406 Reviews
Write a Review406 Reviews of Shane Nicely
November 11, 2025
I purchased all my vehicles from Starling. I was very happy until recent events. I went in on Oct. 27th, 2025 to get a routine tire rotation and oil change. Two days later, my tire control arm I was very happy until recent events. I went in on Oct. 27th, 2025 to get a routine tire rotation and oil change. Two days later, my tire control arm failed causing damage to the axle and other components. Luckily I was covered under my warranties. The team was very quick getting me towed and in a loaner. Four days later, I was notified my truck was ready so I went that morning and switched out my vehicle and take my truck to work. When I went to leave work the same day, my tire was flat. They sent a crew to come change my tire out but unfortunately the spare was not the right tire (I purchased this vehicle at 8k miles from starling in 2022). it was disappointing that I am having to go through this but know and feel Starling should own that they damaged my vehicle initially during the routine tire rotation. This damage was mostly likely caused by the lift but I cannot prove it. I plan to continue to use Starling but hope someone from upper management contacts me and hears the full story. More
Other Employees Tagged: Michael Lamar
November 05, 2025
Excellent customer services! ! Great people! Honest, respectful and courteous!! Always a pleasure to work with!! ! Great people! Honest, respectful and courteous!! Always a pleasure to work with!! More
Other Employees Tagged: Kevin Wilson, Michael Lamar, Joey Sarro JR , Mike Kane, Joe Sarro, DAN WARREN, Justin Cohen
November 05, 2025
There staff seem very friendly helpful and willing to accommodate the customer every need. Thanks accommodate the customer every need. Thanks More
Other Employees Tagged: Justin Cohen
October 31, 2025
Shane Nicely made the process from dropping the truck off, keeping me up to date on the progress and timeline, to picking up the vehicle seamless. Outstanding customer service and support. off, keeping me up to date on the progress and timeline, to picking up the vehicle seamless. Outstanding customer service and support. More

