![](https://www.dealerrater.com/ncdn/s/11.20240528.717/Graphics/badge-certified-employee-mobile.png)
![Anthony Pilla at Brewster Subaru](https://cdn-user.dealerrater.com/images/dealer/41046/employees/d15629084f50.jpg)
Anthony has been in the auto industry for 19 years. He's a huge Giant's fan so watch out. Unfortunately he also likes the Mets. Don't judge him! He's been happily married for 9 years. In his spare time he plays golf, loves fishing and is an ordained minister for those of you looking to get married.
Read moreDealership Experience
9 yrs, 3 mos
Industry Experience
27 yrs, 11 mos
530 Reviews
Write a Review530 Reviews of Anthony Pilla
May 28, 2017
Excellent customer service and sales dept. No stress buy. Excellent price. Knowledgeable staff. Xxxxxxxxx cxx xxx xxxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xx No stress buy. Excellent price. Knowledgeable staff. Xxxxxxxxx cxx xxx xxxx xxx xxx xxx xxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx xxx xxxx xxxxx xxxx xxxxx xxxxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxx xxxxxx xxxx xxxxx xxxxxx xxxxx xxxxxx xxxxx xxxxx xxxx xxxxx xxxxx More
Other Employees Tagged: Nelson DeMelo, Rich Johnson, Patrick Larson
May 27, 2017
I am very happy with my car and the service that I received My sales rep. Anthony Pilla was beyond great. He has gone out of his way to help me and I cannot say enough good things about him. I will recommend My sales rep. Anthony Pilla was beyond great. He has gone out of his way to help me and I cannot say enough good things about him. I will recommend him to all my contacts. Mr. Pilla is a credit to your corporation, You are lucky to have him. I would rate him as a 12 on a 1-10 scale. He has not just sold me a car and forgotten about me. Anthony has helped me to understand the car's features and gone out of his way to help me. I thank you for having such a good man on your team. If you have any questions about this review please call me at 845 724-3233. Once again I will say you are lucky to have Anthony Pilla as a representative for Subaru. I traded in my Porche for the Subaru and it was the right decision. Without Anthony explaining all the advantages of the Subaru I would have doubts, thanks to him I have none. He is a credit to Brewster Subaru and I truly appreciate him. Hugh Ehrenzweig, 845 724-3233 More
May 22, 2017
Better than expected. When I went to Brewster Subaru I was just looking and really wasn't going to buy a car. Anthony's experience, friending and knowledge made me comforta When I went to Brewster Subaru I was just looking and really wasn't going to buy a car. Anthony's experience, friending and knowledge made me comfortable in knowing I was making the right decision. I left there owning a new Crosstrek and couldn't be happier. I will always recommend Brewster Subaru and to make sure they see Anthony Pilla! More
May 17, 2017
Fantastic No Pressure Dealership I cannot think of enough positive words to explain the experience I had buying my first Subaru from Brewster Subaru, There was such a warm and fuzz I cannot think of enough positive words to explain the experience I had buying my first Subaru from Brewster Subaru, There was such a warm and fuzzy atmosphere there from the time I opened the door. First person I encountered was Anthony Pilla. He greeted me with a sincere hello and we began talking about what I was looking for. A totally compassionate gentleman. The first time I stopped in I was in an emotional mood. He did not pressure me, just took me for a walk outside and pointed out what was available. I explained I was not even sure if I wanted a new car. We went back inside and he offered me beverages, fruit and showed me the waiting area for service. It was such a nice area, very comfortable, free refreshments, large TV .... I was impressed. I explained I needed to decide what I actually was trying to achieve. No pressure, a hand shake and the offer to come back or call at any time. Before I made the final decision I felt I needed to check the pricing with another dealer. It was a large, cold, place and they had only one goal, to sell me a car that day. I received multiple annoying phone calls from them and even from the sales manager as well as e-mails. I KNEW where I wanted the car from and it was not them. I went back a few weeks later and once again, my first encounter was with Anthony. I knew this was where I belonged . I decided on a Subaru Forester Premium. He gave me some numbers, I put a deposit down because they had to bring the car to Brewster from another location. I wanted Jasmine Green Metallic. When I went to get it, it was beautiful. I met many other people at Brewster Subaru and every one was jovial, pleasant and treated me with utmost respect. I felt like they were old time friends I then met Rich Johnson the Business Manager and he was amazing. There was none of the usual tension when you are buying a car. He did not PRESSURE me to get anything I did not want. I felt the entire experience was positive and will recommend them to anyone looking for a car. It was a pleasure to work with a smaller company that did not focus entirely on the sale, they wanted to be sure my decision was what I really wanted. They are sure to be a huge success. More
