
Malik Butler
Assistant Sales Manager
Maguire Toyota of Grand Island
1974 Alvin Rd
Grand Island, NY 14072
Dealership Experience
5 yrs, 8 mos
Industry Experience
5 yrs, 8 mos
14 Reviews
Write a Review14 Reviews of Malik Butler
May 26, 2025
Sales was lackluster right away. Picked up my new Tahoe with 4% on the fuel filter. No spare key. Took several calls to get a FOB sent to me because I would have to schedule a separa Picked up my new Tahoe with 4% on the fuel filter. No spare key. Took several calls to get a FOB sent to me because I would have to schedule a separate appointment to program it. Car was never cleaned properly and missing the high county mats that were in there we I took it for a test ride. Don't plan on going back unless they wanna make an effort to remedy this. More
Other Employees Tagged: Scott Molenda
May 02, 2025
Everything from start to finish was very low stress, low hassle, and good communication. The used vehicle I purchased was exceptionally cleaned and detailed when I picked it up. hassle, and good communication. The used vehicle I purchased was exceptionally cleaned and detailed when I picked it up. More
Other Employees Tagged: Scott Molenda
March 19, 2025
Allen is the absolute best with selling cars, def recommend him for your sales needs recommend him for your sales needs More
Other Employees Tagged: Allen Williams, Jenna Hiser, Scott Molenda
March 14, 2025
Staff are always friendly and try their best to get everything done in a timely manner. everything done in a timely manner. More
Other Employees Tagged: Christian Ferullo
February 22, 2025
We have come to this dealership for years. AI is awesome. Allen is great. They work as a team and they always try to fit your car and budget to you AI is awesome. Allen is great. They work as a team and they always try to fit your car and budget to you More
Other Employees Tagged: Ai Alderman, Allen Williams
January 04, 2025
Xavier and Ai were amazing they were patient and didn’t pressure. Ai worked with me to make the payments affordable for me. This is my 3rd vehicle from Toyota on the island and great service each time. pressure. Ai worked with me to make the payments affordable for me. This is my 3rd vehicle from Toyota on the island and great service each time. More
Other Employees Tagged: Ai Alderman , Xavier Matthews
October 25, 2023
This dealer before swapping ownership was great. This new owner kept the same staff and only switched the name as far as it matters because they’re still very honest and friendly. This new owner kept the same staff and only switched the name as far as it matters because they’re still very honest and friendly. More
Other Employees Tagged: Carly Knight, Christian Ferullo, Chris Lyst, Jenna Hiser, Blake Vara, Jerrod Hawkes , Jennifer Gonzales, Ronnie Mansour, Tracey Svida, Ali from service, Kevin who used to work in service
June 14, 2023
Took my car here to use my tire warranty. They had me in and out within a hour. They had me in and out within a hour. More
Other Employees Tagged: Christian Ferullo , Matt Veshia
January 29, 2023
Very good service, very attentive to our needs in a vehicle, was very vocal every step of the way until final purchase. Was very happy and would recommend Maguire group every time. vehicle, was very vocal every step of the way until final purchase. Was very happy and would recommend Maguire group every time. More
Other Employees Tagged: Ai Alderman, Christian Ferullo
January 28, 2023
Everything was as I was told it would be. Very professional and friendly. In todays market it was also a great deal. Great product and great experience! Very professional and friendly. In todays market it was also a great deal. Great product and great experience! More
Other Employees Tagged: Ai Alderman, Carly Knight , Jennifer Gonzales, Dylan Guzenski, John Lipiarz, There was someone from service who was preparing the vehicle and I'm sorry I can't remember his name. However he was very helpful and friendly!
Dealership Inventory (78 Vehicles)


