Michael McKay
Michael McKay at Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati

Michael McKay

New Car Sales Manager

Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati

9101 Colerain Ave
Cincinnati, OH 45251

Contact Me
not yet
rated
25 Reviews

Dealership Experience

12 yrs, 8 mos

Industry Experience

12 yrs, 8 mos

not yet
rated

25 Reviews

Write a Review

25 Reviews of Michael McKay

June 27, 2026

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

BUYER BEWARE! I paid for a brand-new car in full and held up every part of my end of the transaction in good faith. The dealership failed to deliver on the one More

by Daniel Watson
Sales Price Transparency
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
No
Jun 30, 2026

Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati responded

Daniel, thank you for your patience when we corrected the zip code error on the initial sending of your vehicle’s title. We take full responsibility for the error and have remedied the issue as quickly as possible to get the title to you within the expected 45-day period. We apologize for any inconvenience and upset this 43-day arrival may have caused you. Your business is important to us, and we look forward to serving you better in the future. Thank you, Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati

October 05, 2025

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

Out of all the dealerships we’ve visited, this was by far the most disappointing experience. From start to finish, the interaction lacked professionalism, respect, and basic courtesy. The salesman greeted More

by nunya
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
No

Other Employees Tagged: Rob Hughes, Ward Day , Dee Wassan

Oct 06, 2025

Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati responded

This feedback is hard to hear, but I appreciate you bringing it to my attention. We offer our sincere apology for the treatment you experienced. We hope that you were able to find the vehicle you were seeking at the price point you desired. Thank you for stopping in and asking for a quote. Thank you, Sandra Pomeraning - Customer Relations Manager - (513) 385-1800 ext. 8240

Sep 04, 2026

nunya responded

Hi Sandra Pomeraning, I completely forgot to reply! The very next day, we were able to visit a competing Toyota dealership about 35ish minutes away, where they were willing to take 10% off MSRP, something your sales manager had described as unreasonable and even laughable. Your sales manager said "Where did you learn this? From YouTube?" and laughed but the other dealership said: "Let me take this to the manager" and eventually ended up selling the car. What was especially refreshing was that this dealership treated me with respect, had a straightforward conversation with me, and ultimately offered me a discount of a little over 10% to compensate my crappy experience with your dealership. They even mentioned that customers coming from Joseph Toyota have shared similar experiences and just for that, they gave me another $500 off. So, thank you for the horrible experience. In the end, it actually worked out in my favor. I ended up getting a significantly better deal elsewhere, and I didn't even have to travel very far to do it! Oh! And their sales people knew how to do math and didn't toss a calculator at me :) All the best.

July 01, 2023

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

Very friendly. Made the process easy and explained everything! We will definitely purchase a car again from them. More

by paulgallo3717
Sales Price Transparency
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Trevor Robinson , Mike Sipple

Jul 03, 2023

Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati responded

Thank you so much for sharing your 5-star purchasing process with Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati! Have a lovely day!

June 11, 2023

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

DuPree was very professional, friendly and was customer service oriented. Will send my friends and family to him. More

by cindig40
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Jun 12, 2023

Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati responded

Thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts on working with our team. We're glad to hear we delivered such a great experience!

June 08, 2023

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

Great service - knowledgeable staff and facility was well attended. Make (who delivered my car) was extremely helpful. More

by Chris
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Jun 08, 2023

Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati responded

Chris, thank you for choosing Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati for your service. We are thrilled to hear that our knowledgeable staff provided you with great assistance and peace of mind. Safe travels down the road!

May 01, 2023

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

Luke was very helpful and made whole experience. a pleasure. They bought me a front grill that was.damaged no question aske.when and if I buy another car they will be.my first stop.thank you for a More

by rharsley
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes
May 02, 2023

Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati responded

We're thrilled to hear that Luke helped make your whole experience a pleasure, Rharsley! At Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati, we strive to provide excellent customer service and we're delighted to hear you had such a great experience. We're so grateful for your business and hope you love your new front grill!

February 26, 2023

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

All personnel I had interaction with were very friendly, helpful, and accommodating. I would recommend and do business with again. More

by David
Sales Price Transparency
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Tom Platt, Andrew Gray

Feb 27, 2023

Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati responded

Thanks, David, for sharing your thoughts about your experience with Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati. We appreciate your business and hope to see you again soon!

February 23, 2023

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

Larry Reed, and the entire Joseph team (Michael McKay, Barry Johnson, Sarah West) provided the best purchase experience I’ve ever had. Larry Reed deserves his own paragraph, being retired military myself More

by Eagle11
Sales Price Transparency
Trade-in Experience
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Ty Brewer , Larry A Reed, Barry Johnson, Sarah West

Feb 24, 2023

Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati responded

It is fantastic to hear that Larry and the team made your purchasing experience the best you've ever had! Thank you so much for trusting Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati with your business.

February 06, 2023

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

Friendly and helpful staff. Made sure I was taken care of and comfortable with my purchase! Thank you to Larry Reed and Jessica who were a pleasure to work with! More

by katherine.anning
Sales Price Transparency
Purchase Time
Finance Experience
Recommend Dealer
Yes

Other Employees Tagged: Larry A Reed, Jessica (finance)

Feb 06, 2023

Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati responded

Katherine, thank you for the review! We are thrilled to hear that you had a successful purchase experience working with Larry, Jessica, and the Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati team. Drive safely, and we hope to see you back again down the road!

November 04, 2022

Dealership Rating
Employee Rating

A very good , friendly, courteous representative. Great service minimum wait time.yes I would recommend them to a friend or relative. More

by CARLBROWN.SALES
Customer Service
Quality Of Work
Friendliness
Price
Recommend Dealer
Yes
Nov 04, 2022

Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati responded

We're delighted our team offered welcoming and timely service! Your recommendation means a lot to all of us at Joseph Toyota of Cincinnati. Thank you, and safe travels!

1

Dealership Inventory (157 Vehicles)

new 2026 Toyota C-HR car, priced at $42,409
2026 Toyota C-HR
new
Midnight Black Metallic exterior
Automatic
All-wheel Drive
new 2026 Toyota Tundra car, priced at $67,544
2026 Toyota Tundra
new
Celestial Silver Metallic exterior
Automatic
Four-wheel Drive
new 2026 Toyota Crown Signia car, priced at $53,647
2026 Toyota Crown Signia
new
Oxygen White exterior
CVT
All-wheel Drive
new 2026 Toyota Tundra car, priced at $71,784
2026 Toyota Tundra
new
Magnetic Gray Metallic exterior
Automatic
Four-wheel Drive
used 2020 Honda CR-V car, priced at $23,765
2020 Honda CR-V
used
Aegean Blue Metallic exterior
CVT
Front-wheel Drive
used 2019 Honda Pilot car, priced at $20,393
2019 Honda Pilot
used
White Diamond Pearl exterior
Automatic
All-wheel Drive