Do not trust Patriot Subaru’s advertised "No Gimmicks" - andrew.rockwood
Do not trust Patriot Subaru’s advertised "No Gimmicks" Lifetime Warranty. My 2019 Ascent failed the Maine State Inspection due to a cracked weld on the front exhaust assembly, a known factory defect documented perfectly under Subaru TSB 09-106-23R.
There is a major bait-and-switch happening here. While a standard exhaust pipe replacement might normally sit outside of powertrain coverage in a generic parts catalog, Subaru Corporate explicitly designated the repair of this specific structural failure under the Powertrain Warranty on page 3 of TSB 09-106-23R. Because Patriot's Lifetime Warranty explicitly states it "duplicates the factory powertrain warranty," this repair is contractually covered.
The level of administrative incompetence here is staggering. On my official invoice from Patriot, the service department actually wrote: "Lifetime powertrain does not apply. There is no exhaust manifold." Yet, on the very next line of the exact same document, their own technician contradicts this entirely, writing: "Technician found exhaust manifold cracked near the flanges ... Exhaust Manifold (All updated parts and gaskets from 09-106-23R please) — $2,047.88." They literally claimed the part didn't exist while trying to charge me over $2,000 to fix it.
Despite this clear diagnostic and the explicit TSB language, Service Manager Paul Hall denied the claim. They opened a claim with the third-party administrator (WiseF&I / Vehicle Service Administrator LLC) but failed to submit the mandatory diagnostic codes to move it forward. When I escalated this severe breach of contract and paperwork failure to the General Manager, David Shoemaker, my emails were completely ignored. I am posting this review after giving them 21 days to respond and work with me, but leadership has chosen to completely cut off communication.
They use third-party administrative loopholes to escape their own advertised promises. Get corporate involved immediately, because local management and leadership at Patriot will completely ghost you to avoid honoring their word.
Read More