Mike Nemeth

On Thursday, 6/11/26, I stopped by Castle Hyundai in Downers Grove, Illinois on 6/11/26 in the evening. I looked at 2017 Subaru Outback, and saw that it had a considerable sized dent on the passenger l Downers Grove, Illinois on 6/11/26 in the evening. I looked at 2017 Subaru Outback, and saw that it had a considerable sized dent on the passenger left door, the front bumper had a large crack in it at the front driver’s side, and the bumper was also not properly connecting to the driver’s side headlight and front left ¼ panel. I met a salesman by the name of John Pauly, and also met his Sales Manager, Mike. After negotiations (including running a Car History Report, and included running my credit), we come to an agreement that the car would be repaired (bumper and dent in door), and that if the service department didn’t come back with any other issues, that the car would be sold to me for $14,400 plus fees, and that they would give me a trade in for my vehicle of $3,250 (I have the original paperwork given to me by Michael showing the selling price and trade in price for my car. It also lists the date of this report and the sales person’s name). I then took the car for a drive, and when John and I both heard some grinding noises coming from the front end of the car, both sides. I told him to have the car checked out by his service department, and to let me know what was wrong with the car. As he and Mike had agreed to, that provided they fix what was wrong with the car, I would still purchase it for the same agreed amount. On Friday, 6/12/26, John called me at around 10am, and said that they were about to give the car to the service department, and wanted to know if I was serious about the terms that we had discussed. I said yes, provided that the car checked out with service department with no other issues, and that they fix the car as we had discussed. Later in the day, John texted me back stating that the car didn’t pass service inspection., and that they were going to wholesale the car to an auction. About an hour after John had texted me, I texted him back, and asked what exactly they had found wrong with the car. He texted back stating that they didn’t tell him what was wrong, but that it was not worth keeping it due to too much being wrong with it. This in itself is hard to believe that the sales person does not know what is wrong with a car that he was supposed to sell. So I had my doubts that he was telling me the truth. On Tuesday, 6/16/26, still in the need of a car, and also wanting to see if the car was actually off of the lot, I took a drive back down to Castle Hyundai. Sitting at the front right side of the lot, with the front bumper crack having been fixed, but still not properly connected to the headlight and ¼ panel, and still having the same large dent in the right passenger door, was the car that allegedly was to be wholesaled at an auction. (see attached pictures). On Friday, 6/19/26, I called the dealership and spoke with a sales person by the name of Andy, and asked about the car. He said the exact car that I was referring to and that it was for sale. I told him that I had stopped by earlier in the week and saw that it had a dent in the car door. I asked him if there was anything else wrong with the car, and he said “No.” Later this same afternoon, I went back to check the text messages from John Pauly, and he had erased the texts that he had sent to me stating that they were going to wholesale the car and send it to auction, as well as the one where he said that he was not told by the service department what was wrong with the car. I have proof that 6 texts were sent to and from John Pauly on Saturday, 6/12, from my cellular phone account. Currently only 2 texts are showing in our conversation, in my Messages App, from this date, and those 2 texts are only ones that I sent to John. None of John’s replies are listed anymore. Apparently, he decided to delete them in order to cover his tracks and hide what he told me. And the car sales people wonder why used car sales people get such a bad rap. The disappo More

Report | Print

Absolute garbage dump of a dealer. Sent a request for info about a car, and the dealership called me back and said the car was available, and asked when I could come check it out. I as Sent a request for info about a car, and the dealership called me back and said the car was available, and asked when I could come check it out. I asked them if I drive over there now (40 minutes away), would they promise to not sell it before I got there. They said they would hold it, no problem. So I drove over there at lunch, drove the car, talked to the salesmen, and seemed like a good deal. I asked them for financing numbers and if I could do a PPI on the car at a shop right down the street. They brought me out numbers, and we compared with financing numbers I was getting from my bank, so they went back to check with the finance manager. They then came back and said they COULD match the numbers of the bank, but that their sales manager had taken a deposit from an out of state buyer on the car earlier is that morning and had not told them, and they could not sell me the car. I have purchased MANY cars in my life, Toyotas, BMWs, Audis, Porsches, and I have NEVER experienced incompetence of this level. Complete and utter clown-show, and a absolute waste of time More

Report | Print

Great and fast service! ! Castle always takes great care of me and I will be a forever customer! Thank you Castle team! ! Castle always takes great care of me and I will be a forever customer! Thank you Castle team! More

Report | Print

Purchased a vehicle from here online. It was never disclosed that the vehicle has summer tires. The car was sold in winter. First drive out in winter, blew a tire and broke the rim at a p It was never disclosed that the vehicle has summer tires. The car was sold in winter. First drive out in winter, blew a tire and broke the rim at a pothole. Also, dealership never provided any updates on when the car is shipping or delivery date. Purchased the vehicle back in December 2026. Now in April, still have not received my plaes. More

Report | Print