Other Employees Tagged: Rich Johnson
May 06, 2017
Best car buying experience known to man I purchased my fifth Subaru today from Brewster Subaru, price is always a factor in my decision-making, but the quality, honesty and integrity of the I purchased my fifth Subaru today from Brewster Subaru, price is always a factor in my decision-making, but the quality, honesty and integrity of the entire staff is truly impressive.I have purchased both new and used Subarus. Nelson DeMelo is an extraordinary leader who makes certain that every member of his team values every customer, and it is evident that he values his employees. This is truly unlike any car buying experience you will ever have. Our service person Anthony was knowledgeable,a great listener, patient and goes out of his way to make sure the customer fully understands everything they need to know before, during and after the buying experience. If I could rate this dealership 10 stars I would, I recommend every single person who's looking for a car to Brewster Subaru. the deal you make is the deal you get, More
Other Employees Tagged: Nelson DeMelo
May 01, 2017
Great staff, great car, great experience! Anthony, Rich and the rest of the staff made my used car-buying experience a breeze. Very personable and informative. I'll definitely be back. Anthony, Rich and the rest of the staff made my used car-buying experience a breeze. Very personable and informative. I'll definitely be back. More
Other Employees Tagged: Rich Johnson
May 01, 2017
Great Experience This is my 4th Subaru and my first time dealing with Anthony. He handled the process well and kept me in the loop throughout the process. I expect to This is my 4th Subaru and my first time dealing with Anthony. He handled the process well and kept me in the loop throughout the process. I expect to purchase my 5th Subaru and would only go to Anthony. Rob Ziegelmeier More
April 30, 2017
Friendly and efficient experience This will be my third car that I have purchased from this location. Every experience has been fantastic. All three were purchased with the personal This will be my third car that I have purchased from this location. Every experience has been fantastic. All three were purchased with the personal assistance of one of the managers Nelson. He is professional, confident, and approachable. I noticed how comfortable the staff felt with going to him for anything. Even after service hours he was there to help with a customer needing a loaner car. This time I had the pleasure of working with Anthony Pilla, he was extremely patient, kind and thourough throughout the entire process. The finance manager Rich, wow, I was completely impressed with the time he took with me to go over paperwork, offered me multiple options for continuing my warranty, and had everything handy to show me without any glitches. Very smooth process. On a side note, while Anthony was running around situating my trade in, I was completely impressed of the salesman across from him, I do not know his name but he sat by the door. While waiting I listened to him "sell" someone on a Subaru. The knowledge ran off his tongue like butter. And although I didn't work with him personally I felt he should also be recognized. Bravo Brewster Subaru! More
Other Employees Tagged: Nelson DeMelo , Rich
April 26, 2017
Unbelievable experience. From the minute I walked in the door. Everyone was so nice. Made me feel very comfortable. Not felt pressured into buying anything. Antony went over t From the minute I walked in the door. Everyone was so nice. Made me feel very comfortable. Not felt pressured into buying anything. Antony went over the car in detail before I left the lot. Rich went over all the paperwork with me in detail. The entire process is worth more than 5 star. More
Other Employees Tagged: Rich Johnson
April 17, 2017
Fantastic Service and Price Very friendly and polite dealership. Anthony Pilla worked with me to get the best possible deal for a Subaru Wrx compared to all other neighboring Sub Very friendly and polite dealership. Anthony Pilla worked with me to get the best possible deal for a Subaru Wrx compared to all other neighboring Subaru dealerships. I felt comfortable working out the details with him due to his thoroughness and did not feel pressured at all to make a decision. Highly recommend this dealership and Anthony for anybody looking in the market for a Subaru! More