Paul comes to The BMW Store with years of experience in automotive sales - selling his first BMW before turning 21! He is one of the most decorated salesmen in the area. Paul has been awarded Profiles in Achievement every year since 2000, four Professional Councils and BMW's highest award, Grand Travel. Paul lives in Mason and enjoys biking and spending time with his twin girls. Paul was a student athlete playing football at both University of Dayton and Miami University. Paul still cheers for the Flyers and the RedHawks. Paul has been with The BMW Store for over 8 years.
Read more585 Reviews
Write a ReviewDealership Experience
16 yrs, 2 mos
Industry Experience
29 yrs, 11 mos
585 Reviews of Paul Kolleck
March 11, 2026
I had an outstanding experience purchasing my BMW X3 from The BMW Store, and I want to specifically recognize three people who made the entire process exceptional: George (Used Car Sales Manager), Paul (my s The BMW Store, and I want to specifically recognize three people who made the entire process exceptional: George (Used Car Sales Manager), Paul (my salesperson), and Jeremy in the service department. From the very beginning, Paul made the buying process easy, transparent, and genuinely enjoyable. He was knowledgeable about the vehicle, patient with my questions, and never made me feel pressured. He made sure everything was clearly explained and took the time to ensure the car was exactly what I was looking for. George, the Used Car Sales Manager, truly went above and beyond. He personally made sure the car was in outstanding condition before delivery. If anything needed attention, he handled it immediately and ensured it was corrected the right way. It was clear that his priority was making sure the vehicle was perfect, not just “good enough.” That level of care and accountability says a lot about the leadership and culture at The BMW Store. I also want to recognize Jeremy in the service department, who made sure the service work was handled smoothly and professionally. Everything that needed to be addressed was taken care of, and the communication throughout the process was excellent. It’s reassuring knowing the service department stands behind the vehicles they sell. The entire experience felt professional, honest, and customer-focused from start to finish. Buying a car can sometimes be stressful, but this team made it smooth and even fun. Because of the way George, Paul, and Jeremy treated me, I will absolutely be buying my future BMWs from The BMW Store, and I will confidently recommend them to friends, family, and colleagues. If you’re looking for a dealership that truly stands behind their vehicles and takes care of their customers, The BMW Store is the place to go. More
Other Employees Tagged: Jemar DuBose, Jeremy Durbin, George Hubbard, Cyndi Bensman
March 03, 2026
Our buying experience at The Bmw Store was great. Paul, Jemar, Susan and Ric were all very nice and helpful. Paul, Jemar, Susan and Ric were all very nice and helpful. More
Other Employees Tagged: Ric Koresky, Susan Ward, Jemar DuBose
February 28, 2026
Paul was extremely easy to work with, he had the car I was interested in out and ready to test drive as soon as we got there. He also called a few days later to check on the car and give me an update on was interested in out and ready to test drive as soon as we got there. He also called a few days later to check on the car and give me an update on a second key that we are waiting for. It's rare to have such a seamless experience at a car dealership. More
Other Employees Tagged: Susan Ward
February 27, 2026
I’ve been working with the Cinci BMW store for years, many of them with Paul. He always provides excellent service, is honest, fair , and friendly! many of them with Paul. He always provides excellent service, is honest, fair , and friendly! More
Other Employees Tagged: Susan Ward
February 13, 2026
Great experience of buying process. Lovely people who make you feel welcome and try to make it easy. This is my 5th BMW purchase across countries and this was by far the best experience Lovely people who make you feel welcome and try to make it easy. This is my 5th BMW purchase across countries and this was by far the best experience More
Other Employees Tagged: Susan Ward, Jemar DuBose
February 01, 2026
Great service by the sales person Paul Kolleck! Good communication by Paul as our vehicle was being delivered. Good communication by Paul as our vehicle was being delivered. More
Other Employees Tagged: Susan Ward
January 22, 2026
Paul Kolleck acted on finding an X3 to lease very quickly in addition to processing my trade-in at a fair price. Susan Ward gave a patient, thorough explanation of the complicated BMW controls at vehicle pic in addition to processing my trade-in at a fair price. Susan Ward gave a patient, thorough explanation of the complicated BMW controls at vehicle pick-up. More
Other Employees Tagged: Susan Ward
January 16, 2026
Paul Kolleck, Sales Person was outstanding throughout this purchase process. After deciding on vehicle, he kept us updated as to status as vehicle was in manufacturing and being delivered to dealership. this purchase process. After deciding on vehicle, he kept us updated as to status as vehicle was in manufacturing and being delivered to dealership. Once it arrived Paul notified us and Jemar, Finance, emailed all paperwork, to streamline the delivery process. When we arrived at the dealership to take delivery, Paul had Susan Ward, BMW Wizard on standby ready to walk through the features of the vehicle. Susan did an excellent job and offered if we have any questions to reach out to her for help! What a truly and amazing experience with dealership. This vehicle is truly The Ultimate Driving Machine as advertised. Respectfully, Jon and Brenda Schmiedebusch More
Other Employees Tagged: Susan Ward, Jemar DuBose
January 12, 2026
We have been customers at the BMW store for 8+ years. They seem to have a better selection than the dealerships where I live. They are reasonable with respect to pricing. We have always worked with Paul They seem to have a better selection than the dealerships where I live. They are reasonable with respect to pricing. We have always worked with Paul and appreciate his responsiveness. Eric, the finance manager and Susan, the “BMW genius” are clear in going over the paperwork and all the tech in the cars, respectively. Even though we are only there an hour or two every few years, they don’t make us feel like strangers. We plan to keep coming back. More
Other Employees Tagged: Ric Koresky, Susan Ward, Eric Fender
January 11, 2026
I had an exceptional experience with Paul. He was knowledgeable, patient, and genuinely invested in helping me get exactly what I wanted. The entire process was seamless thanks to him. I also He was knowledgeable, patient, and genuinely invested in helping me get exactly what I wanted. The entire process was seamless thanks to him. I also want to recognize Susan for her outstanding knowledge, She explained all the car’s functions clearly and made sure I felt completely comfortable using every feature. Truly a great team! More
Other Employees Tagged: Susan Ward

