Nicole DiTullio
Nicole DiTullio at New Motors

Nicole DiTullio

Finance Manager

New Motors

8670 Peach St
Erie, PA 16509

5.0
291 Reviews

Nicole was born in Erie, PA, and currently lives in Waterford, PA. She attended Mercyhurst University where she studied in Marriage and Family Studies with a minor in Psychology. Nicole started at New Motors in February of 2011, as a Business Manager she excels in always landing the best interest rates for all of New Motors' customers, as well as covering information on warranties and other protection programs we offer. Nicole is engaged to her fiance David, with a planned wedding for October 2015. They have two cats and seven chickens. She enjoys spending her free time snowmobiling in the Erie winters and hanging out on the boat in the summers on Lake Erie. Nicole's job is to make financing a vehicle the most pleasant and comfortable experience possible.

5.0

291 Reviews

Write a Review

291 Reviews of Nicole DiTullio

November 23, 2025

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

Jeff made the whole process of trading in my old vehicle for something new very smooth and easy and I’ve had zero regrets getting into something more suitable for Erie county! More

by Ghosttrooper94
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Nick Dylewski, Jeff Waid

Nov 24, 2025

New Motors responded

We love to hear it! Thank you for choosing New Motors and for sharing your experience with Jeff. Enjoy your new ride!

April 07, 2025

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

Excellent dealership had excellent service very professional service ever one was polite and helpful I recommend this dealership to customers. More

by martindw5130
Service Price Transparency
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Apr 08, 2025

New Motors responded

Thank you for recommending New Motors! We're delighted to hear that our team provided professional and helpful service during your visit. We appreciate your support and look forward to serving you in the future!

January 03, 2025

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

We were welcomed when we came in, met with Shane Harney. He had been contacted during the summer with what we wanted to purchase. He gave us his time by checking what cars were available in our price rang More

by bdouble1
Sales Price Transparency
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Shane Harney, Nick Dylewski

Jan 03, 2025

New Motors responded

Thank you for sharing your experience with Shane and the team at New Motors! We're glad to hear that everything went smoothly, from finding the right car to finalizing the purchase. Enjoy your new vehicle!

November 23, 2024

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

I want to take a moment to let you know about our recent experience when we stopped at your New Motors dealership in Erie PA. and the sales representative Mike Francis. We appreciated Mike's patience and ki More

by bobandcarol77
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Mike Francis

Nov 25, 2024

New Motors responded

Thank you for sharing your experience with Mike and the team at New Motors Subaru! We're delighted to hear that he provided such patient and kind assistance during your purchase of the 2019 Subaru Ascent. It's great to know that our service met your expectations, and we appreciate any recommendations you make on our behalf. Enjoy every mile in your new vehicle!

September 16, 2024

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

I was ignored when I entered the dealership. I am female. After several minutes I approached a woman walking by and she connected me with a salesman. He treated me with respect and dignity. More

by rev
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Brendan Eisinger

Sep 17, 2024

New Motors responded

Thank you for sharing your experience. We apologize for the initial oversight when you arrived, but we're glad to hear that our salesman treated you with respect and dignity. If there's anything more we can do to improve your visits in the future, please let us know. Thank you, Andrew Vollant - General Sales Manager - 814-868-4805

August 31, 2024

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

This is the 5th Subaru we've bought from New Motors. ..and there's a reason for that! New Motors is different from any other dealer Ive ever dealt with. No hassles, no hang ups....straight up good servic More

by mainstreetmarshall
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Beth Moski, Jeff Waid

Sep 03, 2024

New Motors responded

Thank you for your continued trust in New Motors! We're delighted to hear that our hassle-free service and dedicated team keep bringing you back. Enjoy your new Subaru, and we look forward to serving you again!

June 18, 2024

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

The purchase process was smoothly and timely managed. We appreciated both the salesman and the finance manager's support and friendship. Nick Gaiser handled the sale without pressure and allowed time fo More

by MaryBeth
Sales Price Transparency
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Nick Gaiser

Jun 18, 2024

New Motors responded

MaryBeth, we're delighted to hear that Nick and the team at New Motors Subaru made your purchase process smooth and pressure-free. Thanks for sharing your experience!

April 12, 2024

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

Steven Lobaugh and the New Motors team are simply the best. I purchased my first new car and never felt so comfortable doing so. I will be a New Motors Subaru customer moving forward for all the rest of More

by Jordan E
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Apr 12, 2024

New Motors responded

Congratulations on the purchase of your first vehicle, Jordan! We're so glad Steven and our team at New Motors Subaru ensured you felt comfortable and accommodated along the way. Here's to happy miles ahead - enjoy!

September 26, 2023

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

Always professional in making appointments, service, and handling any issues that they discover when performing the service. More

by Mccracke001
Service Price Transparency
Workmanship
Service Time
Service Communication
Recommend Dealer
Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Seth Murphy, Nick Dylewski

Sep 26, 2023

New Motors responded

Thanks for the positive feedback! We're glad to know that our team at New Motors Subaru has been able to provide you with professional and efficient service.

August 15, 2023

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

New Motors is a great place to purchase a car. The Subaru's have been very highly recommended by friends and family. The personnel at the dealership are extremely helpful, that includes the serv More

by tmkeshref
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Steve Lobaugh

Aug 15, 2023

New Motors responded

Thanks for the positive feedback! We're glad to know you had a great experience at New Motors Subaru. Our team is always here to help with your automotive needs. Safe travels in your new car!

1
...

Dealership Inventory (504 Vehicles)

new 2026 Volkswagen Atlas car, priced at $52,277
2026 Volkswagen Atlas
new
Deep Black Pearl Effect exterior
Automatic
All-wheel Drive
new 2026 BMW X3 car, priced at $55,750
2026 BMW X3
new
Black Sapphire Metallic exterior
Automatic
All-wheel Drive
new 2026 Subaru Forester car, priced at $40,185
2026 Subaru Forester
new
Crystal Black Silica exterior
CVT
All-wheel Drive
new 2026 BMW 840 Gran Coupe car, priced at $99,625
2026 BMW 840 Gran Coupe
new
Dravit Gray Metallic exterior
Automatic
All-wheel Drive
new 2026 Subaru Ascent car, priced at $52,720
2026 Subaru Ascent
new
Silver Metallic exterior
CVT
All-wheel Drive
new 2026 Volkswagen Atlas Cross Sport car, priced at $44,129
2026 Volkswagen Atlas Cross Sport
new
Deep Black Pearl Effect exterior
Automatic
All-wheel Drive