
Michael McKay
New Car Sales Manager
Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati
9101 Colerain Ave
Cincinnati, OH 45251

Dealership Experience
11 yrs, 9 mos
Industry Experience
11 yrs, 9 mos
24 Reviews
Write a Review24 Reviews of Michael McKay
October 05, 2025
Out of all the dealerships we’ve visited, this was by far the most disappointing experience. From start to finish, the interaction lacked professionalism, respect, and basic courtesy. The salesman greeted the most disappointing experience. From start to finish, the interaction lacked professionalism, respect, and basic courtesy. The salesman greeted us late and brought out the wrong vehicle, despite us clearly discussing the correct model beforehand. Once we sat down to review numbers, I mentioned that other dealerships had offered $1,500–$2,000 off MSRP. Rather than addressing that, he asked me to “give him a number.” I replied that I’d like 10% off MSRP — a reasonable starting point for negotiation. His response was to toss me a calculator and tell me to figure it out myself because he was “bad at math.” He then asked me to “fake sign” a paper as a show of commitment — a pointless gesture — before returning with no counteroffer or clear response. When I asked for clarification, he threw out random figures like $500, $600, or $1,200 without explanation, then admitted he didn’t know where those numbers came from. At no point did anyone attempt to respectfully engage in a legitimate negotiation or provide a clear out-the-door price. Our input was ignored repeatedly, and the conversation felt dismissive and unprofessional. When our salesperson took our offer to the sales manager, the manager loudly said, “Man up and sign the paper,” clearly intending for us to overhear it. That kind of behavior is entirely unacceptable in a professional setting. As we decided to leave rather than continue dealing with the games and disrespect, the manager capped things off by calling us “a bunch of xxxx washers.” Every other dealership we visited treated us with honesty and respect — qualities this dealership clearly lacks. More
Other Employees Tagged: Rob Hughes, Ward Day, Dee Wassan
July 01, 2023
Very friendly. Made the process easy and explained everything! We will definitely purchase a car again from them. Made the process easy and explained everything! We will definitely purchase a car again from them. More
Other Employees Tagged: Trevor Robinson , Mike Sipple
June 10, 2023
DuPree was very professional, friendly and was customer service oriented. Will send my friends and family to him. service oriented. Will send my friends and family to him. More
Other Employees Tagged: Trevor Robinson, Dupree Ratchford
May 01, 2023
Luke was very helpful and made whole experience. a pleasure. They bought me a front grill that was.damaged no question aske.when and if I buy another car they will be.my first stop.thank you for a a pleasure. They bought me a front grill that was.damaged no question aske.when and if I buy another car they will be.my first stop.thank you for a great experience. More
Other Employees Tagged: Rob Hughes, Ward Day, Laura Hall, Sandra Pomeraning, Luke Shirley
February 23, 2023
Larry Reed, and the entire Joseph team (Michael McKay, Barry Johnson, Sarah West) provided the best purchase experience I’ve ever had. Larry Reed deserves his own paragraph, being retired military myself Barry Johnson, Sarah West) provided the best purchase experience I’ve ever had. Larry Reed deserves his own paragraph, being retired military myself he delivered & more! I would Highly recommend Joseph Toyota to anyone researching/considering purchasing a vehicle! More
Other Employees Tagged: Ty Brewer , Larry A Reed, Barry Johnson, Sarah West
February 06, 2023
Friendly and helpful staff. Made sure I was taken care of and comfortable with my purchase! Thank you to Larry Reed and Jessica who were a pleasure to work with! Made sure I was taken care of and comfortable with my purchase! Thank you to Larry Reed and Jessica who were a pleasure to work with! More
Other Employees Tagged: Larry A Reed, Jessica (finance)
November 03, 2022
A very good , friendly, courteous representative. Great service minimum wait time.yes I would recommend them to a friend or relative. Great service minimum wait time.yes I would recommend them to a friend or relative. More
Other Employees Tagged: Rob Hughes, Ward Day, Trevor Robinson, Laura Hall, Sandra Pomeraning , Steve Stackhouse

