Orlando Casale | Page 4
Service Manager
Mercedes-Benz of Orange County powered by Benzel-Busch
1 Mercedes Way
Harriman, NY 10926
Dealership Experience
9 yrs, 3 mos
Industry Experience
36 yrs, 8 mos
Specialties & Trainings
Career Development and NADA Professional Management Series, Parts and Service
118 Reviews
Write a Review118 Reviews of Orlando Casale
November 10, 2025
Omar was very disrespectful towards me during a 3-way conference call with car shield. He was trying to get my approval to move forward with repairs without giving me the estimated costs of the repairs. conference call with car shield. He was trying to get my approval to move forward with repairs without giving me the estimated costs of the repairs. When I asked for the numbers, Omar was ill-prepared and was then tallying each line item from memory, he completely forgot about one of the items and the representative from car shield pointed it out, which means a pro forma invoice was not generated or any prior calculations done. Whenever I would ask Omar for labor costs or parts costs, he would ignore me and continue with his spiel. At a few intervals got snappy. When I realized he was intentionally ignoring my questions, I started repeating the question, because I wasn’t going to agree with repairs unless I have the numbers. I even asked him if he was okay, whenever the Car Shield rep asked a question he would stop find out and answer immediately. So that told me he knew better, it was just a lack of respect for me. I will never deal with him again, when Scott was my service rep, he was very respectful, clear and responsive. He kept me in the loop, he was never belittling or condescending. If Omar has a problem with other races then he should not be in the service industry…seek help if necessary. But I do not believe Mercedes Benz of Orange County condones this kind of behavior, based on my previous experiences with Scott. I was going to let it go and take my business elsewhere, but the idea that this might not be his first time doing this, it is only right to bring it to someone’s attention. I am personally disappointed in myself for allowing him to make me react in a back and forth manner, because he failed to take responsibility or acknowledge his actions. It was absolutely my worst experience since dealing with your company. More
Other Employees Tagged: Omar Martinez , I left a message or manager of Service and I haven’t received a call back yet.
November 10, 2025
Great dealership with great service/people in general. Overall above and beyond dealership. World class Overall above and beyond dealership. World class More
Other Employees Tagged: Alix Grubbs, Sam Sierra, Laura Carpenter, Reputation Management, Benzel Admin, Omar Martinez, Matt Cannella, Matthew Destefano , Mark Webster
November 08, 2025
Emari was wonderful very knowledgeable and showed me how much I saved buy pre buying the service package. Outgoing and on point. much I saved buy pre buying the service package. Outgoing and on point. More
Other Employees Tagged: Omar Martinez
September 27, 2025
A little bit of a wait but, Omar was polite and a real nice guy and I got to eat bagels and coffee and watch TV in the lounge so all good. Services were performed nicely. nice guy and I got to eat bagels and coffee and watch TV in the lounge so all good. Services were performed nicely. More
Other Employees Tagged: Reputation Management, Benzel Admin, Omar Martinez , Scott Bateman, Scott Cruver, Frankie Devita, Michael Paccione, Mark Webster
September 22, 2025
Everyone at the dealer was very professional and helpful. When i went to pickup the car the receptionist did double duty, welcomed me in an checked me out, which i thought was very helpful. When i went to pickup the car the receptionist did double duty, welcomed me in an checked me out, which i thought was very helpful. More
Other Employees Tagged: Victor Parra Vazquez , Mark Webster
September 20, 2025
Roger Pauletta, Joe (manager) & Orlando Service Manager are fabulous!! I could go to a dealership 15 minutes away. BUT instead I drive 1-1/2 hours to go to MB of Orange County. Their Personnel and service are fabulous!! I could go to a dealership 15 minutes away. BUT instead I drive 1-1/2 hours to go to MB of Orange County. Their Personnel and service dept. can't be beat. Everyone is so friendly, professional & knowledgeable about all things Mercedes ha to offer They should be rewarded! More
Other Employees Tagged: Alix Grubbs, Sam Sierra, Reputation Management, Benzel Admin, Omar Martinez , Scott Bateman, Scott Cruver, Frankie Devita, Mark Webster, Roger Pauletta
September 17, 2025
Organized, professional and prompt. There was no delays. They told me the A service was going to be two to three hours. They were done in that time frame. There was no delays. They told me the A service was going to be two to three hours. They were done in that time frame. More
Other Employees Tagged: Scott Bateman
September 14, 2025
It’s always a pleasure to take the car to Mercedes-Benz. Orange County. Very nice very knowledgeable. my needs and makes everything happen. He’s the best for the past five years I am very happy with the ser Orange County. Very nice very knowledgeable. my needs and makes everything happen. He’s the best for the past five years I am very happy with the service provided. More
Other Employees Tagged: Omar Martinez , Scott Bateman, Scott Cruver, Frankie Devita
August 30, 2025
I reside 8 miles from this dealership and am very pleased that I can depend on all the staff to service my 3 sprinters. that I can depend on all the staff to service my 3 sprinters. More
Other Employees Tagged: Omar Martinez

