Dealership Experience
8 yrs, 11 mos
Industry Experience
27 yrs, 11 mos
434 Reviews
Write a Review434 Reviews of Keeley Murphy
February 15, 2026
Probably the best car buying experience I’ve ever experienced! Researching their inventory the night before, I had picked a first and a second choice Forester. When I showed up, all the staff were pl experienced! Researching their inventory the night before, I had picked a first and a second choice Forester. When I showed up, all the staff were pleasant and easy to talk to. They made time to learn about me and my hubby, where we’ve lived and what I liked to do and how I needed the vehicle to work for me (I have a 55# dog—need I say more?). THEN we talked about the vehicles I had chosen. Both were brought for me to test drive (but I only needed my first choice — which was still available). They examined my trade in while out for the test drive, and had everything ready to review when I returned. The offer for my trade in was in line with KBB. The price for the new vehicle was quite competitive. The financing with their incentive program was selected, and paperwork drawn up. None of the “I have to go talk to my manager” nonsense. Then hubby and I were given a tutorial on some of the features and the new Crimson Red Forester came home with us! More
Other Employees Tagged: Brian Fogarty, Travis Philbrook, Ashton Loyd, Dave Winford
February 15, 2026
Everyone was very professional and knowledgeable. I was impressed with the speed and accuracy in getting my new car and gave me a fair trade that I wasn’t expecting. I was impressed with the speed and accuracy in getting my new car and gave me a fair trade that I wasn’t expecting. More
Other Employees Tagged: Ashton Loyd, Dave Winford
February 14, 2026
Daveyon and Keeley were both great to work with. Buying a car out of state has its challenges, and both men were up to the task. They were both went above and beyond to make this a wonderful experi Buying a car out of state has its challenges, and both men were up to the task. They were both went above and beyond to make this a wonderful experience. Communication was quick, thorough professional and pleasant. And when my car was delivered today, it was exactly as it was described. Thank you for everything! More
Other Employees Tagged: Dave Winford
February 08, 2026
This is the 4th Subaru I have leases from them. I have all my services done there and have recommended them to friends that have had bad experiences at other Subaru dealerships. Will be back for th I have all my services done there and have recommended them to friends that have had bad experiences at other Subaru dealerships. Will be back for the next one. More
Other Employees Tagged: Frank Tilghman
January 29, 2026
Everyone was Fantastic from Start to Finish. Very happy with the vehicle, trade, and financing! Very happy with the vehicle, trade, and financing! More
Other Employees Tagged: Adam Burke
January 23, 2026
I had an fantastic experience working with Josh E. From start to finish, he was professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely focused on helping me find the right vehicle—not just making a sale. He to From start to finish, he was professional, knowledgeable, and genuinely focused on helping me find the right vehicle—not just making a sale. He took the time to answer all my questions, explained everything clearly, and made the entire process smooth and stress-free. I never felt pressured, and he's communication and transparency really stood out. If you’re looking for someone honest, patient, and easy to work with, I highly recommend him. Couldn’t be happier with my purchase and the overall experience! More
Other Employees Tagged: Josh Elliott
January 22, 2026
This was my first service and it went well. Very quick which I appreciate. Thanks Very quick which I appreciate. Thanks More
Other Employees Tagged: Frank Tilghman, Aaron Forness, Jacob McMillen
January 21, 2026
I was so pleased with my experience at Randy Marion Subaru. I wanted to look at one car (which I purchased), and they didn't try to push me to consider other choices. Josh was the best kind of salespe Subaru. I wanted to look at one car (which I purchased), and they didn't try to push me to consider other choices. Josh was the best kind of salesperson. He did not pressure me. He wasn't in a hurry. He was very thorough and honest and kind. His approach was for me to have a good experience. I couldn't have asked for a better experience. More
Other Employees Tagged: Josh Elliott , The other Josh who's in training
January 18, 2026
Nice people great to deal with and not pushing like others would buy again Thanks others would buy again Thanks More
Other Employees Tagged: Josh Elliott
Dealership Inventory (211 Vehicles)

