My name is Matthew Tillapaugh aka "Tilly" and I am a sales professional here with O'Daniel Automart/Mazda. I have been with O'Daniel Automotive group for over 5 years and have been in the service industry my whole life. Therefore, I strive to make my customers experience with O'Daniel very unique and exciting. I tend to give my customers a sense of relatxation and confidence that I will take care of them at all cost. I have 2 children; my son Henry and daughter Victoria who enjoy going to the Zoo and taking small trips to any amusement park, swimming pool or museum in the area. They both enjoy playing sports and excel at school where you can presumably say they both are teacher's pets. I look forward to assisting you in the future!
Read more494 Reviews
Write a ReviewDealership Experience
13 yrs, 6 mos
Industry Experience
13 yrs, 6 mos
494 Reviews of Matthew Tillapaugh
November 26, 2019
Everyone has been extremely friendly and helpful! I found exactly what I was looking for. Very happy with this experience! I especially appreciate all the staff for working around my work schedule. I also lo exactly what I was looking for. Very happy with this experience! I especially appreciate all the staff for working around my work schedule. I also love being able to communicate with the staff via text messaging —it has worked well with my work schedule! More
Other Employees Tagged: Spencer Leatherman, Dan Ringenberg, Brad Trahin, Nick Whitworth
November 23, 2019
Excellent Experience Very customer-focused, professional, and personal from the initial contact through the final paperwork and delivery. I highly recommend O'Daniels and Very customer-focused, professional, and personal from the initial contact through the final paperwork and delivery. I highly recommend O'Daniels and Matt Tillapaugh and the other management and administrative staff. More
Other Employees Tagged: Todd Jacquay , Dan Ringenberg
November 11, 2019
Excellent Representative To Work With!!! This is our second CX 5 purchasing experience and this time was even better than the last. Matt Tillapaugh was our representative, and he was excelle This is our second CX 5 purchasing experience and this time was even better than the last. Matt Tillapaugh was our representative, and he was excellent to work with in all phases. He was extremely knowledgeable, personable, and very professional to work with. He has a "no pressure " sales approach and he answered all of our questions without hesitation. I would recommend Matt Tillapaugh to anyone because I know they will have the same excellent experience that we had. More
Other Employees Tagged: Todd Jacquay , Dan Ringenberg
November 05, 2019
Exceeded my expectation!! Matt Tillapaugh was the ODaniel associate who recently assisted me with the purchase of a CX5. He did an outstanding job. He was knowledgeable, prof Matt Tillapaugh was the ODaniel associate who recently assisted me with the purchase of a CX5. He did an outstanding job. He was knowledgeable, professional and not pushy!! I would definately recommend him to anyone looking to purchase a vehicle. Thank you, Matt, for your expertise and assistance!! More
October 17, 2019
Happy Again Purchased my 1st Mazda —2014 CX-5 from Matt Tillapaugh at O’Daniels in 2013 & was so happy with experience—from sale and working with Matt— that I wen Purchased my 1st Mazda —2014 CX-5 from Matt Tillapaugh at O’Daniels in 2013 & was so happy with experience—from sale and working with Matt— that I went back to add a 2019 CX-5. My husband took over the 2014 to replace his car and so we now have two CX-5s in our garage. Matt once again did not disappoint. He and Mr Jacquay put together a good deal. Matt is great to work with—patient, respectful, courteous, friendly and honest. We look forward to many years in our CX-5s. ZOOM ZOOM!! Thanks so much. More
Other Employees Tagged: Todd Jacquay , Dan Ringenberg
October 16, 2019
Very Satisfying Experience The process of shopping for and purchasing a certified preowned vehicle at O'Daniel was pleasant and satisfying. We were treated well by Matt Tillapa The process of shopping for and purchasing a certified preowned vehicle at O'Daniel was pleasant and satisfying. We were treated well by Matt Tillapaugh and Dan Ringenberg. Matt was patient with us as we took a couple lengthy test drives. It was overall very satisfying. More
Other Employees Tagged: Dan Ringenberg
September 19, 2019
Great experience Everyone was great. I originally worked with Jeff and switched over to Matt. Both were amazing. Matt noticed I had a nail in my tire but I had to be a Everyone was great. I originally worked with Jeff and switched over to Matt. Both were amazing. Matt noticed I had a nail in my tire but I had to be at work asap. He came and picked the car up, repaired it, and brought it back, all while I was at work. I'm extremely thankful and grateful for their service. More
Other Employees Tagged: Jeff Cearbaugh
September 13, 2019
LOVE our new Mazda 3 and the Service My wife and I just recently bought a new 2019 Mazda 3 Hatchback Preferred package and we absolutely love it! I have nothing but positive thoughts on t My wife and I just recently bought a new 2019 Mazda 3 Hatchback Preferred package and we absolutely love it! I have nothing but positive thoughts on the car including how clean/sharp both the interior and exterior are, the drive is amazing, and all of the safety features are a game changer! Besides from loving our new car, the service we got matched. We are actually repeat customers as 4 years ago we bought a new CX-5 from the same place and the same salesman, Mathew Tillapaugh. The service we obtained was absolutely phenomenal! My favorite thing about working with Matt, which makes him stand out from other salesman I've worked with in the past, is that he genuinely cares about what I both want and need! He doesn't try and sell me up on a higher level car or a higher level trim, but rather he listens to want I'm wanting and then helps make an informed decision on which vehicle and trim suites what I'm looking for. Originally my wife and I went in with the mindset we would get a CX-3, but after describing all we that we wanted both in the car but financially, we came to the 3 and we are so glad we did. The Fort Wayne dealership was also super helpful as we wanted the car's exterior to be Pearl White along with interior leather seats that too were white/tan. They didn't have this color combination, but they were able to find one at an Indy dealer, switch them out, and get us the car by the end of the week on the last day of incentives so we could take advantage of them! In a nutshell we love our car and the dealership is great and easy to work with at every level! More
Other Employees Tagged: Todd Jacquay , Dan Ringenberg
September 10, 2019
Marvelous Mazda My husband and I had a great experience leasing a new vehicle from Mazda. Since this is the first purchase/lease of a vehicle for us in about 10 year My husband and I had a great experience leasing a new vehicle from Mazda. Since this is the first purchase/lease of a vehicle for us in about 10 years, and our first SUV purchase, we wanted to make the right choice. In doing much research and asking others for their opinion, the Mazda brand kept rising to the top. And from the moment we walked into the dealership until we picked up our new Mazda CX-5, we understood why. The service was excellent. Matt Tillapaugh worked closely with us and was always friendly, helpful and professional. Matt was very thorough in going over all the features on the CX-5. He patiently answered all our questions. And as we have not purchased a new car for about a decade, the technology has certainly changed! The other staff that we encountered during the leasing process were also very helpful and professional. We are very happy with our new Mazda and I foresee us becoming loyal Mazda customers! More
Other Employees Tagged: We worked with a couple of other employees during the Financing process. They did introduce themselves, I just don't recall their names.
September 10, 2019
No Games Not your typical dealership that plays games lowballing your trade in, adding add ons that nickel and dime you to death. The sales man Matthew Tillap Not your typical dealership that plays games lowballing your trade in, adding add ons that nickel and dime you to death. The sales man Matthew Tillapaugh followed up after the sale and spent over an hour going over the features of the car with me. More

