

Anthony has been in the auto industry for 19 years. He's a huge Giant's fan so watch out. Unfortunately he also likes the Mets. Don't judge him! He's been happily married for 9 years. In his spare time he plays golf, loves fishing and is an ordained minister for those of you looking to get married.
Read moreDealership Experience
6 yrs
Industry Experience
24 yrs, 8 mos
345 Reviews of Anthony Pilla
February 22, 2021
"Great dealership and very easygoing people! Really..."
- Cameronct3Great dealership and very easygoing people! Really appreciate the hospitality and the approach they take when getting a new car or receiving service. I will most definitely continue getting my lease from this dealership.
Read MoreOther Employees Tagged: John Chaber, Rich Johnson
February 06, 2021
"I had a wonderful experience with AnthonyThe experience..."
- mikefitz1069I had a wonderful experience with Anthony The experience was quick and efficient I will definitely recommend the entire group to my friends Thanks Anthony
Read MoreOther Employees Tagged: Rich Johnson
January 29, 2021
"Wonderful people! I had a great experience with Nelson,..."
- VictoriaWonderful people! I had a great experience with Nelson, Anthony & Rich. From start to finish they were kind, helpful, friendly and honest. They made getting into my new Crosstrek exciting and I know I will be in good hands going forward. I will recommend them to everyone!
Read MoreOther Employees Tagged: Nelson DeMelo, Rich Johnson
January 24, 2021
"This was my second time leasing with Brewster Subaru. The..."
- AbeckerThis was my second time leasing with Brewster Subaru. The experience was great both times. Anthony Pilla makes you feel like family and is just so helpful/willing to do the best he can for you. Rich also makes the contract part of the process super easy! Good honest People. Would highly recommend them to anyone looking for a Subaru!
Read MoreOther Employees Tagged: Rich Johnson
January 18, 2021
"Personable, knowledgeable and excellent experience!..."
- bellrock8Personable, knowledgeable and excellent experience! Answered all our questions directly and clearly, no bull. They worked with us quickly and easily to get what we wanted. A refreshing car buying experience ! Both Anthony and Rich took great care of us. Thanks guys! We LOVE our new Outback.
Read MoreOther Employees Tagged: Rich Johnson
December 29, 2020
"My family is now in our third from Brewster Subaru and we..."
- Katie R.My family is now in our third from Brewster Subaru and we wouldn't even think about going to another dealer! Everyone is incredibly friendly and professional, and - unlike any other dealer we've ever been to - there was no pressure at any point in the process. We always feel confident that Anthony, Rich, and the whole team have our best interests at heart and are looking for the best deal for us that fits our budget and our lifestyle. Highly recommended!
Read MoreOther Employees Tagged: Rich Johnson
December 26, 2020
"I don’t usually leave reviews but I am beyond inclined to..."
- jonathangrivera87I don’t usually leave reviews but I am beyond inclined to do so as my experience was that amazing. My husband and I purchased not one but TWO cars with Subaru of Brewster. Initially we went in with the mindset to purchase one vehicle, however, because the experience was so wonderful, smooth and they worked with us so well that we decided to purchase a second Subaru! I have always been very skeptical of car dealerships, especially since I was once burned by one many years ago. However my husband needed a car and I began searching online for dealerships. We knew we wanted a Subaru but wanted to make sure we chose the best dealership for that. Call me corny but I am a review kind of person. I specifically chose Subaru of Brewster because I liked how many positive reviews/stars they had. My husband and I purchased TWO brand new 2021 Subaru’s from sales rep Anthony Pilla. From the second I walked into the dealership I was greeted by everyone, not to mention the place was spotless, such a clean dealership! As I walked further in I instantly gravitated towards sales rep Anthony Pilla. He was so welcoming and extremely friendly. I knew right away I wanted to do business with him. We told him exactly what my husband wanted, from make, year to even color of the Subaru and Anthony both accommodated every need/want and got us into the car we wanted right away. It felt like we knew Anthony for years. I couldn’t believe how well he handled us and how detailed and honest he was. I literally never once felt rushed or like he was trying to get one over on us. He treated us with such respect and such kindness. In fact, Anthony was so awesome to deal with and my husbands whole car buying experience was so great that I decided to trade in my own vehicle and purchase a SECOND 2021 Subaru with him! Anthony was truly the most amazing sales rep I have EVER dealt with. I knew I made the right choice choosing him to be our sales rep! I highly highly recommended him. Upon finalIzing everything we met the General Manager, Nelson who personal introduced himself and sat with us to ask how we were doing and if we needed anything at all to please ask. He worked with us so well and really cared about making us happy. Towards the final steps we then dealt with their finance manager Rich who was so amazing. I could not believe now detailed, thorough and patient he was. He literally took his time and explained EVERYTHING to us. I never once felt rushed or like I was being scammed. (Which is very important). I HIGHLY recommend Subaru of Brewster!!!
Read MoreOther Employees Tagged: Nelson DeMelo, Rich Johnson
December 12, 2020
"Brewster Subaru is above and beyond the best dealership I..."
- ajeanlautureBrewster Subaru is above and beyond the best dealership I have ever worked with. Anthony Pilla is an outstanding sales representative. He is the first person I have ever returned to to get a car from. His attention to detail and knowing the needs of his customers is unlike anything I have experienced before; he is absolutely a top notch sales representative and human being. Anyone who is looking to buy a car or have it serviced should return to Brewster Subaru and asked specifically for Anthony Pilla!!!!
Read MoreOther Employees Tagged: Rich Johnson , Patrick Larson