Nicole was born in Erie, PA, and currently lives in Waterford, PA. She attended Mercyhurst University where she studied in Marriage and Family Studies with a minor in Psychology. Nicole started at New Motors in February of 2011, as a Business Manager she excels in always landing the best interest rates for all of New Motors' customers, as well as covering information on warranties and other protection programs we offer. Nicole is engaged to her fiance David, with a planned wedding for October 2015. They have two cats and seven chickens. She enjoys spending her free time snowmobiling in the Erie winters and hanging out on the boat in the summers on Lake Erie. Nicole's job is to make financing a vehicle the most pleasant and comfortable experience possible.
Read more291 Reviews
Write a Review291 Reviews of Nicole DiTullio
November 23, 2025
Jeff made the whole process of trading in my old vehicle for something new very smooth and easy and I’ve had zero regrets getting into something more suitable for Erie county! for something new very smooth and easy and I’ve had zero regrets getting into something more suitable for Erie county! More
Other Employees Tagged: Nick Dylewski, Jeff Waid
April 07, 2025
Excellent dealership had excellent service very professional service ever one was polite and helpful I recommend this dealership to customers. professional service ever one was polite and helpful I recommend this dealership to customers. More
Other Employees Tagged: Shane Harney, Tony Confer, Keisha Hines, Seth Murphy, Nick Dylewski
January 03, 2025
We were welcomed when we came in, met with Shane Harney. He had been contacted during the summer with what we wanted to purchase. He gave us his time by checking what cars were available in our price rang He had been contacted during the summer with what we wanted to purchase. He gave us his time by checking what cars were available in our price range and model. He also gave us the website to refer to. When we located the car we were interested in, Shane made an appointment with us for making the purchase. The finance manager explained the document very clearly. Purchasing the car was very smooth. More
Other Employees Tagged: Shane Harney, Nick Dylewski
November 23, 2024
I want to take a moment to let you know about our recent experience when we stopped at your New Motors dealership in Erie PA. and the sales representative Mike Francis. We appreciated Mike's patience and ki experience when we stopped at your New Motors dealership in Erie PA. and the sales representative Mike Francis. We appreciated Mike's patience and kindness in helping us as we looked at and eventually purchased a 2019 Subaru Ascent vehicle. This was a major step us for us in moving into this vehicle and Mike was with us every step of the way as we reviewed the many features on this car. We appreciated Mike taking the time in making sure that this vehicle definitely fitted our needs for reliability and comfort. I also appreciated that your salesman Mike was not pushy. We would definitely recommend our friends to meet Mike if they are interested in their next vehicle purchase. We also want to thank New Motors for providing the services needed for this vehicle. Thank you, sincerely Bob & Carol Sims More
Other Employees Tagged: Mike Francis
September 16, 2024
I was ignored when I entered the dealership. I am female. After several minutes I approached a woman walking by and she connected me with a salesman. He treated me with respect and dignity. I am female. After several minutes I approached a woman walking by and she connected me with a salesman. He treated me with respect and dignity. More
Other Employees Tagged: Brendan Eisinger
August 31, 2024
This is the 5th Subaru we've bought from New Motors. ..and there's a reason for that! New Motors is different from any other dealer Ive ever dealt with. No hassles, no hang ups....straight up good servic ..and there's a reason for that! New Motors is different from any other dealer Ive ever dealt with. No hassles, no hang ups....straight up good service from their sales staff and their service dept. More
Other Employees Tagged: Beth Moski, Jeff Waid
June 18, 2024
The purchase process was smoothly and timely managed. We appreciated both the salesman and the finance manager's support and friendship. Nick Gaiser handled the sale without pressure and allowed time fo We appreciated both the salesman and the finance manager's support and friendship. Nick Gaiser handled the sale without pressure and allowed time for us to consider our options and determine the economic advantages to the purchase. Thank you Nick. More
Other Employees Tagged: Nick Gaiser
April 12, 2024
Steven Lobaugh and the New Motors team are simply the best. I purchased my first new car and never felt so comfortable doing so. I will be a New Motors Subaru customer moving forward for all the rest of best. I purchased my first new car and never felt so comfortable doing so. I will be a New Motors Subaru customer moving forward for all the rest of my vehicle purchases! More
Other Employees Tagged: Joe Armbruster, Rebecca Kovach, Nick Dylewski, Steve Lobaugh
September 26, 2023
Always professional in making appointments, service, and handling any issues that they discover when performing the service. handling any issues that they discover when performing the service. More
Other Employees Tagged: Seth Murphy, Nick Dylewski
August 15, 2023
New Motors is a great place to purchase a car. The Subaru's have been very highly recommended by friends and family. The personnel at the dealership are extremely helpful, that includes the serv The Subaru's have been very highly recommended by friends and family. The personnel at the dealership are extremely helpful, that includes the service department and the sales staff. More
Other Employees Tagged: Steve Lobaugh

