quality experience! We appreciate your endorsement and look forward to serving you again in the future. Thanks again!
My service advisor has been wonderful.
He still treats my car as though it’s new even when it’s not of warranty. Thank you Khang. Thank you Goodson Acura.
He still treats my car as though it’s new even when it’s not of warranty. Thank you Khang. Thank you Goodson Acura.
More
by Pee
Service Price Transparency
Other Employees Tagged:
Khang
Aug 19, 2026 -
Goodson Acura of Dallas responded
Thank you for sharing 5-stars and noting your advisor was wonderful to work with. We appreciate your endorsement and look forward to serving you again in the future. Best wishes!
Excellent service and Khang was the best.
Better than Sewell and that’s hard to beat.
Better than Sewell and that’s hard to beat.
More
by carolsuzannenelson
Service Price Transparency
Jun 07, 2026 -
Goodson Acura of Dallas responded
carolsuzannenelson, thank you for sharing 5 stars! We're glad to hear Khang is the best and provided excellent service! We appreciate your endorsement and look forward to serving you again in the future. Thanks again!
Great service here as always- arrived at 7 and was out by
9. They always do a good job
9. They always do a good job
More
by rdt517
Service Price Transparency
May 12, 2026 -
Goodson Acura of Dallas responded
rdt517, thank you for sharing 5 stars! We're glad to hear our team always provides great service! We appreciate your endorsement and look forward to serving you again in the future. Thanks again!
Goodson Acura offers a premium experience without
unnecessary frills or the feeling that you’ll be paying more for lavish touches. Good service, always on time, good knowledgeable sales staff, alway
unnecessary frills or the feeling that you’ll be paying more for lavish touches. Good service, always on time, good knowledgeable sales staff, always willing to help without a stuffy atmosphere. Just right!
More
by jonesjp7
Service Price Transparency
Other Employees Tagged:
Ceante Ford - Sales - 5 stars
Mar 21, 2026 -
Goodson Acura of Dallas responded
jonesjp7, thank you for sharing 5-stars and noting that everything went according to plan, was on time and not oversold! We appreciate your feedback and look forward to serving you additionally when the time comes. Thanks again!
Service Advisor today was fantastic care of my Mother’s
Acura. We appreciate the honest assessment and fast turnaround at the last minute. Thank you, will be back!
Acura. We appreciate the honest assessment and fast turnaround at the last minute. Thank you, will be back!
More
by jennifermayfield
Service Price Transparency
Mar 03, 2026 -
Goodson Acura of Dallas responded
jennifermayfield, thanks for sharing 5-stars and noting that Khang took great care of your Mother's Acura! We appreciate your endorsement and look forward to serving you again in the future. Thanks again!
I had an excellent experience at the Acura dealership.
The service was smooth, professional, and stress-free from start to finish. My service advisor KHANG NGUYEN was extremely helpful, knowledgeable, and
The service was smooth, professional, and stress-free from start to finish. My service advisor KHANG NGUYEN was extremely helpful, knowledgeable, and kept me informed throughout the entire process. He made sure all my questions were answered and that my vehicle was well taken care of. I truly appreciate the great customer service and will definitely be returning for future service. Highly recommend!
More
by jessica.ofarrell09
Service Price Transparency
Jan 11, 2026 -
Goodson Acura of Dallas responded
jessica.ofarrell09, thank you for sharing 5-stars and noting that Khang was extremely helpful during your visit! We love hearing he answered all your questions and made sure your vehicle was taken care of comprehensively. We appreciate your endorsement and look forward to serving you additionally in the future. Thanks again!
Always consistent, excellent performance and service from
all departments; sales, service, parts and body shop.
all departments; sales, service, parts and body shop.
More
by Mj-thorn
Service Price Transparency
Jan 09, 2026 -
Goodson Acura of Dallas responded
Mj-thorn, thanks for sharing 5-stars! We're happy to hear our team provides consistent, excellent service! We appreciate your endorsement and look forward to serving you again in the future. Thanks again!
Excellent service.
my service provider mr jonathan always take care of me .always smile. Speak politely. 5*****
my service provider mr jonathan always take care of me .always smile. Speak politely. 5*****
More
by 25muhammad
Service Price Transparency
Dec 04, 2025 -
Goodson Acura of Dallas responded
25muhammad, thank you for sharing 5-stars! We're happy to hear Jonathan always provides excellent service! We appreciate your endorsement and look forward to serving you additionally in the future. Thanks again!